Technology is a Useful Servant but a Dangerous Master

The saying "technology is a useful servant but a dangerous master" resonates deeply in today's educational landscape ("The Nobel Peace" 29). While technology can enhance our lives and productivity when properly controlled, it can quickly become our master, dictating our behavior and attention. Nowhere is this paradox more evident than in our schools, where cell phones have become both a tool and a threat to learning. Despite their potential benefits, cell phones in educational settings often become the master rather than the servant, creating an environment where learning takes a backseat to digital distractions.

Therefore, cell phones should not be used in schools because they are a significant distraction to students, they enable academic dishonesty through cheating, and they can facilitate cyberbullying.

When technology becomes the master rather than the servant, the first and most critical issue is how cell phones severely disrupt student attention. "'Students persistently use them for a great deal for personal interactions via social media when they should be paying attention to what is going on in class,' according to Connie Fawcett, a high school teacher in Oklahoma (Keima 9). This firsthand observation reveals how these devices have become digital masters, commanding students' attention at will. Social media on cell phones is one of the biggest distractions for students, with the average teenager checking their phone up to 150 times during a school day. The consequences are severe: when students don't learn essential concepts in class because they're enslaved by their phones, they risk compromising their academic success and future opportunities.

Furthermore, when technology shifts from servant to master, it can corrupt academic integrity. "One issue is that camera phones can be used to take photographs of quizzes or exams and transmit them to classmates" (Obringer and Coffey 1). This misuse of technology not only undermines the efforts of students who worked hard studying, but also corrupts the learning process itself. More concerning is how this behavior establishes patterns that can severely impact students' future academic and professional lives, where ethical conduct is paramount. Modern smartphones, with their instant sharing capabilities, have made cheating both effortless and harder to detect - transforming these devices from educational tools into instruments of academic dishonesty. Just as this demonstrates how technology can master ethical behavior, it similarly enables another serious issue: cyberbullying.

Finally, perhaps the darkest example of technology becoming a dangerous master is when cell phones enable cyberbullying. "According to the survey, "46 percent of heavy users experience cyberbullying on their cell phones, a much higher rate compared to just 23 percent of teenagers who are within the 'normal usage' bracket" (Riley 8). These statistics paint a disturbing picture: almost half of students who frequently use phones become victims of cyberbullying, showing how these devices can transform from communication tools into weapons of harassment. Even moderate phone usage correlates with significant cyberbullying rates, potentially leading students down paths of anxiety, depression, and other destructive outcomes. Without strict limitations on phone use in schools, this digital master will continue to enable harassment that follows students beyond school walls. Although this evidence clearly shows the dangers of unrestricted phone use, some argue that phones can serve a positive purpose in education.

Proponents of classroom technology argue that phones can serve as useful tools, particularly for playing music to help students concentrate. However, this argument exemplifies how technology can deceive us into believing it is serving when it is actually mastering our attention. Research challenges this belief: "Two years ago, for example, Peter Bregman wrote in the Harvard Business Review Blog Network that multitasking can reduce productivity by as much as 40%, increase stress and cause a 10-point fall in IQ" (Earl 5). This scientific evidence reveals the true nature of supposed 'background' phone use - rather than serving student focus, it masters their cognitive resources, significantly diminishing their learning capacity. What students perceive as a helpful study aid actually becomes a master of their attention, reducing their academic performance while creating an illusion of productivity.

The wisdom in recognizing that 'technology is a useful servant but a dangerous master' becomes particularly clear in the educational context. Through examining how cell phones serve as distractions, enable academic dishonesty, and facilitate cyberbullying, we see how these devices can shift from potentially useful tools to destructive forces that master student attention and behavior. While modern technology offers numerous benefits outside the classroom, maintaining phone-free educational spaces is crucial for preserving the integrity of learning environments and protecting students' academic and personal development. Only by preventing technology from becoming the master can we ensure it remains the servant of education rather than its destroyer.

Did you like this example?

3543

189