Hopkins and the Duality of Same-Sex Love

Gerard Manley Hopkins, a prominent English poet of the Victorian Era, grappled with the complex interplay between his religious beliefs and his same-sex attractions. Born on July 28, 1844, Hopkins' life was marked by intellectual and emotional turbulence, culminating in his untimely death from typhoid fever on June 8, 1889, in Dublin. His academic journey led him to Oxford, where he studied Classics and earned recognition for his innovative poetic style, ultimately winning a poetry award that paved the way for his college education. It was during his time at Oxford that Hopkins formed a deep attachment to fellow poet Digby Mackworth Dolben, a relationship that profoundly affected him and his subsequent decisions.

Inner Conflict and Suppression

Hopkins' internal struggle with his sexuality was intricately tied to his religious convictions. After Dolben's tragic drowning, Hopkins abandoned poetry and converted to Catholicism, eventually becoming a Jesuit priest in 1868. His poetry, characterized by themes of nature and spirituality, notably in works like "The Wreck of the Deutschland," which recounts the deaths of nuns in a shipwreck, became a private endeavor. This poem, rejected by the Jesuit magazine for its resemblance to the works of Walt Whitman, another homosexual poet, illustrates the societal and religious constraints that stifled Hopkins' creative and personal expression. Despite encouragement from his peers to publish, Hopkins' rejection by a religious publisher deepened his sense of isolation and depression. It was only posthumously, through the efforts of his friend Robert Bridges, that Hopkins' poetry gained public recognition in 1918, as recounted in "Gerard Manley Hopkins" by Charlotte Barrett.

The Struggle in Verse

In poems like "To what serves Mortal Beauty," Hopkins addresses his feelings towards same-sex love. The poem references Saint Gregory the Great and his encounter with two young men, using this narrative to explore the tension between recognizing beauty and adhering to Christian doctrine. Hopkins poses a poignant question about how to respond to such beauty, ultimately suggesting that one must appreciate it without succumbing to physical desire. This conflict is further illustrated in "Where art thou, friend," where Hopkins laments the suppression of his true self, forced to conform outwardly to societal expectations while internally embracing his homosexuality. The recurring theme of suppression permeates Hopkins' work, reflecting his internalized conflict between his religious devotion and his unfulfilled desires.

Stylistic Innovations and Influences

Hopkins' poetry is distinguished by its use of "sprung rhythm," a metrical system he devised that begins with a stressed syllable, allowing for a unique lyrical expression. This innovative style, influenced by Welsh writing and the works of Walt Whitman, set Hopkins apart and contributed to the evolution of free verse poetry in the 20th century. His use of end rhymes and vivid imagery appeals to the senses, creating a powerful emotional resonance. Hopkins' formal and precise language, even when exploring deeply personal themes, invites readers to empathize with his struggles and place themselves in his position. This stylistic approach provides a nuanced lens through which to view Hopkins' internal conflict and the societal pressures of his time.

Victorian Era vs. 21st Century Perspectives

The Victorian Era, characterized by its rigid social norms and moral codes, presented significant challenges for individuals like Hopkins who grappled with their sexuality. Hopkins' depiction of same-sex love, confined to the realm of the mind and spirit, contrasts starkly with contemporary attitudes in the 21st century, where same-sex love is increasingly celebrated and accepted. The rainbow flag, a symbol of LGBTQ+ pride, represents the societal shift towards inclusivity and acceptance, contrasting with the veiled existence that Hopkins and his contemporaries were forced to lead. This evolution in societal attitudes underscores the progression from secrecy to openness and acceptance, highlighting the ongoing journey towards equality and understanding.

Personal Reflections and Broader Implications

Hopkins' poetry, with its profound emotional depth and introspective quality, offers valuable insight into the challenges faced by individuals navigating their identities within restrictive societal frameworks. His work serves as a poignant reminder of the personal cost of suppression and the enduring struggle for authenticity and self-acceptance. The publication of Hopkins' poetry by Bridges not only honored his legacy but also provided a voice for others facing similar struggles, encouraging them to embrace their true identities. In reflecting on Hopkins' life and work, we are reminded of the importance of fostering an inclusive and accepting society, where individuals are free to express their identities without fear of judgment or persecution.

Did you like this example?

885

37