Symbolic Patterns in Hemingway Literature

Spanish hills cast elephant-shaped shadows over a railway station where two lovers dance around unspoken truths in Hemingway's masterpiece of subtle tension. Set in a train station amidst the barren Spanish landscape, the narrative delves into a conversation that subtly revolves around an unspoken topic: Jig's pregnancy and the American's desire for her to have an abortion. Through a careful examination of the story's symbolism, this essay will demonstrate how Hemingway conveys the underlying themes of choice, communication, and the inherent tension in their relationship.

By analyzing the symbolic elements such as the hills, drinks, and the conversation itself, we can gain a deeper understanding of the characters' internal struggles and the story's broader implications.

The Symbolism of the Hills

The title "Hills Like White Elephants" serves as an entry point into Hemingway's intricate use of symbolism. On the surface, the hills represent the physical landscape surrounding the train station, but they also symbolize Jig's pregnancy. The comparison between the hills and white elephants is significant; white elephants are often considered burdensome gifts, reflecting how the pregnancy is perceived by the characters. When Jig observes the hills and comments, "They look like white elephants," she is not only noticing the geographical feature but also alluding to the life-changing decision she faces. The hills, with their stark white appearance against the dry, brown country, symbolize the contrast between Jig's potential new life as a mother and the barren state of her current relationship with the American. This dichotomy highlights the tension between hope and despair, choice and coercion.

The Role of Alcohol

Alcohol, specifically beer, is another symbol that Hemingway uses to underscore the couple's fraught relationship. The American's casual ordering of "dos cervezas" suggests his disregard for the gravity of the situation. His focus on drinking implies a desire to escape reality and avoid confronting the emotional weight of Jig's pregnancy. Jig's remark, "That's all we do, isn't it—look at things and try new drinks?" underscores the superficial nature of their relationship, which seems to lack depth and genuine connection. By using alcohol as a metaphor for avoidance, Hemingway criticizes the American's superficial approach to the situation and his reluctance to engage in meaningful dialogue about their future.

Dialogue and Tension

The dialogue between Jig and the American is rife with subtext and unspoken tension. The American's repetitive assurance, "I don’t want you to do it if you don’t want to," is a half-hearted attempt to appear supportive while subtly pressuring Jig to comply with his wishes. His trivialization of the abortion as "an awfully simple operation" further reveals his insensitivity to Jig's feelings and the potential consequences of the procedure. At the time Hemingway wrote this story, abortion was illegal in Spain, making the American's insistence even more problematic. This historical context highlights the societal constraints that further complicate Jig's decision, emphasizing her isolation and the American's disregard for her autonomy.

The Implications of Their Decision

As the story progresses, the characters' internal conflicts become increasingly apparent. Jig's contemplation of the beads from the curtain, a moment of introspection, signifies her awareness of the irreversible change her decision will bring. The American's actions, such as moving the luggage to the other side of the station, suggest a tentative resolution, but they also underscore the uncertainty of their future. The approaching train, symbolizing the passage of time and the inevitability of choice, looms large over their interaction.

The story's conclusion remains ambiguous, leaving readers to ponder the outcome of Jig and the American's relationship. Jig's enigmatic smile, which could indicate resignation, acceptance, or defiance, adds to the story's complexity. Whether she chooses to have the abortion or not, it is clear that their relationship will never return to its previous state. The dissolution of their partnership is hinted at through the American's solitary drink and his uneasy anticipation of the future.

Conclusion: The Power of Hemingway's Subtlety

In "Hills Like White Elephants," Hemingway employs a masterful use of symbolism to explore themes of choice, communication, and the complexities of human relationships. Through the imagery of the hills, the motif of alcohol, and the charged dialogue between Jig and the American, he crafts a narrative that speaks volumes about the characters' internal struggles and the broader societal issues surrounding them. By leaving the story's resolution open to interpretation, Hemingway invites readers to engage with the text on a deeper level, encouraging reflection on the nature of choice and the consequences of our actions. Ultimately, the story serves as a poignant reminder of the power of subtlety in literature and the enduring impact of Hemingway's storytelling.

Did you like this example?

1051

55