Indigenous Art: Tradition Meets Truth

Indigenous art is revered globally for its exploration of diverse and unique cultures that differ significantly from mainstream societal norms. For many decades, museums and universities have taken on the responsibility of preserving the integrity and quality of indigenous art by showcasing it to the public. However, these institutions also play a dual role in shaping and sometimes distorting perceptions of authenticity and tradition within indigenous cultures. While they educate non-indigenous audiences about these cultures, they inadvertently contribute to the creation of their own narratives of tradition.

Defining Tradition and Authenticity

Tradition is commonly defined as the transmission of customs, beliefs, or tangible cultural representations from one generation to the next. Conversely, authenticity is characterized by the quality of being genuine or real. In the context of indigenous art, tradition refers to the passing down of specific artistic styles, stories, and the art itself through generations. Authenticity, however, is more ambiguous, as anything created can be considered authentic simply because it exists. This ambiguity raises the issue of tourism, where the line between genuine traditional art and profitable representations of indigenous art becomes blurred. A notable example is the depiction of a Maori woman wearing a sacred hei-tiki pendant.

The hei-tiki pendants are significant to the Maori people of New Zealand, symbolizing fertility and often given to newlywed women to aid in conception. These pendants are traditionally passed down through generations, embodying cultural continuity. Bohemian artist Gottfried Lindauer, renowned for his depictions of Maori natives, was commissioned by some Maori chiefs to create artworks that authentically captured their facial tattoos, clothing, and cultural essence. In stark contrast, other artists may produce works depicting Maori natives with an authentic appearance, yet lacking the traditional essence. An example is a plastic keychain of a hei-tiki pendant, created solely for profit, highlighting the clash between tradition and authenticity.

The Role of Museums and Universities

Museums and universities play a pivotal role in preserving and supporting the continuity of indigenous art. Museums educate non-indigenous audiences by displaying genuine traditional art, thereby helping to preserve the quality and integrity of cultural craftsmanship. By showcasing these artworks in safe, controlled environments, museums prolong their lifespan, preventing degradation or obscurity. Universities, on the other hand, take a more objective approach by providing an unbiased understanding of what traditional indigenous art truly encompasses. They delve into not just the physical art, but also the methods of creation, the motivations behind them, and the creators themselves.

The benefits of showcasing indigenous art in museums and universities are evident, providing the public with direct exposure and education about these cultures. For instance, Native Americans are often misrepresented in the media, as exemplified in the film Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man’s Chest, where they are portrayed as primitive. Such portrayals, although potentially authentic, are not accurate representations of Native American culture. Historically, they were resourceful and adept at utilizing their environment, particularly in hunting and resource management. However, the power held by ethnographic institutions can also lead to complications, as they have the authority to decide which artworks to display, potentially fabricating their own interpretations of other cultures’ traditions.

Balancing Authenticity and Tradition

While authenticity and tradition are similar in concept, their application can differ significantly. Tourist art, museums, and universities all contribute to representing the traditions of African, American, and Oceania cultures. The authenticity of these representations is undeniable, but their traditional nature depends on the creators' intentions and cultural understanding. Museums and universities play a crucial role in educating the world about indigenous art and its styles, yet they also have the potential to fabricate their own narratives. The proper preservation and representation of indigenous cultures hinge on good intentions and deep cultural knowledge, as emphasized in the HAVC 80 course at the University of California, Santa Cruz.

Case Studies: Artistic Narratives

Artistic works like Joane Cardinal Schubert’s "The Lesson" and Yinka Shonibare’s "Diary of a Victorian Dandy" further illustrate the interplay of tradition, authenticity, and cultural narrative. Schubert’s work, set in a classroom, is a poignant commentary on the oppression of natives, drawing from her personal experiences and ancestry to highlight the systematic erosion of indigenous traditions. Similarly, Shonibare’s work challenges Victorian notions of race and class, using irony to subvert traditional social hierarchies. These pieces exemplify how art can serve as a powerful medium for exploring and challenging cultural narratives.

The Fred Harvey Trading Company also played a role in shaping perceptions of indigenous cultures. Founded in 1876, the company offered hospitality services along the Santa Fe Railway, inadvertently introducing Americans to Native American cultures. While this increased American interest in indigenous ways of life, it also contributed to the commodification of native cultures for tourism.

In conclusion, the relationship between tradition and authenticity in indigenous art is complex and multifaceted. While museums and universities strive to preserve and educate, they must remain vigilant against the potential for misrepresentation. By fostering a deeper understanding and appreciation of indigenous cultures, we can ensure their traditions are genuinely preserved for future generations.

Did you like this example?

1212

64