Divine Authority in Greek Mythological Hierarchy

In the intricate tapestry of Greek mythology, the gods often exhibit behaviors and traits that are as multifaceted as they are profound. Among these deities, Poseidon stands out not only for his dominion over the seas, earthquakes, and horses but also for his contentious actions and temperamental nature. My claim is that Poseidon was, in many respects, a problematic figure whose legacy is marred by cruelty and poor judgment. This essay seeks to examine the complexities of Poseidon's character, drawing from various myths and legends to argue that his negative attributes often overshadow his contributions.

Exploitation and Family Dynamics

One of the most troubling aspects of Poseidon's mythological narrative is his exploitation of women, which is vividly illustrated in the story of Medusa. Medusa, initially a beautiful maiden, was transformed into the fearsome Gorgon we know today. This transformation was not due to her own wrongdoing but rather as a consequence of Poseidon's actions. According to the myth, Medusa was violated by Poseidon in Athena's temple, a sacrilegious act that angered the goddess. As punishment, Athena turned Medusa into a creature so hideous that her gaze could turn onlookers to stone. This myth not only highlights Poseidon's disregard for consent and boundaries but also reflects the harsh realities faced by women in ancient stories, who often bore the brunt of divine indiscretions.

Poseidon's inappropriate behavior was not confined to strangers; he also exhibited disturbing tendencies within his own family. His pursuit of Demeter, his own sister, is a testament to his relentless desire for female attention. Despite Demeter's attempts to evade him by transforming into a mare, Poseidon pursued her in the form of a stallion. This union resulted in the birth of two offspring: the horse Arion and the goddess Despoina. Such myths underscore Poseidon's lack of respect for familial and social norms, painting him as a god whose desires often eclipsed moral considerations.

The Battle for Athens and Questionable Intentions

Poseidon's contentious nature is further exemplified in the myth of Athens' patronage. The city of Athens, a beacon of wisdom and culture in ancient Greece, became the arena for a divine contest between Poseidon and Athena. Both gods sought to become the city's protector, and each presented a gift to its inhabitants. Poseidon, wielding his mighty trident, struck the ground and created a well. However, the water was salty and thus unusable for the city's populace. In contrast, Athena offered the olive tree, a symbol of peace and prosperity, which proved far more beneficial. King Cecrops, impressed by Athena's offering, chose her as the city's patron goddess. Poseidon's response was to curse Athens, ensuring it would suffer from water scarcity. This myth not only highlights Poseidon's pettiness and vindictiveness but also contrasts his impulsive nature with Athena's wisdom and foresight.

Poseidon's interactions with mortals also reveal his flawed character. His relentless pursuit of Amphitrite, whom he forced into marriage, stands as a testament to his domineering disposition. Despite her initial reluctance, Amphitrite eventually acquiesced, worn down by Poseidon's insistence. Even after their union, Poseidon's infidelity continued unabated, further illustrating his lack of respect for commitments and relationships.

The Destructive Force of Nature and Divine Retribution

As the god of the sea, Poseidon's influence extended beyond personal interactions to encompass the natural world. His control over the oceans and earthquakes made him a formidable force capable of both creation and destruction. While he contributed to the pantheon by creating the horse and the diverse creatures of the sea, Poseidon's power was often wielded with a capricious hand. His temperamental nature manifested in violent storms, shipwrecks, and earthquakes, causing untold suffering to mortals. The World Health Organization estimates that millions die annually due to water-related issues, a testament to the destructive potential of Poseidon's domain.

A prime example of Poseidon's wrath is found in the Odyssey, where he relentlessly pursued Odysseus, the legendary Greek hero. Angered by Odysseus's blinding of his son, the Cyclops Polyphemus, Poseidon unleashed his fury upon the hero and his men. Despite Odysseus's actions being driven by self-preservation, Poseidon's vindictive pursuit resulted in the destruction of Odysseus's fleet and prolonged his journey home. This myth underscores Poseidon's inability to forgive and his propensity for holding grudges, even at the expense of human lives.

A Complex Legacy

While Poseidon's actions often paint him as a malevolent figure, it is essential to recognize that he was not entirely devoid of virtue. His contributions to the Greek pantheon, such as the creation of the horse and his role in the Trojan War, demonstrate his capacity for creativity and strategic thinking. During the Trojan War, Poseidon sided with the Greeks, motivated by a grudge against the Trojan king Laomedon. His support played a crucial role in the Greeks' eventual victory, showcasing his ability to channel his powers for a cause.

In conclusion, Poseidon's legacy in Greek mythology is one of complexity and contradiction. While he was undoubtedly a powerful and influential deity, his actions often reveal a darker side characterized by cruelty, vindictiveness, and a lack of moral restraint. Despite these flaws, Poseidon's contributions to the pantheon and the natural world cannot be entirely dismissed. Like many figures in mythology, he embodies the duality of human nature, serving as a reminder of the complexities inherent in power and the consequences of unchecked desires.

Did you like this example?

397

21