The American Dream: a Puerto Rican Nightmare

In Pedro Pietri’s evocative poem "Puerto Rican Obituary," the poet vividly depicts the harsh realities faced by Hispanic communities, particularly Puerto Ricans, living in Spanish Harlem, New York City. Through a masterful use of language and narrative, Pietri challenges the myth of the American Dream, revealing its dark side for those living under an oppressive societal structure. At the start of the poem, Pietri describes the inequities endured by hardworking Puerto Ricans, who consistently find themselves disadvantaged despite their relentless efforts.

This essay explores how Pietri uses different perspectives and characters to critique the American Dream and highlight the struggles of Puerto Ricans in America during his time, ultimately presenting a haunting portrait of unfulfilled lives.

Exposing Economic Disparities

Pietri paints a bleak picture of the economic hardships faced by Puerto Ricans, emphasizing the systemic injustices that prevent them from achieving the prosperity promised by the American Dream. He poignantly states, "They died broke, They died owing, They died never knowing," underscoring the perpetual cycle of debt and lack of fulfillment experienced by these individuals. This refrain serves as a powerful indictment of the societal structures that exploit marginalized communities, depriving them of the opportunities afforded to others. The inability of Puerto Ricans to access basic financial services, such as entering the front doors of the first national city bank, starkly illustrates their economic marginalization and the barriers they face in pursuing upward mobility.

Loss of Cultural Identity

Pietri also delves into the cultural dislocation experienced by Puerto Ricans as they strive to assimilate into American society. Through the portrayal of characters like Juan, Miguel, Milagros, Olga, and Manuel, Pietri explores the identity crisis that arises when individuals feel compelled to abandon their heritage in favor of Americanization. He laments the loss of cultural roots with the line, "Dead Puerto Ricans, Who never knew they were Puerto Ricans." This poignant statement highlights the existential conflict faced by many ethnic groups who, in the pursuit of acceptance and success, lose touch with their native culture. Pietri suggests that this cultural erasure is akin to a form of death, as it denies individuals the opportunity to fully embrace and express their true selves.

The Futility of the American Dream

Throughout the poem, Pietri critiques the elusive nature of the American Dream for Puerto Ricans, portraying it as an unattainable goal that leaves individuals feeling disillusioned and trapped. He paints a vivid picture of people chasing dreams that remain out of reach due to systemic barriers and societal neglect. In a particularly striking metaphor, Pietri writes, "From the nervous breakdown streets where the mice live like millionaires and the people do not live at all are dead and were never alive." Here, Pietri contrasts the carefree existence of animals with the oppressive conditions faced by Puerto Ricans, suggesting that their lives are devoid of meaning and vitality. This metaphor powerfully conveys the futility of pursuing the American Dream when fundamental rights and opportunities are denied.

Reimagining Dreams and Survival

Pietri further illustrates the distorted reality of the American Dream through examples of individuals waiting for basic necessities rather than pursuing personal fulfillment. Characters like Miguel, Milagros, and Olga are depicted as waiting for welfare checks, a raise, or the chance to stop working—desires that starkly contrast with the traditional image of the American Dream as one of prosperity and comfort. Pietri’s portrayal highlights the grim reality that many Puerto Ricans face, where survival takes precedence over the pursuit of happiness. Their dreams are reduced to mere hopes for subsistence, reflecting a grim existence that challenges the very notion of the American Dream.

Conclusion

In "Puerto Rican Obituary," Pedro Pietri offers a poignant critique of the American Dream through the lens of the Puerto Rican experience. By highlighting the economic struggles, cultural dislocation, and unattainable aspirations faced by Puerto Ricans in Spanish Harlem, Pietri exposes the harsh realities of an oppressive society that fails to deliver on its promises. His use of evocative language and vivid imagery serves as a powerful reminder of the systemic injustices that continue to affect marginalized communities. Ultimately, Pietri's poem calls for a reevaluation of the American Dream, urging society to confront these disparities and strive for a more equitable future where all individuals have the opportunity to thrive and embrace their true identities.

Did you like this example?

529

28