Queer Identity in Winterson’s Oranges are not the only Fruit

Introduction

Jeanette Winterson's novel, Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit, presents a compelling narrative that explores the complexities of identity, sexuality, and societal norms through the lens of a young girl named Jeanette. Set in a traditional, religious community, the story unfolds across eight chapters, each named after a biblical book, symbolizing Jeanette's journey through her formative years. This essay seeks to examine how the novel illuminates key concepts of "Queer Theory," as outlined by Meg-John Barker in Queer: A Graphic History.

Through this analysis, we will explore how Winterson challenges traditional gender roles and societal expectations, using the character of Jeanette to question and subvert the notion of a fixed identity, thereby offering a rich tapestry of themes that resonate with modern discussions around gender and sexuality.

Challenging Traditional Gender Roles

Since the dawn of human civilization, rigid gender roles have dictated the behaviors and expectations of individuals. These roles are often perpetuated through societal norms, such as assigning leadership to men, as exemplified by the biblical figure Adam, and prescribing toys and clothing based on gender. In Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit, Jeanette's mother epitomizes this traditional mindset, attempting to mold her daughter into a replica of herself, adhering strictly to heterosexual norms. She perceives the world in binary terms, lacking an understanding of mixed feelings or identities, as Winterson illustrates: "She had never heard of mixed feelings. There were friends and there were enemies" (Winterson, Pg. 1).

Judith Butler's concept of the "Heterosexual Matrix," as discussed in Barker's work, is particularly relevant here. Butler argues that society naturally constructs norms that exclude alternative ways of living. This is evident when Jeanette's mother insists on Jeanette wearing a pink raincoat, a color culturally associated with femininity. Jeanette's discomfort with this choice highlights her internal conflict and the societal pressure to conform: "The unknowns of my needs frighten me. I do not know how huge they are, or how high they are, I only know that they are not being met" (Winterson, Pg. 170). Butler's theory underscores the arbitrary nature of gender roles, suggesting that identities are not inherently binary or static but are shaped by historical and cultural contexts.

Fairy Tales and Identity

Winterson cleverly employs fairy tales throughout the novel to mirror Jeanette's experiences and emotions, further queering the text. In one such tale, the story of Winnet Stonejar and the Wizard allegorically parallels Jeanette's life. Winnet's journey, which involves being manipulated by a sorcerer and facing rejection for her love, echoes Jeanette's struggle against her mother's rigid beliefs. The metaphor of the orange in the title, representing a singular view of gender or sexuality, reflects Jeanette's mother's insistence on conformity. When Jeanette is expelled from her home after her mother discovers her lesbian identity, it epitomizes the societal control over individual identity, a theme central to Monique Wittig's concept of "The Straight Mind."

Wittig argues that gender and sexuality are so intertwined that understanding them within a heterosexual context marginalizes non-heteronormative identities. This is poignantly illustrated when Jeanette reflects on her identity: "This was clearly not true. At that point I had no notion of sexual politics, but I knew that a homosexual is further from a woman than a rhinoceros" (Winterson, Pg. 129). Through these narratives, Winterson critiques the constructed nature of gender roles and asserts that identities are fluid and multifaceted.

The Relevance of Queer Theory

The application of Queer Theory in Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit extends beyond LGBTQ+ issues to encompass the broader concept of queerness itself. Throughout the novel, Jeanette grapples with finding a path to personal happiness, often feeling alienated from the dominant cultural norms. Her unique perspective challenges the binary understanding of gender, as she navigates a world that doesn't readily accept her identity. This aligns with Queer Theory's emphasis on deconstructing traditional notions of identity and embracing the diversity of human experiences.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Jeanette Winterson's Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit provides a profound exploration of identity and societal norms through the lens of Queer Theory. The novel's critique of traditional gender roles, its use of allegorical fairy tales, and its challenge to the heterosexual matrix illuminate the complexities of identity formation. By examining Jeanette's journey, Winterson offers a nuanced portrayal of queerness, advocating for a more inclusive and fluid understanding of identity. This analysis not only highlights the relevance of Queer Theory in literature but also underscores the ongoing struggle for acceptance and self-discovery in the face of societal expectations.

Did you like this example?

936

49