Leadership in Animal Farm

Leadership's true nature emerges through Animal Farm's parallel rulers - calculating Napoleon and visionary Snowball. The narrative, which serves as an allegory for the events leading up to the Russian Revolution and the subsequent rise of Stalinism, hinges on the ideological and practical differences between these two prominent pigs. This essay aims to delve into why Snowball emerges as a more favorable leader than Napoleon, highlighting their divergent ideas, interactions with other animals, and methods of gaining loyalty and control. Ultimately, Snowball's leadership is characterized by innovation and selflessness, while Napoleon's is defined by tyranny and manipulation.

Snowball's Visionary Leadership

Snowball embodies the qualities of a visionary leader, driven by a genuine desire to improve the lives of the animals on the farm. Unlike Napoleon, whose primary focus is on consolidating power, Snowball is more concerned with the welfare of the community. His creativity, intelligence, and eloquent public speaking make him an effective and persuasive leader. Snowball's dedication to the farm is evident in his tireless work ethic and his ability to juggle multiple projects simultaneously. As the best writer among the pigs, he not only drafts complex plans for the windmill but also educates other animals, fostering a sense of collective progress.

One of Snowball's most significant contributions is his role in the Battle of the Cowshed, where he exhibits both bravery and strategic acumen. He not only plans the defense against the human attackers but also risks his life by leading the charge. This selfless act highlights his commitment to the cause and his willingness to sacrifice for the greater good. Snowball's ideas are rooted in Old Major's vision of an egalitarian society, where all animals benefit from the fruits of their labor. This is evident in his plans to build the windmill, which he believes will ease the workload and improve the quality of life on the farm.

Napoleon's Authoritarian Rule

In stark contrast, Napoleon represents a leader consumed by power and control. His approach to leadership is marked by manipulation, fear, and exploitation. From the outset, Napoleon exhibits a lack of concern for the well-being of the animals. His announcement of a sixty-hour workweek, coupled with the threat of reduced rations for those who do not comply, underscores his disregard for the animals' health and exhaustion. Unlike Snowball, who seeks to inspire and uplift, Napoleon employs coercion and intimidation to maintain his authority.

Napoleon's expulsion of Snowball is a pivotal moment that reveals his true nature. By eliminating his rival, Napoleon ensures that he has no competition for power, thereby establishing himself as the farm's unchallenged dictator. He then manipulates the animals through a propaganda campaign, using Squealer to spread lies about Snowball and scapegoating him for every misfortune that befalls the farm. This tactic not only consolidates Napoleon's power but also diverts attention from his failures as a leader. Furthermore, Napoleon's creation of a private army of loyal dogs serves as a tool of repression, instilling fear in the animals and quashing any dissent.

The Dichotomy of Leadership

The fundamental differences between Snowball and Napoleon's leadership styles can be distilled into their underlying motivations and methods. Snowball is driven by the ideals of Animalism and the betterment of the farm, while Napoleon is motivated by self-interest and the desire for absolute control. Snowball's leadership is characterized by inclusivity, innovation, and bravery, whereas Napoleon's rule is marked by exclusion, propaganda, and oppression.

In conclusion, Snowball emerges as the more admirable leader because of his commitment to the collective welfare of the animals and his adherence to the principles of Animalism. His vision for a better future, coupled with his willingness to work alongside the other animals, sets him apart from Napoleon's tyrannical and self-serving regime. Through the juxtaposition of Snowball and Napoleon, Orwell presents a powerful critique of totalitarianism and underscores the importance of leadership that prioritizes the common good over personal ambition.

Did you like this example?

5971

250