Good and Evil: Symbolism in Hawthorne’s ‘Young Goodman Brown’

Faith's foundations crumble in Salem's shadows as Young Goodman Brown discovers evil lurking behind virtuous masks. Through rich symbolism, Hawthorne explores the enduring conflict between good and evil, crafting a narrative that follows an ordinary man's journey from innocence into the darkness of evil. This story delves into societal corruption, the absence of personal moral choices, and an encounter with the devil himself.

While the story concludes ambiguously, the uncertainty surrounding Goodman Brown’s encounter with the devil—whether it was reality or fantasy—suggests that he experiences corruption either in the external world or within his own thoughts.

The theme of good versus evil is reinforced by the protagonist and his wife's names, Faith's pink ribbons, and the story's setting.

The protagonist’s name, Young Goodman Brown, significantly contributes to the story's central theme. The name Goodman is a play on words, suggesting "good man," yet it is laced with irony. While Goodman Brown initially appears as an innocent, godly man, the story reveals a deeper, more complex character. In Robert W. Cochran's scholarly article, "How Young Goodman Brown Became Old Badman Brown," he argues that Goodman was never truly a "good man" as he willingly chooses to leave his Faith (154). As Goodman’s journey progresses, he becomes increasingly entangled in evil, symbolizing the corruption of the "good man." Despite presenting himself as a virtuous individual, Goodman Brown is quick to abandon his moral and religious beliefs when he sees respected figures like his father, grandfather, Goody Cloyse, Deacon Gookin, and even his wife on the devil’s side. This irony in Goodman Brown's name reflects the broader theme of deception within the community, where appearances often mask a darker reality.

Faith, Goodman Brown’s wife, further develops the Good vs. Evil theme. Her name symbolizes the faith Goodman carries, both in his wife and his religious beliefs. At the beginning of the story, Goodman leaves his wife, claiming that after this night, he will remain by her side forever: "She’s a blessed angel on earth; and after this one night, I’ll cling to her skirts and follow her to Heaven" (Hawthorne 7). However, as Faith’s physical presence fades, so too does Goodman’s personal faith. Paul J. Hurley, in his article "Young Goodman Brown’s ‘Heart of Darkness’," highlights how Goodman’s departure from Faith signifies the beginning of his loss of religious faith (412). Goodman’s internal struggle, as he laments leaving his wife for the errand, further underscores his moral conflict: "What a wretch am I, to leave her on such an errand!" (Hawthorne 7). Despite his initial acknowledgment that Faith held him back, Goodman ultimately continues on his journey, displaying his faltering faith.

Faith’s pink ribbons add another layer of symbolism to the narrative, representing innocence and purity. Hawthorne describes Faith as a cheerful, innocent woman, and her pink ribbons enhance this image. The color pink is traditionally associated with modesty and innocence, often linked to young girls and their attire. Ribbons, too, symbolize delicacy and purity. As the story unfolds and Goodman encounters the devil, he witnesses Faith’s pink ribbons fluttering down from the sky, symbolizing her loss of innocence. Paul W. Miller, in "Hawthorne’s ‘Young Goodman Brown’: Cynicism or Meliorism?" emphasizes that the sight of the ribbons signifies Faith’s corruption and abandonment of innocence (260). When Goodman sees the ribbons, he realizes his perception of Faith as pure and modest is shattered, as she too is implicated in the same sins he is committing.

The setting of "Young Goodman Brown" in Salem, Massachusetts, during the Puritan era, reinforces the Good vs. Evil theme. Salem is infamous for its witch trials, and the characters’ encounters with the devil suggest a parallel to these historical events. In Fannye N. Cherry’s article, "The Sources of Hawthorne’s ‘Young Goodman Brown’," she discusses the possibility that the characters Goodman sees at the devil’s encounter are, like those accused in the witch trials, leading double lives—respectable during the day and sinister at night (345). The fact that Goodman’s community does not acknowledge the night’s events the following day supports this interpretation, suggesting they may be hiding their involvement in such activities. This duality mirrors the historical context of the Salem witch trials, where individuals were often accused of consorting with the devil.

The narrative of Goodman Brown is unsettling, focusing on the theme of Good vs. Evil by highlighting symbolism that illustrates a personal loss of innocence. The irony of Goodman Brown’s name reveals the disparity between his outward appearance and inner reality. Faith’s name and her pink ribbons further symbolize the loss of innocence and religious faith. The setting in Salem provides a historical backdrop that enriches the narrative, drawing parallels to the witch trials and the theme of hidden evil within a seemingly pious community.

In conclusion, "Young Goodman Brown" by Nathaniel Hawthorne is a complex tale that examines the loss of innocence and the struggle between good and evil through rich symbolism and historical context. The narrative challenges readers to consider their own moral choices and the potential for corruption within themselves and society. It questions how far curiosity can lead one into darkness, leaving the interpretation of Goodman Brown’s journey open to reflection on the nature of human morality. By addressing the structural and thematic elements more cohesively, this analysis provides a comprehensive exploration of the symbolism in Hawthorne’s work, offering insights into the timeless conflict between good and evil.

Did you like this example?

563

30