Gender Oppression and Mental Health in the Yellow Wallpaper

Victorian medicine meets patriarchal control with devastating consequences in Gilman's chilling account of a woman's psychological imprisonment. The narrator, suffering from post-partum depression, is subjected to her husband's misguided care, which is emblematic of the patriarchal attitudes prevalent in the 1800s. This essay argues that gender oppression, as portrayed in the story, directly contributes to the mistreatment and deterioration of women's mental health conditions, highlighting the need for empathy and understanding in medical treatments. By examining how male dominance and societal expectations affect women's health, the essay underscores the importance of addressing these issues for better mental health outcomes.

Patriarchal Control and Its Consequences

In Gilman's narrative, the protagonist's husband, John, a physician, embodies the controlling behavior typical of patriarchal societies. His insistence on rest and isolation as treatment reflects a broader societal disregard for women's autonomy and understanding. Mahua Mandal's journal article "Men’s Controlling Behaviors and Women’s Experiences of Physical Violence" provides a framework for understanding these dynamics. Mandal notes that men in patriarchal settings often employ tactics like isolation to maintain control, leading to heightened anxiety and depression in women (Mandal 2). The narrator's experience of being confined to a room, cut off from meaningful interaction, exemplifies how such tactics can aggravate mental health conditions. Her statement, "I cry at nothing, and cry most of the time... And I am alone a good deal just now" (Gilman 7), underscores the emotional toll of isolation, a factor that undoubtedly deepens her depression.

Isolation's Detrimental Effects

Isolation is a critical factor in the narrator's decline, as it is known to have adverse effects on individuals' well-being. Gerit Linneweber's article, "A Simple Computer Vision Pipeline Reveals the Effects of Isolation," confirms that isolation can significantly impact health and exacerbate diseases (Linneweber 4). In "The Yellow Wallpaper," the narrator's descent into hallucinations is symbolized by her fixation on the wallpaper and the imagined figure within it: "The faint figure behind seemed to shake the pattern, just as if she wanted to get out" (Gilman 17). This quote illustrates how prolonged isolation can lead to a breakdown in mental stability, making it clear that the narrator's environment plays a crucial role in her deteriorating mental state.

Understanding Through Empathy

The differences in male and female brain function have been cited as reasons for varying responses to emotional distress. Simon Baron-Cohen's research highlights these differences, suggesting that males may struggle with emotional awareness due to later development of the frontal lobe, which governs emotional expression and empathy (Cohen 3). In "The Yellow Wallpaper," John's inability to empathize with his wife is evident when the narrator observes, "John does not know how much I really suffer. He knows there is no reason to suffer, and that satisfies him" (Gilman 10). This lack of understanding and empathy is a barrier to effective treatment, as it dismisses the legitimacy of the narrator's feelings and experiences.

Gender Dynamics in Medical Care

The disparity in treatment approaches by male and female doctors further highlights the impact of gender on healthcare outcomes. Adam Beaini's article, "Are Male and Female Doctors Really That Different?" reveals that male doctors often work longer hours, which may lead to decreased attentiveness and empathy in patient care (Beaini 1). In the story, John's dual role as husband and doctor results in a conflict of interest, where he fails to treat his wife's condition with the seriousness it deserves. The narrator herself notes, "John is a physician, perhaps that is one reason I do not get well faster" (Gilman 18), suggesting that his professional biases and personal relationship hinder her recovery.

Conclusion

In "The Yellow Wallpaper," gender oppression is intricately linked to the mistreatment of mental health issues, illustrating the detrimental effects of patriarchal control and isolation. The story serves as a cautionary tale about the importance of empathy and understanding in treating mental health conditions, particularly in women. By exploring the limitations imposed by societal norms and the differences in male and female approaches to care, the narrative advocates for a more compassionate and informed perspective on mental health treatment. If the narrator had received appropriate care and empathy, her journey might have been one of healing rather than descent into insanity. This underscores the need for addressing gender biases in healthcare to improve mental health outcomes for all.

Did you like this example?

958

40