Understanding Systems Theory through ‘The Breakfast Club’

Introduction

The enduring appeal of John Hughes' iconic film, The Breakfast Club (1985), lies in its exploration of teenage stereotypes and the struggle to transcend them within the microcosm of a high school detention. The film famously begins with the line, "You see us as you want to see us, in the simplest terms, the most convenient definitions," categorizing its characters as a brain, an athlete, a basket case, a princess, and a criminal. This essay delves into how the film illustrates systems theory in a high school context, demonstrating the dynamic interactions and evolving relationships among these seemingly disparate characters.

By examining the communication patterns, stereotypes, and personal revelations depicted in the film, we can gain a deeper understanding of how systems theory operates within human relationships, particularly among adolescents.

Systems Theory: A Framework for Understanding Communication

Systems theory, as defined by Ludwig von Bertalanffy, offers a framework for understanding the interconnectedness and complexity of human interactions. In the realm of communication, this theory posits that individuals interact dynamically over time, shaping their relationships based on core beliefs and experiences. Amy Lang, a telecommunications professor at Indiana University, emphasizes that communication systems are composed of individuals whose attributes and behaviors define the system's structure. These systems are characterized by openness, wholeness, interdependency, feedback, and equifinality, all of which are vividly illustrated in The Breakfast Club.

Stereotypes as Systematic Constructs

The film begins by categorizing the students of Shermer High School into reductive stereotypes, a reflection of how society often simplifies complex individuals into convenient labels. John Bender, labeled the "criminal," is a prime example of how these stereotypes function within a system. His aggressive demeanor and defiance are defense mechanisms against the abuse he suffers at home. Similarly, Andrew Clarke, the "athlete," is pressured by his father to embody toughness and success, even at the cost of his own happiness. These stereotypes, while initially serving as barriers, eventually become the basis for deeper understanding and connection among the characters.

Openness and Wholeness in the High School System

The high school environment depicted in the film is an open system, constantly interacting with its environment and allowing for the exchange of information and experiences. The students, initially resistant to breaking out of their assigned roles, gradually open up to each other, revealing vulnerabilities and shared struggles. This openness is crucial for the development of wholeness within the system, as the characters begin to see themselves as part of a greater whole rather than isolated individuals. The concept of nonsummativity is evident when the students unite to challenge the authority of Mr. Vernon, their detention supervisor. Their collective action demonstrates that the group's strength surpasses the sum of its individual parts.

Feedback and Interdependency

Feedback, both positive and negative, plays a significant role in shaping the students' interactions. Bender's provocative behavior initially receives negative feedback from his peers, who attempt to ignore or silence him. However, as the film progresses, the characters begin to provide positive feedback by acknowledging and validating each other's experiences. This shift in feedback encourages more open and honest communication, breaking down the barriers of their stereotypes. The interdependency among the students becomes apparent as they realize that changes in one individual affect the entire group, ultimately leading to a transformation in their collective dynamic.

Equifinality: Divergent Paths, Shared Goals

The concept of equifinality, where different paths lead to the same outcome, is a central theme in The Breakfast Club. Despite their diverse backgrounds and personal struggles, the characters discover a shared desire to avoid becoming like their parents. This realization serves as a unifying force, transcending the superficial differences that initially divided them. Brian, the "brain," grapples with the pressure to excel academically, while Allison, the "basket case," struggles with feelings of invisibility. Claire, the "princess," and Andrew confront the expectations placed upon them by their families. Through their interactions, the students come to understand that their individual experiences are interconnected, leading them to a common understanding of themselves and each other.

Conclusion

The Breakfast Club remains a powerful exploration of the complexities of human relationships and the systems that both constrain and define them. By applying systems theory to the film, we gain insight into the ways in which communication and interaction shape our understanding of ourselves and others. The characters' journey from isolation to connection exemplifies the principles of openness, wholeness, feedback, and equifinality, highlighting the potential for transformation within a seemingly rigid system. As the students of Shermer High School move beyond their stereotypes, they demonstrate the enduring relevance of systems theory in understanding the intricacies of human behavior and communication. Through this lens, we can appreciate how the film's message continues to resonate with audiences today, offering a timeless reflection on the power of empathy and connection in breaking down societal barriers.

Did you like this example?

329

14