Gender Identity in Family Guy

Queering is an analytical approach applied to popular culture to interrogate and challenge the constructed norms around sexuality, gender fluidity, masculinity, and femininity. This method seeks to deconstruct the pervasive assumption of heteronormativity, which positions heterosexuality as the sole normal and acceptable form of sexuality. As Sullivan (2003) articulates, queering popular culture involves critically engaging with cultural artifacts to explore the ways in which meaning and identity are textually and intertextually reproduced. While the term "queer" is often considered gender-neutral, its representation in mainstream media frequently aligns with male homosexuality (Brontsema, 2004).

This essay examines the character Stewie Griffin from the animated sitcom Family Guy, investigating how his portrayal exemplifies the concept of queering.

Queering Stewie Griffin

Stewie Griffin, a one-year-old prodigy in Family Guy, stands out due to his remarkable intelligence and ongoing struggle to "fit in" with his peers. His age amplifies the intrigue surrounding his queerness, as it challenges traditional perceptions of gender identity and sexual orientation development. Stewie’s gender identity is deliberately ambiguous, hinting at homosexuality and even transgender tendencies, often manifested through his affinity for women's clothing and makeup—elements that can be interpreted as drag. The show employs subtext to subtly hint at Stewie's homosexuality through flamboyant elements such as expressive hand movements and suggestive comments, while also alluding to his potential pansexuality.

A recurring theme in Stewie's characterization is his aggressive demeanor, which could be interpreted as a manifestation of frustration in his quest for self-discovery as a queer individual. This notion is supported by the show's creator, Seth MacFarlane, who, in an interview with Playboy magazine, commented on Stewie's ambiguous sexual identity. MacFarlane noted, "Ultimately, Stewie will be gay or a very unhappy repressed heterosexual. It also explains why he’s so hellbent on killing [his mother, Lois] and taking over the world: He has a lot of aggression, which comes from confusion and uncertainty about his orientation” (Gatecrasher, 2009). This acknowledgment highlights the struggles faced by individuals in the LGBTQ+ community regarding "coming out" and aligning with their true identity amidst societal expectations.

Stewie's Journey of Self-Discovery

In the episode "Send in Stewie, Please," Stewie's journey towards self-discovery takes a significant turn as he subtly comes out as homosexual. The episode features Stewie being sent to a child psychologist, Dr. Pritchfield, after pushing a classmate down the stairs. Upon entering the psychologist's office, Stewie scrutinizes a photograph of Dr. Pritchfield and his younger partner, delving into the nuances of their relationship. This moment underscores the societal pressures and self-doubt often imposed by gay elitism, which is frequently portrayed in media as young, successful white men clad in designer attire.

During the session, Stewie admits to pushing his classmate because of his feelings for him, only to immediately clarify, "not like him, like him." He asserts a semblance of heterosexual confidence while acknowledging fluidity: “If anything I’m less gay than I used to be…But do I think that Grant Gustin and I would make the most adorable Instagram couple? Yes, I do.” This dialogue reveals Stewie's internal conflict and struggle to fit in with peers who do not share his interests. The episode further explores Stewie's use of a fake accent as a "coat of armor," highlighting the lengths individuals go to in order to navigate societal expectations and protect their true selves.

Conclusion

While Family Guy never explicitly defines Stewie's sexuality, the show importantly acknowledges the complexity and nuance of the journey towards self-acceptance. Through a blend of subtle and overt messaging, the series engages in queering by exploring the multifaceted nature of identity and challenging conventional norms. Stewie's character serves as a microcosm of the broader societal conversation on queerness, underscoring the increased prominence and meaningfulness of such narratives in contemporary popular culture. By examining Stewie's character through the lens of queering, we gain a deeper understanding of the ongoing dialogue surrounding identity, acceptance, and the dismantling of heteronormative constructs.

Did you like this example?

350

15