Foster Care System: Challenges, Successes, and Paths to Improvement

Introduction

The foster care system, a crucial component of child welfare, is a network managed at both federal and state levels. It acts as an alternative living arrangement for children who cannot safely remain with their biological parents or guardians due to various concerns, including neglect or abuse. The primary purpose of this system is to safeguard children and provide them with stable and nurturing environments, whether in foster homes, group homes, or shelters. Ideally, the ultimate objective for these children is reunification with their families, provided it is deemed safe and feasible.

However, this goal is not always achievable, leading to prolonged stays in the system until the children age out or, in rarer instances, get adopted. This essay critically examines the multifaceted foster care system, highlighting both its strengths and its shortcomings. It will explore key aspects such as statistical trends, the challenges of aging out, issues of permanent connections, educational impacts, and the influence of race and sexual orientation. Additionally, it will discuss how the foster care experience can significantly increase the likelihood of involvement with the criminal justice system.

Statistical Insights

The foster care system currently accommodates approximately 400,000 children, with an influx of about 250,000 new youths entering each year. Of these, 47% are Caucasian, 21% are African American, and 20% are Hispanic. Notably, the proportion of Caucasian youths entering the system is on the rise, while the percentage of African American entrants is gradually decreasing. The median age of children entering foster care is roughly 6.3 years, indicating that many children experience significant life changes at a young age.

Despite these challenges, there are positive trends as well. In 2016, the number of adoptions surpassed those in 2015 by 3,653, with a total of 57,208 adoptions taking place. This represents a 13% increase in adoptions since 2014, with 52% of these adoptions occurring within foster families where the children had already spent a significant amount of time, thus becoming an integral part of the family unit. However, the average wait time for children, whose parental rights have been terminated, to be adopted remains at 31.2 months, which, while an improvement over previous years, is still too long for a child in need of a permanent family environment.

A noteworthy improvement is the decline in the number of children aging out without permanent connections. Between 20,000 and 25,000 youths age out annually, reflecting a 45% decrease over the past decade. This improvement suggests that more children are leaving the system with supportive networks, which can significantly reduce their risk of incarceration, homelessness, and other negative outcomes. In 2016 alone, 250,000 children exited the foster care system, with 89% finding stability through reunification with biological parents, kinship care, adoption, or legal guardianship. Unfortunately, nearly 100,000 children were removed from their homes due to parental drug use, a 7% increase since 2015, reflecting the ongoing drug epidemic in the United States. Additionally, 166,000 children entered foster care due to neglect, often correlated with parental substance abuse. This rising trend in child abuse and neglect, largely driven by drug abuse, presents a daunting challenge for state systems already struggling with burgeoning caseloads.

Educational Challenges

Education can serve as a beacon of hope for many children who have experienced parental separation, neglect, or abuse. Engaging in school activities can distract them from their adverse circumstances and is essential for building a brighter future. However, children in the foster care system frequently encounter educational hurdles. They often move from school to school, disrupting their academic progress and making it difficult to keep pace with varying curriculums.

These frequent relocations create significant barriers for foster care youths, requiring them to exert extra effort to catch up academically. Establishing and maintaining positive relationships with peers and teachers is also challenging due to the transient nature of their school experiences. For instance, my personal experience of attending eight different schools highlights the difficulties of being caught between curriculums, often finding myself either lagging behind or far ahead. This inconsistency diminishes the chances of receiving scholarships or grants, and it limits opportunities for foster youths to participate in leadership roles or achieve academic honors.

The likelihood of foster care youths graduating from high school is alarmingly low. Only 50% of these children graduate, as they are three times more likely to drop out than their peers from low-income families. Many are placed in remedial or special education classes and are more prone to receiving failing grades. Despite the aspirations of many foster youths to attend college, numerous barriers stand in their way. These children often lack the emotional support, understanding, and financial resources necessary for higher education. Among the 400,000 foster care youths in the United States, less than 3% complete a four-year university degree. The financial obstacles are significant, as these youths typically lack parental co-signers for loans and find that FAFSA loans do not cover the full cost of tuition. Additionally, they often lack guidance on navigating college applications and financial aid processes, further hindering their educational prospects.

Sexual Orientation and Discrimination

LGBTQ youth face unique challenges within the foster care system, often experiencing issues not encountered by their heterosexual peers. There is a higher likelihood of LGBTQ youths being placed in group homes or shelters rather than family settings, resulting in more frequent moves between placements. This situation arises from biases and discrimination within the system, as well as a lack of understanding and acceptance.

Tragically, these youths, who have already endured traumatic experiences, may enter a system ill-equipped to address their needs. Despite growing societal acceptance, many foster families and system staff remain unwilling to embrace LGBTQ youths, citing moral objections. Discrimination extends beyond foster families to include caseworkers, social workers, group home staff, and peers. LGBTQ youth are over twice as likely to experience poor treatment within the foster care system compared to their heterosexual counterparts. A survey conducted in New York City revealed that 78% of LGBTQ youths were removed or ran away from foster placements due to hostility toward their sexual orientation or gender identity. In group homes, 100% of LGBTQ youths reported verbal harassment, and 70% reported physical violence.

Aging Out and Independence

For most teenagers, turning 18 marks a significant milestone as they transition into legal adulthood. However, for children in foster care, this milestone can evoke feelings of fear and anxiety. Each year, over 25,000 youths age out of the foster care system in the United States, with the age of aging out varying between 18 and 24 depending on individual needs, disabilities, and state regulations. In Pennsylvania, for example, youths can choose to leave care at 18 but have the option to remain until 21 if they wish. While many choose to sign out, there are benefits to staying in care, such as receiving a monthly stipend for basic necessities and retaining support from caseworkers and social workers.

When youths age out of the system, they often feel lost and vulnerable. They face uncertainty about securing their next meal, finding a place to live, and accessing healthcare. With limited experience and transportation options, obtaining stable employment becomes a daunting challenge. The transition to independent living is fraught with difficulties, including poor education, housing instability, and increased risk of poverty. While several programs aim to support former foster youths, they often prove ineffective, leaving many to navigate the transition to adulthood on their own. This lack of support can lead some to engage in criminal activities as a means of survival.

Criminal Justice System and Foster Care

Youth in foster care are at a heightened risk of entering the criminal justice system, whether as juveniles or adults. Those placed in group homes face a significantly higher likelihood of involvement with the criminal justice system compared to those in traditional foster homes. Frequent moves between placements exacerbate this risk, as instability often leads to engagement in criminal activities.

By the age of 17, more than half of foster care youths have had some interaction with the criminal justice system, whether through arrest, conviction, or overnight stays in correctional facilities. The risk is particularly pronounced for those who have experienced five or more moves, with 90% of such youths having a definitive chance of entering the juvenile justice system. Within just two years of leaving care, over one-quarter of these youths are arrested and enter the criminal justice system.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the foster care system presents numerous challenges for the youth it serves. While it aims to provide protection and stability, many children face significant barriers, including disrupted education, discrimination based on sexual orientation, and a lack of permanent connections. These challenges often lead to involvement in criminal activities, perpetuating a cycle of disadvantage. Addressing these issues requires systemic changes to ensure that all foster care youths receive the support and opportunities they need to thrive, minimizing the risk of negative outcomes and helping them transition successfully into adulthood.

Did you like this example?

341

18