Why Recess is Bad: the Impact of Recess on Student Well-Being

Introduction

Recess in school is a topic that has sparked considerable debate among educators, parents, and policymakers. While some argue that it takes away from valuable instructional time, the benefits of recess are substantial and multifaceted. This essay argues that children of all ages should have recess at least once a day. Recess not only enhances focus and academic performance but also provides essential exercise and supports mental health. By allowing students a break from the rigors of classroom learning, recess can significantly contribute to a well-rounded educational experience.

Enhancing Focus and Academic Performance

One of the key reasons for advocating recess in school is its positive impact on students' ability to concentrate and perform academically. In Caralee Adams’s article, "The Benefits of Recess Are Clear. Why Are Schools Cutting Back?" it is emphasized that recess plays a crucial role in helping kids focus on their schoolwork. Olga Jarrett, quoted in the article, mentions, "It's kids who have trouble concentrating that need recess more than anybody else—and they are the ones less likely to get it." This statement highlights the paradox that the students who would benefit most from recess are often the ones who are deprived of it. As students progress to higher grades, their recess time is often reduced or eliminated, despite the growing demands of their academic workload. Without the opportunity to release pent-up energy, students may struggle to maintain their focus and engagement throughout the long school day.

Recess provides a necessary pause in the day, allowing students to return to their studies with renewed energy and concentration. This is especially important for older students who may not have the opportunity to take breaks during their 6-7 hour school day. By reinstating or extending recess in school, we can help students of all ages improve their academic performance by providing them with the mental and physical break they need to refocus.

Promoting Physical Health

Another compelling reason to include recess in school curricula is its crucial role in promoting physical health. In the article "Many Schools Have Cut Recess to Focus More on Math and Reading. Is It Time to Put the Fun Back on the Schedule?" by Allison Friedman, the importance of physical activity is underscored. Friedman notes, "Doctors say kids need an hour of exercise each day. But between homework and family time, it can be hard to get enough. Cartwheeling around at recess can help keep kids healthy." This highlights the challenge many children face in meeting their daily exercise requirements due to the demands of modern life. With the growing prevalence of screen time and video games, children are less likely to engage in physical activities after school. By incorporating recess in school, educators can ensure that students receive at least a portion of their recommended physical activity during the school day.

Recess offers an opportunity for children to engage in unstructured play, which not only contributes to their physical well-being but also enhances their social skills and creativity. Schools that prioritize recess in school schedules actively contribute to the development of healthier, more active students.

Supporting Mental Health

Recess also plays a vital role in supporting students' mental health. In Ryan Nguyen’s article, "Do Teens Need Recess?" the mental health benefits of physical activity are emphasized. Nguyen states, "Studies show that children who engage in physical activity reap the benefits of improved physical and mental health—yet only 27 percent of high schoolers get the recommended 60 minutes of daily physical activity." This statistic is concerning, as it indicates that a significant majority of high school students are not receiving the exercise necessary for optimal mental health. Recess in school can serve as a valuable outlet for students to alleviate stress and escape the pressures of academic and social life.

By incorporating recess into the daily school schedule, we can provide students with a crucial opportunity to clear their minds and recharge. This is particularly important for students who may face stressful home environments and lack other avenues for relaxation and mental well-being. Recess not only supports mental health but also fosters a positive school culture where students feel more balanced and ready to learn.

Addressing Counterarguments

Despite the compelling arguments for recess in school, some educators and school administrators argue that it detracts from instructional time and could hinder academic progress. Reagon Zuber’s article, "Do We Need Recess?" presents this perspective, stating, "If I'm forced to go to recess, that cuts back on the time allotted to my education—and that'll only hurt me in the long run." While it is important to acknowledge this viewpoint, it is equally important to consider the broader benefits of recess. Rather than reducing instructional time, recess can enhance the quality of learning by improving students' focus, emotional well-being, and physical health. A balanced school day that includes time for both academic study and physical activity can lead to more effective and engaged learners.

Conclusion

In conclusion, recess in school is an essential component of a well-rounded education. By providing students with the opportunity to take breaks, engage in physical activity, and support their mental health, recess can significantly enhance their overall school experience. Schools that prioritize recess not only contribute to better academic outcomes but also foster healthier, happier students. As educators and policymakers consider the future of education, it is crucial to recognize the vital role that recess plays in the development of well-rounded, successful students. Therefore, all schools should ensure that students of all ages have access to daily recess, creating an environment where learning and well-being go hand in hand.

Did you like this example?

262

14