Gender in American Healthcare

Social constructs are deeply embedded in the everyday lives of individuals across the globe, influencing everything from cultural norms to gender roles. These constructs can vary widely among different societies, often impacting the opportunities and expectations placed upon individuals. Women, in particular, have historically faced significant challenges in achieving equality with men, despite decades of progress. From the women's suffrage movement of the 1800s to the present day, women have fought tirelessly for the right to vote, own property, and attain independence.

Yet, even now, gender disparities persist, particularly in traditionally male-dominated fields like medicine. This essay will explore the intricate web of gender roles in American medicine, examining how societal norms and expectations shape the experiences of women in this field.

Sociological Perspectives on Gender Roles

Occupational segregation, or the division of labor based on characteristics like gender, is a pervasive issue in many professions, including medicine. Judith Lorber, a prominent sociologist specializing in gender studies, describes the phenomenon of women in the medical system being "ghettoized." This term refers to the confinement of women to lower-ranking positions within the medical hierarchy due, in part, to limited opportunities for advancement. In her work "Paradoxes of Gender" (1995), Lorber highlights the systemic barriers that women face in pursuing higher positions within the medical profession.

Susan Hinze, a medical sociologist, has also contributed significantly to the understanding of gender dynamics in medicine. Her research, "Gender and the Body of Medicine or At Least Some Body Parts" (1999), delves into the perceptions of physicians regarding the medical hierarchy and gender roles. Physicians acknowledge the existence of a hierarchy based on prestige, but women are more likely to resist this notion. Hinze's study reveals that medicine is institutionalized by symbolic bodies, with higher prestige associated with qualities like machismo and action-orientation, while lower prestige is linked to passivity and less physical engagement.

In the 1960s, women constituted a mere 5% of medical students, a figure that grew to 42% by 1993. However, as more women entered the medical field and began specializing, a wage gap emerged between specialists and primary care physicians. Hinze cites three explanations for this trend: the "social roles perspective," which suggests women choose less demanding specialties due to family responsibilities; the "cultural feminist perspective," which emphasizes women's desire for a holistic approach to medicine; and the "liberal feminist perspective," which highlights discrimination and deterrents faced by women. While these factors affect both men and women, the emphasis on prestige and interventionist specialties often pressures women to conform to a male-defined hierarchy.

Anthropological Insights into Gender Dynamics

Anthropology offers a unique lens through which to examine gender roles in medicine, providing a holistic understanding of cultural influences. Joan Cassell, an anthropologist at Harvard University, explores the experiences of women in the male-dominated world of surgery in her work "Doing Gender, Doing Surgery: Women Surgeons in a Man’s Profession." She highlights the stereotypical gender differences that persist in the medical field, with women perceived as nurturing and men as competitive and detached.

Despite the increase in female surgeons from the 1970s to 1993, women continue to face challenges in integrating into this "men's club." Female surgeons often feel isolated from professional networks and pressured to conform to gender-stereotyped roles. They must balance assertiveness with femininity, walking a fine line between being perceived as competent and being labeled as difficult to work with.

Cassell's research underscores the importance of examining gender roles cross-culturally to gain a deeper understanding of how societies construct and perpetuate these roles. Anthropologists emphasize that gender is not a fixed classification based solely on biological criteria but a socio-cultural construct that varies across cultures. This perspective sheds light on the historical male dominance in the medical field and the evolving roles of women as they strive to break free from traditional constraints.

The Influence of Cultural Norms on Medicine

The influence of cultural norms on gender roles in medicine is evident when comparing Western biomedicine to traditional healing practices. In many traditional medical systems, women can hold positions of authority, such as shamans, and are respected as equals. However, Western medicine often perpetuates gender biases through its language and practices. Terms like "activity vs. passivity" and "fixing vs. maintaining" reflect underlying societal values that associate masculinity with dominance and femininity with subservience.

The biomedical model, which emphasizes aggressive intervention and the treatment of symptoms, is often linked to masculine qualities. This association influences the perception and status of different medical specialties. For example, surgery, characterized by its invasive and hands-on nature, is considered a prestigious and masculine field, while specialties like family medicine are viewed as less prestigious and more feminine.

Howard Stein, a medical anthropologist, highlights the compartmentalization of clinical roles, knowledge, and skills according to culturally ingrained gender categories. This compartmentalization reinforces existing gender biases and shapes the experiences of women in the medical field.

The Beauty Myth and Gender Expectations

The concept of beauty and its impact on gender roles is another significant aspect of the discussion. Naomi Wolf, a feminist author, explores the relationship between beauty and female identity in her book "The Beauty Myth." She argues that societal expectations of female beauty are not merely about aesthetics but about control and obedience. The notion that "pain is beauty" reflects deeply ingrained cultural beliefs that have affected women's emotional and physical well-being for generations.

Wolf's analysis reveals how the medical field, particularly cosmetic surgery, has capitalized on these beauty standards. The rise of cosmetic surgery can be seen as a modern extension of historical practices that pathologized female experiences, such as hysteria in the 19th century. As more women enter the medical profession and challenge traditional gender roles, the field of cosmetic surgery continues to thrive, perpetuating ideals of beauty that reinforce societal norms.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the interplay between gender roles and the medical profession is a complex and multifaceted issue. From the sociological perspectives of occupational segregation and prestige hierarchies to the anthropological insights into cultural norms and gender expectations, it is clear that women in medicine face unique challenges. These challenges are rooted in historical and cultural constructs that continue to shape the experiences of women in this field. By examining these dynamics through a multidisciplinary lens, we gain a deeper understanding of the barriers women encounter and the progress they have made in challenging traditional gender roles. As society continues to evolve, it is essential to recognize and address these issues to create a more equitable and inclusive medical profession for all.

Did you like this example?

593

25