Patriarchy and Inequality in Hills Like White Elephants

Gender roles clash beneath Spanish skies as Hemingway exposes how patriarchal pressure shapes the destiny of two lives over afternoon drinks. Set against a seemingly mundane backdrop, the narrative unfolds an intense conversation between a man and a woman grappling with a life-altering decision: whether or not to proceed with an abortion. Through the subtle interplay of dialogue and symbolism, Hemingway crafts a narrative that challenges the societal norms of his time, presenting a woman who ultimately asserts her own agency.

Patriarchal Manipulation

Throughout the story, the American man exemplifies patriarchal dominance through his attempts to manipulate the woman, Jig, into agreeing with his perspective on the pregnancy. His insistence that “I don’t want anyone else but you” (Hemingway, 638) is a strategic attempt to persuade Jig by appealing to her emotions and fears of losing him. This manipulation underscores the power imbalance in their relationship, where the male figure exerts control over the female's autonomy. The man's repeated assurances that the abortion is “perfectly simple” and akin to “letting air in” (Hemingway, 636) aim to trivialize the procedure, thereby dismissing Jig’s legitimate concerns and emotions. His persistent pressure highlights the pervasive patriarchal belief that men have the right to make decisions about women’s bodies, reducing women's roles to mere compliance with male desires.

Jig, however, gradually becomes aware of this manipulation and begins to assert her own voice. Initially engaging in small talk to deflect the conversation, she eventually confronts the American by asking him to “please please please please please please please stop talking” (Hemingway, 638). This plea marks a pivotal moment of resistance, where Jig challenges the patriarchal narrative and demands respect for her autonomy. Her insistence on silence is not merely a request for peace but a powerful assertion of her right to make decisions concerning her own body, thus subverting the traditional power dynamics at play.

Female Agency and Power

Jig’s journey toward autonomy is central to the narrative’s exploration of gender roles and the struggle for female empowerment. While the physical burden of pregnancy grants her the ultimate power in deciding the fate of her unborn child, the psychological struggle to assert this power against societal and relational pressures is profound. The American’s continuous attempts to dominate the conversation underscore the societal expectation for women to conform to male decisions. However, Jig’s eventual demand for silence and her threat to “scream” (Hemingway, 638) if the American continues to speak, signify her reclaiming of agency. This act of defiance is not just a personal victory but a broader statement on the power dynamics between genders, illustrating that women can and should have control over their own bodies and lives.

Moreover, Jig’s decision to speak up and assert her needs challenges traditional gender roles that often depict women as passive or submissive. Her actions reflect a broader feminist narrative that advocates for women's right to self-determination. By resisting the American’s pressure and asserting her own voice, Jig not only defies the patriarchal expectations placed upon her but also embodies a sense of liberation and empowerment. This transformation from a passive participant in the conversation to an active decision-maker highlights the potential for women to break free from the constraints of gender inequality and assert their autonomy.

Gender Roles and Inequality

The narrative also delves into the broader theme of gender inequality, as evidenced by the differing ways the characters are portrayed and addressed. The American man is consistently referred to by his nationality, lending him a sense of identity and authority, while Jig is simply “the girl,” a term that diminishes her presence and individuality. This distinction underscores the societal tendency to prioritize male voices and perspectives, relegating women to the background and denying them a distinct identity.

The imbalance is further emphasized by the American’s focus on his own desires and his disregard for Jig’s feelings. His relentless pursuit of the abortion reflects a self-centered worldview, where the woman's needs and emotions are secondary to his own convenience. This dynamic symbolizes the broader societal issue of male dominance, where women’s voices are often marginalized, and their choices are dictated by male authority.

Despite these challenges, Jig’s ultimate refusal to be silenced or coerced represents a powerful critique of gender inequality. Her journey toward self-assertion and the recognition of her own worth challenges the traditional gender roles that have long restricted women’s autonomy. By standing up to the American and making her own choice, Jig embodies the potential for women to transcend societal constraints and claim their rightful place as equal participants in their own lives.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Ernest Hemingway’s “Hills Like White Elephants” offers a poignant exploration of patriarchy and gender inequality through the lens of a couple’s conversation about abortion. Jig’s journey from manipulation to self-assertion highlights the struggle for female agency in a patriarchal society. By challenging the American’s dominance and asserting her own voice, Jig defies traditional gender roles and underscores the importance of women’s autonomy. While the story leaves the outcome of her decision ambiguous, it ultimately emphasizes the significance of individual choice and the potential for women to break free from societal constraints. Through Jig’s narrative, Hemingway not only critiques the patriarchal norms of his time but also advocates for a more equitable and empowering vision of gender relations.

Did you like this example?

531

28