The Vital Role of Apoptosis in Developmental Biology

Apoptosis, a fundamental cellular process, enables cells to undergo programmed and organized death.

Introduction

This form of programmed cell death, or PCD, is indispensable for maintaining the stability and equilibrium of living organisms. It is a universal process observed across both vertebrates and invertebrates (Miguel-Aliaga et al., 2009). Understanding "normal" development often involves comparing it against what is considered abnormal, given that PCD has a distinguishable relationship with cell division and differentiation. When these processes fall out of balance, developmental abnormalities may arise.

Cell proliferation, which refers to the increase in cell numbers through growth and division, alongside PCD, ensures the body's homeostasis. Disruption of this delicate balance can jeopardize normal organismal development. Recent research endeavors aim to unravel the role of apoptosis in neurodevelopment and its intricate relationship with it. This essay addresses the significance of apoptosis in prenatal development, provides examples of unregulated apoptosis, and situates apoptosis within the broader context of developmental psychobiology. Furthermore, it discusses the field's importance and implications for understanding human development.

What is Apoptosis?

Apoptosis, synonymous with programmed cell death (PCD), is the process where cells self-destruct by activating an intercellular death program. It occurs during both prenatal and postnatal development, extensively within the developing vertebrate nervous system, particularly during early neural development stages (Miguel-Aliaga et al., 2009). High-density proliferated areas in the developing nervous system are prime sites for PCD (Blaschke et al., 1996). A notable example of PCD is observed in figure 1, where the sculpting of mouse paws during embryonic development mirrors human fetal development. Initially webbed, these paws gain definition as cells between the "fingers" die off (Alberts et al., 2002).

Mechanisms of Apoptosis

Cells undergoing apoptosis follow a structured, orderly process (illustrated in Figure 2). The cell initially shrinks and develops bubble-like blebs on its surface. Concurrently, chromatin condenses, and DNA and organelles fragment into smaller pieces. As the cell membrane blebs, fragments move toward these blebs, forming apoptotic bodies. These bodies emit signals attracting phagocytic immune cells, such as macrophages, which "clean up" by engulfing the cell fragments.

The apoptosis process is driven by caspase proteins, which execute cell death via two distinct pathways. The extrinsic pathway involves external death signals from neighboring cells, binding to the cell's death receptors and connecting to the FAS-associated death domain (FADD). This cascade culminates in caspase activation, leading to apoptosis. Alternatively, the intrinsic pathway is triggered by internal cell damage or lack of survival signals, prompting mitochondrial release into the cytoplasm and initiating the caspase cascade, ultimately leading to apoptosis (Thouvenot-Nitzan, 2016).

Evolutionary Perspectives

Darwin's theory of evolution significantly influenced developmental psychology's formation, bridging biology and psychology. Prior to evolution theory, psychology focused on analyzing the mind's structure. Post-evolution theory, the focus shifted to understanding mental processes' functions (Michel and Moore, 1994). This paradigm shift catalyzed the behaviorist movement, emphasizing observable phenomena over speculative narratives. Before this shift, psychologists lacked empirical means to study development, particularly using children as study subjects (Michel and Moore, 1994).

Preformationism, an early developmental concept, posited that development was nonexistent, with everything prepackaged from inception. This ideology viewed children as miniature adults, lacking distinction from adults. Preformationism was gradually supplanted by predeterminism, which envisaged development as a predestined, organized process occurring in distinct stages (Michel and Moore, 1994). This paradigm fostered an understanding of development as a sequential change over one's lifespan.

Developmental Psychobiology authors note, "Darwin's theory, designed to account for life form diversity, and development within a lifespan, includes changes and continuity. Predeterminist approaches sought evolutionary explanations for individual development" (Michel and Moore, 1994). Embryologist Haeckel proposed that embryos reflect their species' phylogenetic past, encapsulated in the phrase "ontogeny recapitulates phylogeny." Scientists like G. Stanley Hall applied recapitulation theory to human psychological development, observing children's reflexes, instincts, and planned behaviors. Scholars like Jean Piaget and Heinz Werner similarly constructed cognitive development models with distinct early childhood stages (Evans, 2019).

Challenges with Haeckel’s Law

Haeckel's law posited that an individual's development retraces its species' evolutionary history, with embryos reflecting ancestral evolutionary changes (Michel and Moore, 1994). However, Haeckel's law overlooked that while ancestral structures may appear in early embryonic development and disappear later, individual developmental adaptations are proximally adaptive and distinct from evolution (Evans, 2019).

Practical Understanding of Apoptosis

Some researchers propose that apoptosis offers an evolutionary advantage, as complex nervous systems evolved alongside mechanisms to eliminate abnormal or unnecessary cells (Miguel-Aliaga et al., 2009). Studies demonstrate a positive correlation between cell proliferation and PCD across organisms (Miguel-Aliaga et al., 2009). In humans, up to 50% of cells die shortly after creation, compared to 10% in nematode C. elegans (Miguel-Aliaga et al., 2009).

Alcohol, a well-documented teratogen, can cause prenatal deficiencies and complications (Dunty et al., 2001; Prock et al., 2007). Fetal alcohol syndrome (FAS) can induce abnormalities such as mental retardation, attention deficit disorder, and central nervous system (CNS) dysfunction (Dunty et al., 2001; Prock et al., 2007). Previous studies suggest ethanol-induced malformation involves disrupted PCD timing. For example, Dunty et al. (2001) analyzed ethanol exposure in mice during gastrulation, equivalent to human gestation week 6, encompassing crucial morphogenic events like gastrulation, neurulation, and organogenesis. Their study found excessive cell death in crucial cell populations like the neural crest, suggesting cell death as a mechanism for understanding biological discrepancies.

Apoptosis and Developmental Psychobiology

Michel and Moore (1994) highlight developmental psychobiology's interdisciplinary approach, integrating evolutionary and developmental biology with psychology sub-disciplines to address developmental questions and behavior. Understanding development through a single perspective—psychology or biology—provides an incomplete picture. Instead, the interplay between these disciplines reveals developmental nuances and manifestations.

Apoptosis exemplifies developmental psychobiology's importance. Abnormal neuronal loss is increasingly recognized as a pathological feature in neuropsychiatric diseases like Alzheimer's, Parkinson's, Fragile X syndrome, and schizophrenia (Margolis et al., 1994). PCD functions as a biological mechanism potentially leading to developmental and behavioral deficiencies if homeostasis with cell proliferation is not maintained.

Critics view PCD as an evolutionarily preserved regulatory tool. As a process, it can both challenge and support predeterminist thought. Each cell encodes mechanisms for self-destruction. In normal development, specific cells undergo predetermined PCD. However, when exposed to external influences like teratogens, PCD may fail to self-regulate, challenging predeterminism's notion of predestined progression toward a "better" individual (Michel and Moore, 1994). Ultimately, PCD's role in development is fundamental, bridging biology and psychology and offering insights into complex developmental processes.

Did you like this example?

887

37