Gender Identity in their Eyes were Watching God

Zora Neale Hurston’s novel Their Eyes Were Watching God is a profound exploration of gender discrimination and the relentless pursuit of personal freedom by its protagonist, Janie Crawford. Set in the early 20th century, the novel delves into the societal and personal challenges faced by Janie as she navigates through the expectations and limitations imposed on her due to her gender and race. This essay examines the central theme of gender discrimination as experienced by Janie, highlighting her journey from being oppressed by societal norms to achieving a sense of independence and self-realization.

Societal Expectations and Early Life

From a young age, Janie is acutely aware of the societal expectations that dictate her roles and responsibilities as a woman. Her grandmother, Nanny, embodies these societal pressures by arranging Janie's marriage to a man who can provide financial stability, rather than a partner chosen out of love. Nanny's plan reflects a broader societal norm where women were expected to marry for security rather than affection. Hurston writes, “She realized that marriage doesn’t equate to love. With her first dream shattered, Janie came of age” (Hurston 25). This realization marks a pivotal moment in Janie's life, as she begins to understand that love and marriage are not synonymous, and that societal norms often suppress individual desires, especially for women.

Marriage as a Tool of Control

The oppressive nature of gender roles is further highlighted in Janie's marriage to Joe Starks. Joe, a man with conservative views, perceives women as extensions of their husbands, devoid of their own voices or identities. When Janie attempts to speak in public, Joe interrupts, asserting, “Thank you for your compliments, but my wife isn’t skilled in public speaking. I didn’t marry her for that. She’s a woman; her place is at home” (Hurston 43). Joe's words encapsulate the prevailing belief that women should remain in the domestic sphere, reinforcing the notion that their primary role is to support their husbands rather than pursue their own ambitions. This dynamic illustrates how marriage was often used as a means of control, restricting women's autonomy and reinforcing their subservience to men.

Tea Cake and the Illusion of Equality

After Joe's death, Janie's relationship with Tea Cake offers a seemingly different perspective. While Tea Cake treats Janie with more respect than her previous husbands, he still unconsciously upholds gendered stereotypes. He offers to escort Janie home, commenting, “Just like a little girl in her Easter dress. You look nice!” (Hurston 98). Although Tea Cake's intentions may be genuine, his actions reveal an underlying belief that women are inherently weaker and in need of protection. This moment underscores the pervasive nature of sexism, even in relationships that appear more equitable. Tea Cake’s protective gesture, though well-meaning, subtly undermines Janie’s agency and reinforces traditional gender roles.

The Burden of Being a Black Woman

In the context of early 20th-century Southern society, Janie's struggles are further compounded by her identity as a black woman. Hurston poignantly captures this intersectionality through Nanny's perspective: “So de white man drops the load and tells the nigger man to pick it up. He picks it up because he has to, but he does not carry it. He hands it to his ladies. The nigger woman is the mule of the globe as far as Ah can see” (Hurston 14). This metaphor highlights the compounded oppression faced by black women, who are marginalized both by race and gender. In a society that devalues women, and particularly women of color, Janie's journey becomes emblematic of the broader struggle for equality and self-determination.

Janie's Path to Independence

Towards the end of the novel, Janie's personal growth and increasing independence signify her triumph over the societal constraints that have long held her back. After the tragic death of Tea Cake, Janie reflects on the nature of love and relationships, asserting, “Love is lak de sea. It’s uh movin’ thing, but still and all, it takes its shape from de shore it meets, and it’s different with every shore” (Hurston 191). This metaphor signifies Janie's understanding that love is not a monolithic experience but is shaped by individual circumstances and perspectives. By rejecting societal norms that dictate what love should be, Janie reclaims her agency and asserts her right to define her own life and relationships.

Janie's ultimate act of self-determination occurs when she makes the difficult decision to end Tea Cake's life as he succumbs to madness from rabies. Hurston writes, “The pistol and the rifle rang out almost together. The pistol just enough after the rifle to seem its echo” (Hurston 184). This moment of agency is significant not only because it is a decision made independently, without the influence of others, but also because it symbolizes Janie's liberation from the oppressive forces that have governed her life. By taking control of her destiny, Janie exemplifies the strength and resilience needed to overcome systemic gender discrimination.

Conclusion

Zora Neale Hurston's Their Eyes Were Watching God offers a compelling exploration of gender discrimination and the quest for self-empowerment. Through Janie's journey, the novel critiques the societal structures that confine women to predetermined roles and highlights the resilience required to transcend these limitations. By ultimately asserting her independence, Janie challenges the oppressive gender norms of her time and embodies the possibility of living life on one's own terms. Her story serves as a testament to the enduring struggle for gender equality and the transformative power of self-realization.

Did you like this example?

341

18