Should Students Wear School Uniforms

Introduction

The debate surrounding whether or not it is appropriate to require students to wear school uniforms is far from over. Many educators champion the implementation of school uniforms, citing the ways in which they can reduce distractions while fostering a sense of community. Parents tend to hold this view as well, drawing comparisons between the clothes required by professionals on the job and those worn by young people when they return to the classroom. At the same time, many students are fiercely opposed to the idea, maintaining that the ability to choose their own attire is a form of self-expression and part of the human identity.

While school uniforms may provide a sense of equality, public opinion casts doubt on the true effectiveness of such a program.

School uniforms are nothing new. In fact, in history, students often wore uniforms. In the United States of America in particular, it can be observed that school uniforms were most prominent in educational settings during the decade of the 1990s; a significant percentage of urban public schools and suburban ones implemented them during this time. Even today, school uniforms are worn to a greater degree by elementary and middle school students than upperclassmen in high school. The wider debate surrounding school uniforms can raise numerous questions: Do school uniforms instill a sense of equality among students? To what extent, if at all, do they impact factors such as community or identification within a school? And should students still be required to dress the part under stricter dress codes? While insights from these viewpoints may provide a variety of ideas and evidence regarding the effectiveness of school clothing, we must ultimately remember to approach this discussion with respect for others' stories and points of view. Data from every community, after all, will tell a different story.

Benefits of Implementing School Uniforms

Implementing school uniforms can have a handful of benefits: - First and foremost, uniforms can create a sense of unity. They let students know that they are a part of something that is larger than they are. This can instill a sense of school spirit and pride. - When every student dresses the same, it can reduce peer pressure. The question of what to wear seems to be at the front of almost every student’s mind. When students wear uniforms, it can eliminate this question and turn the focus back on academics. - Additionally, uniforms can eliminate bullying or teasing. A student cannot be teased because their shirt came from one store, and another student’s shirt came from a different store. - Uniforms can make things simpler at home. One of the key benefits of uniforms is that it simplifies a family’s morning routine. Not only do uniforms make mornings easier for students, they also speed up the dressing process for teachers, office staff, and administrators who do not have to worry about anything controversial appearing in their hallways or on campus. Not all students have the same financial means to afford clothing. Students who come from affluent families are able to wear the latest fashion trends, while students who come from lower-income families have to do without. Uniforms would eliminate this distinction. Proponents of school uniforms believe that uniforms improve the behavior of students. They believe that behavior thought to be one of the ultimate goals of schools was seen as significantly improved in students who wore uniforms.

Drawbacks and Criticisms of School Uniforms

Although advocates of school uniforms offer a variety of rationales for imposing a districtwide (or nationwide) requirement that students and teachers wear standardized clothes in the classroom, the practice has drawn criticism as well. Critics of school uniforms argue that they can impose a significant burden on a student’s inherent rights of self-expression, originality, and personal beauty. Children, according to this view, need the opportunity to make important personal choices related to identity and self-definition. Schools serve as social centers where children can hone their unique fashion and style sensibilities just as adults do. School uniforms deprive them of such opportunities, dampen their creativity and inventiveness, and deny them the right to be different. For these and other aesthetic reasons, a sizable number of kids rebel against school uniform mandates that are imposed upon them.

In some communities, parents have murmured against school uniform policies, sometimes arguing that they infringe on their rights as patrons of public education. In other cases, parents have worried that long pants and heavy sweaters might present discomfort or practicality issues during hot summer months when offered as part of a school uniform. There is concern that favoring school uniform mandates may result in shunning from the other half of the room. Indeed, some parents see mandatory school uniforms as imposing too much on their pocketbooks, particularly when they are required to purchase new uniforms at the start of a given school year. Economic research indicates that school uniforms can put a financial strain on some families, particularly when economically deprived families already struggle to pay for regular clothes. Longitudinal studies have found no significant association between school uniforms and heightened academic achievement. Furthermore, school discipline research is increasingly finding that school uniform mandates have at best little to no effect on disciplinary infractions. Uniforms may often be detachable symbols that only temporarily attach us to the problems from which we seek release. Uniform mandates for school children are as entrenched today as they are divisive. In many communities, big and small, the pro and con arguments are well known around the kitchen table. Some local charter or private school boards may themselves adopt policies about classroom attire; however, the regular complaints of opponents and defenders are worth considering when continuous challenges are raised whenever public schools have the potential to deeply affect people's lives.

Impact of School Uniforms on Student

A number of studies have been conducted exploring the effects of school uniforms on student performance. While there seems to be evidence to suggest that there is a correlation between wearing school uniforms and academic achievement at schools, we found few studies that use methods that would identify a causal relationship between the two. Therefore, we believe it is inappropriate to say that data suggest there is a clear causal relationship. Instead, we suggest that there may be elements of truth within the debates on pros and cons. Pros generally agree that a reduction in the 'decision making' for students could lead to increased concentration and application in the classroom. Perhaps the most widely assumed 'pro' of introducing a uniform policy at schools is that it makes a key contribution towards improved student behavior. The kinds of practices required in an environment in which people follow uniform rules might involve consultative processes and consensus building, with students and staff at the schools feeling partly responsible for developing school rules and uniform norms. The commitment to following certain uniform rules and practices may reflect the broader environment of the school, and the starting place may be the view that an ordered, well-established set of school practices provides the appropriate basis for effective learning. Indeed, several case studies at schools that have improved behavior list the development of a 'whole school approach' or a 'culture of firmness and fairness'.

Conclusion

Ultimately, there are both pros and cons to adopting a uniform policy in your school. The real conclusion of this chapter is that we simply do not know. It is not clear whether school uniforms have a positive impact on student performance or discipline. While the theoretical reasons for adopting a uniform policy seem sound, there is a real concern that there could be some unintended consequences connected to uniform adoption.

For schools interested in adopting school uniforms, it is important to consult the specific context in which the school is located. There are many different perspectives held by various stakeholders in each local community, so it is necessary to discuss the issue with students, faculty, and parents before establishing a uniform policy. Schools interested in truly striking a balance might consider relaxed uniform policies allowing exceptions for religious garb, accessories, and circumstances warranting special consideration. There are arguments for the absolute embrace of strict uniform policies, and there are some good reasons for partial acceptance based on a variety of non-discretionary circumstances. The key reason not to accept the complete uniform policy is to strike a balance between the potentially positive aspects of uniform policies and the individual style of students. School boards and administrators must figure out what is best for their own school and school district. Given the young age of students who are required to wear uniforms, it is probably best to include the input of these students' parents. Moreover, school districts that do adopt a uniform policy should evaluate whether the policy is reaching its goals with respect to student performance and behavior.

Did you like this example?

244

10