Exploring Philosophical Ideas in the Netflix Movie “13th”

The Netflix documentary “13th” catapults viewers into a realm where historical injustices collide with contemporary struggles, unraveling a narrative deeply intertwined with philosophical ideas. Directed by Ava DuVernay, the film delves into the complex legacy of the 13th Amendment to the United States Constitution and its ramifications on the African American community. As the lens of the camera captures the harsh realities of systemic racism, mass incarceration, and the commodification of human lives, it prompts a reflection on philosophical concepts that underpin these issues.

At its core, “13th” interrogates the notion of freedom and its elusive nature within the context of racial inequality. The 13th Amendment, while ostensibly abolishing slavery, contains a loophole – “except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted.” This exception becomes a fulcrum for the documentary’s exploration of the prison-industrial complex. Philosophically, it raises questions about the true nature of freedom. Can one truly be considered free if their liberties can be curtailed through the criminalization of their existence? The film prompts viewers to ponder whether the veneer of freedom can mask a more insidious form of oppression.

The documentary also engages with the concept of justice and its application within a racially biased system. Philosophical ideals of justice, fairness, and equity come under scrutiny as the film dissects the disproportionate incarceration of Black individuals. The juxtaposition of harsh sentencing for minor offenses within Black communities with lenient responses to similar infractions in predominantly white neighborhoods lays bare the systemic injustices ingrained in the criminal justice system. Viewers are compelled to question the very foundations of justice – is it truly blind, or is it, as “13th” suggests, an instrument wielded with bias and prejudice?

Additionally, “13th” delves into the idea of power and its manifestation within institutions. Philosophers throughout history, from Foucault to Fanon, have explored the dynamics of power and its impact on individuals and communities. The documentary scrutinizes how power is wielded through the criminalization of Blackness, with historical echoes of the post-Civil War era’s convict leasing system reverberating through the decades. It prompts a reflection on the enduring nature of power structures and the ways in which they adapt and persist over time.

A profound philosophical question raised by “13th” revolves around the concept of identity. The film elucidates how the criminalization of Black individuals has been woven into the fabric of American identity. From the era of slavery to the present, the dehumanization of Black bodies for economic gain has persisted. This raises existential questions about the nature of identity – who gets to define it, and how is it shaped by systems of oppression? “13th” challenges viewers to grapple with the uncomfortable reality that the devaluation of Black lives has been a recurrent theme in the construction of American identity.

In conclusion, “13th” transcends its role as a documentary; it emerges as a philosophical inquiry into the complexities of freedom, justice, power, and identity. By intertwining historical narratives with contemporary realities, the film invites viewers to engage with profound questions that resonate far beyond the screen. As the credits roll, the philosophical echoes of “13th” linger, prompting a deeper examination of the structures that shape our society and the enduring philosophical questions that underscore the quest for a more just and equitable world.

Did you like this example?

284

15