Why College should not be Free: a Critical Analysis

College dreams clash with economic reality in free education's complex debate. Understanding why college should not be free requires careful examination of its potential consequences on both educational quality and societal structure. Free colleges might seem like a good idea at first glance, but deeper analysis reveals many problems in this system. First, schools have the possibility of being overfilled because so many people would apply to free colleges. Desirable degrees will likely be taken because of so many people getting a free education to get them.

This illustrates a fundamental reason why college should not be free: the system would become overwhelmed and potentially compromise educational quality.

Skill jobs, which are jobs that don't necessarily require a degree, would have fewer people working in that field, and because they don't require a degree, many people would probably have a degree and would not want to "waste" it. Taxes would be a lot higher because America already pays for public schooling, so adding free colleges, which takes a lot more money to run, would be an extremely large amount of money to pay.

Another compelling argument why college should not be free relates to student motivation and academic commitment. Students might take their ability to get a free education less seriously. Overfilling colleges would mean that the job you might get would most likely be taken by other people who want the same job, which would lower your percentage to actually get the job. If a lot of students get degrees, it could possibly lead to a number of workers being inactive during their work, which would be based on their limitations.

If colleges were free, then the education system would be flooded with more people trying to get a degree. Right now, going to college and getting a degree sets you apart from others when you are applying for the job. If everyone got a degree and was going for the same job, then this means that when applying for the job, there are going to be other people with the same level of education applying for the same job.

The economic implications provide further evidence of why college should not be free. With so many people getting the same degree, jobs that do not require a degree such as construction, painting, or other "skill jobs" will have fewer people doing that kind of work, which still makes good money and is necessary. These skill jobs are essential but will hold less interest for people who could otherwise get a degree. Even today, fewer people want to do jobs like construction, painting, landscaping, and other jobs like that, but if they don't do it then who will?

Some colleges might have to create wait lists, because so many people would apply and so many people who had families low in income would not be able to get in, and people who would have enough money to go to a private college would try to get into a free one (if they wanted the things that college was offering). This demonstrates why college should not be free without first addressing fundamental issues of access and capacity. People applying to free colleges might not be able to get in, even if that was the field that that specific college specialized in.

If college was free, schools would be overcrowded. Schools are already overcrowded in most high schools, and as the graduating classes get bigger and bigger, there are going to be more people in college. Many people present this fact with the solution that we should expand our colleges, but the problem with that is that there isn't enough space. The amount of money that it would take to expand to fit more people would be an immense amount of money spent, an immense amount of money that could be used for many other things.

A critical examination of why college should not be free reveals that it could paradoxically hurt those it aims to help. One of the other problems with free college is that it would not help the lower middle class and the poor. The idea of a free college wouldn't provide much additional help to the lowest of society. There are many factors that could come into play when dealing with the overcrowdedness of colleges, and that is just another reason why college should not be free.

While the goal of making higher education more accessible is admirable, the evidence clearly shows why college should not be free in our current system. Instead of implementing universal free college education, we should focus on developing more sustainable solutions to educational accessibility. This might include expanding financial aid programs, developing alternative educational pathways, and creating more targeted assistance for those who need it most. By taking this more nuanced approach, we can address the real challenges of educational access without compromising the quality and value of higher education.

Did you like this example?

861

38