American Dream Critique in Miller Drama

Introduction

Arthur Miller’s "Death of a Salesman" provides a profound exploration of tragedy, aligning in significant ways with the Aristotelian definition outlined in his seminal work, "Poetics." The play’s protagonist, Willy Loman, exhibits characteristics that qualify him as a tragic hero, albeit with modern reinterpretations. According to Aristotle, a tragedy involves the downfall of a person of high esteem, often due to a tragic flaw or error, known as hamartia. This form of drama is intended to evoke emotions of pity and fear among the audience, ultimately leading to catharsis.

Through an examination of the play's plot, characters, and thematic elements, it becomes evident that Miller’s work embodies many of these classic elements, while also challenging and expanding upon them to suit a more contemporary context.

Willy Loman: A Modern Tragic Hero

Willy Loman serves as the central figure in Miller’s narrative, embodying the tragic hero archetype. Unlike traditional Aristotelian protagonists, who are often figures of notable stature, Willy is an everyday man whose life is marked by delusion rather than excessive pride. His relentless pursuit of the elusive American Dream—a vision of success that remains just out of reach—serves as his tragic flaw. This obsession blinds him to the reality of his life, causing harm to himself and those around him. While Willy's unwavering belief in his dream could be viewed as a form of pride, it is more accurately described as a tragic fixation on illusion over reality. This deviation from classical tragedy reflects a modern twist, illustrating the broader societal issue of unattainable dreams.

Miller utilizes Willy to critique the American Dream, portraying it as a pervasive illusion that leads to perpetual dissatisfaction and despair. Willy’s belief that personal charm and likability are the keys to success becomes his undoing, as he fails to adapt to changing societal norms and economic conditions. Despite his initial status as a respected businessman, Willy’s inability to recognize his limitations and adapt to the realities of his environment leads to his tragic downfall. This portrayal not only aligns with but also expands upon Aristotle’s concept of hamartia by depicting a flaw that resonates with contemporary audiences.

The Tragic Arc and Familial Impact

Willy’s journey from a once-influential salesman to a state of disillusionment and despair underscores the tragic arc of the play. Aristotle’s definition emphasizes a serious tone with a sorrowful ending, which is poignantly realized in Willy’s eventual suicide. Unable to reconcile his failures as a professional, husband, and father, Willy’s decision to end his life reflects his ultimate inability to adapt to an unforgiving reality. His death leaves his family bereft, not only of a provider but also of hope for their own futures. The tragedy is compounded by the realization that Willy’s sons, particularly Biff, are destined to inherit his failures, continuing the cycle of disillusionment and unfulfilled dreams.

Miller’s portrayal of Willy’s family adds a layer of depth to the tragedy, highlighting the broader consequences of Willy’s actions. His wife, Linda, and his sons are depicted as collateral damage in Willy’s relentless pursuit of success. Their dependence on him, both emotionally and financially, underscores the interconnectedness of personal and familial tragedy. This extension of the tragic impact to Willy’s family serves to heighten the emotional resonance of the narrative, evoking a sense of pity and fear that is central to the Aristotelian concept of catharsis.

A Modern Interpretation of Tragedy

While Miller’s play adheres to many Aristotelian principles, it also ventures into new territory by presenting a tragedy centered on an ordinary individual. Aristotle posited that a tragic hero should possess noble qualities, yet Willy Loman is characterized by his ordinariness. Despite this divergence, Willy’s role as a tragic hero is pivotal in advancing the narrative’s themes and emotional depth. His life and eventual demise reflect the struggles of many post-World War II Americans, grappling with financial instability, complex family dynamics, and the pressures of societal expectations.

Miller’s work serves as a commentary on the human condition, exploring themes that resonate with audiences beyond the confines of classical tragedy. The play’s setting in a post-war America recovering from economic and social upheaval further contextualizes Willy’s struggles, making them relatable to contemporary viewers. This modern reinterpretation of tragedy challenges traditional notions while maintaining the core elements that evoke a powerful emotional response.

Conclusion

Arthur Miller’s "Death of a Salesman" masterfully weaves together the elements of Aristotelian tragedy with modern sensibilities, creating a narrative that resonates deeply with audiences. Through Willy Loman, Miller explores the complexities of the American Dream and the human propensity for self-deception. While the protagonist’s ordinariness diverges from classical definitions, his tragic arc and its impact on his family align with the emotional and thematic requirements of a tragedy. Ultimately, the play’s ability to evoke pity and fear, leading to catharsis, solidifies its place as a seminal work of modern tragedy, redefining and expanding upon Aristotelian principles to reflect the realities of contemporary life.

Did you like this example?

5791

241