The Role of Theme in Hawthorne’s the Birthmark

Introduction

Nathaniel Hawthorne's short story "The Birthmark" delves into profound themes that are intricately woven into the narrative, making them essential for understanding the underlying message Hawthorne aims to convey. Themes serve as the backbone of storytelling, providing depth and insight into the characters' actions and motivations. In this particular tale, the dominant themes of obsession and man's attempt to conquer nature through science are prominently displayed. These themes not only drive the plot but also offer a critical commentary on human nature and the perils of excessive ambition.

This essay will explore how Hawthorne skillfully employs these themes to craft a narrative that is both thought-provoking and cautionary.

Obsession and Perfection

Hawthorne constructs a narrative where the initial belief that love can triumph over all imperfections is gradually overshadowed by the destructive force of obsession. The character of Aylmer, a brilliant and accomplished scientist, embodies this obsession. He is married to Georgiana, a woman of remarkable beauty marred only by a small birthmark on her cheek. This mark, resembling a tiny red handprint, becomes a focal point of Aylmer's fixation. While some might interpret the birthmark as a symbol of human imperfection or a testament to the natural flaws that make us human, Aylmer perceives it as a repugnant blemish that taunts his scientific prowess and mocks his quest for absolute perfection.

Aylmer's obsession is poignantly captured in his words to Georgiana: "Dearest Georgiana, you came so nearly perfect from the hand of Nature that this slightest possible defect, which we hesitate whether to term a defect or a beauty, shocks me, as being the visible." Here, Aylmer's choice of words reveals his deep-seated discomfort with imperfection and his inability to reconcile his love for Georgiana with his desire for flawlessness. This internal conflict highlights the destructive nature of obsession, as Aylmer's love for his wife is gradually eclipsed by his relentless pursuit of an unattainable ideal.

The Power of Science and Nature

Central to Hawthorne's narrative is the theme of man's attempt to conquer nature through the application of scientific knowledge, regardless of the potential consequences. Aylmer's unwavering belief in the supremacy of science leads him to view Georgiana not as a partner but as a subject for experimentation. In his quest to remove the birthmark, Aylmer isolates Georgiana from the natural world, substituting sunlight with artificial light and filling the air with synthetic fragrances. Through these actions, Aylmer attempts to mold reality to his own design, disregarding the inherent beauty of nature in favor of scientific manipulation.

Hawthorne further illustrates Aylmer's misplaced priorities by depicting his interactions with Georgiana. Their relationship, once rooted in love, becomes increasingly defined by Aylmer's scientific endeavors. Georgiana, once confident in her beauty, begins to question her self-worth under the weight of Aylmer's scrutiny. Aylmer's persuasive rhetoric and self-assuredness in his scientific abilities lead Georgiana to succumb to his obsession, agreeing to undergo the procedure to remove the birthmark, even at the cost of her life.

Conclusion

In the end, Aylmer achieves his goal of eradicating the birthmark, but this victory is pyrrhic, as it results in the loss of Georgiana's life. Through this tragic outcome, Hawthorne underscores the futility of attempting to surpass the natural order and the dangers of allowing obsession to overshadow love and reason. "The Birthmark" serves as a stark reminder of the limitations of human ambition and the inherent risks of valuing scientific prowess over the sanctity of human life. By weaving together the themes of obsession and the clash between science and nature, Hawthorne crafts a narrative that resonates with timeless relevance, challenging readers to reflect on the ethical implications of their pursuits and the importance of embracing the imperfections that make us human.

Did you like this example?

623

26