The Trail of Tears: a Complex Legacy

Westward Expansion is a pivotal chapter in the narrative of how the United States evolved into its present form.

Yet, the journey to this point is not merely a tale of triumph and progress; it is also marked by significant injustices, particularly against Native American communities. The process of Westward Expansion is still a matter of controversy in contemporary society, as it involves a deeper exploration of historical facts and statistics that unveil a saga laden with more negatives than positives.

Native Americans hold a vital place in the cultural tapestry of the United States, and their stories and experiences should remain etched in our collective memory.

Historical Context

Today, Native American tribes enjoy a degree of tribal sovereignty and are recognized by the government, a situation starkly different from the 1800s. Before the onset of Westward Expansion, approximately 250,000 Native Americans, representing an array of tribes, inhabited the Great Plains. This land was their home, their cultural and spiritual anchor. However, the insatiable greed of American settlers, driven by a voracious appetite for land and resources such as gold, posed an existential threat to the Native American way of life. In an attempt to protect their lands and people, Native Americans negotiated numerous treaties. Nonetheless, due to rampant governmental corruption, many of these agreements were either ignored or inadequately implemented, with annuity payments often failing to reach the tribes.

The Indian Removal Act

The Indian Removal Act of 1830, a cornerstone of President Andrew Jackson's Indian removal policy, empowered the federal government to forcibly relocate Native American tribes. This legislation, narrowly passed by Congress with a one-vote margin, was met with opposition from various missionary societies. Despite this resistance, the Treaty of New Echota in 1835, which was later repudiated by the Cherokee people, ceded Cherokee lands west of the Mississippi to the U.S. in exchange for $5,000,000. The U.S. Congress ratified this treaty in 1836, providing the Cherokees with a two-year deadline to vacate their lands. During this period, the U.S. Army was already preparing stockades for the impending removal. Between May 1838 and March 1839, approximately 16,000 Cherokees were forcibly rounded up and detained in these stockades, setting the stage for the infamous Trail of Tears.

The Trail of Tears

The Trail of Tears represents the forced and brutal relocation of approximately 100,000 indigenous people, including Cherokee, Creek, Chickasaw, Choctaw, and Seminole tribes, from regions between Michigan, Louisiana, and Florida to lands west of the Mississippi River. Although this exodus involved multiple tribes, it is most closely associated with the Cherokee. The name "Trail of Tears" encapsulates the profound suffering endured by Native Americans during this grueling journey. For the Cherokees and other displaced tribes, it became a cultural memory known as "the trail where they cried." The Seminole tribe, in particular, resisted removal with fierce determination, resulting in costly conflicts for both the U.S. and the Seminoles. Ultimately, in 1835, around 4,000 Seminoles were captured and sent to Indian Territory.

Enduring Hardships

The Trail of Tears was neither a short nor easy trek, encompassing approximately 2,200 miles of land and water routes that spanned nine states. Tribes traveled on foot, by wagon, steamboat, horse, and railroad. Many were not afforded the time to gather their belongings, leaving them ill-equipped to withstand the harsh weather conditions. Under orders from General Winfield Scott, the Cherokees were herded along the trail at a merciless pace, only permitted to stop when their escorts allowed it. The relocation inflicted lasting scars, both physically and culturally, on the tribes involved. The loss of life during this arduous journey left many tribes severely diminished, and the forced assimilation further eroded their cultural identities.

Legacy and Reflection

Although the Trail of Tears occurred two years after Andrew Jackson's presidency, it was his policies that initiated this tragic chapter in history. While some argue that Jackson's intentions may have been to protect Native Americans by assimilating them into American society, history paints a different picture. According to Jackson's statements, he believed that relocation would extend the existence of Native American tribes, albeit in a different form. Yet, the removal process resulted in the loss of their cultural and spiritual connections to their ancestral lands.

Despite the immense hardships they faced, the Trail of Tears has become an integral part of Native American culture and history. The relocation, driven by a combination of fear and a desire for land, was rationalized by settlers as an opportunity to spread their cultural values. However, this forcible assimilation, including sending Native American children to boarding schools and participating in ceremonies like the "last arrow" pageant, stripped away their cultural heritage.

Even before the Trail of Tears, the five tribes—the Cherokee, Choctaw, Seminole, Creek, and Chickasaw—had made efforts to assimilate and embrace European ways of life. This earned them the moniker "The Five Civilized Tribes." While American settlers may have believed they were helping Native Americans by enforcing assimilation, history reveals that their insatiable hunger for land often overshadowed any genuine concern for cultural integration.

In retrospect, while the Trail of Tears represents a profound loss to Native American culture, it also stands as a testament to their resilience. Despite the catastrophic impact of forced relocation, many tribes managed to preserve their identities and continue to thrive today, a testament to their enduring strength and cultural richness.

Did you like this example?

753

40