Decoding Hamlet: Psychoanalysis and Grief in Shakespeare’s Tragedy

Introduction

Applying a psychoanalytic lens to literary works often yields profound insights into characters' behaviors and motivations. This holds especially true for Shakespeare's "Hamlet," a tragedy intricately woven with themes of psychology and grief. Shakespeare has crafted a unique psychological landscape for Hamlet, revealing his internal fallacies and conflicts. By examining Hamlet through the dual frameworks of psychoanalysis and the five stages of grief, we can better understand his notorious inaction in seeking revenge for his father's murder. Psychoanalysis delves into Hamlet's id, ego, and superego, while the stages of grief highlight his emotional turmoil following the death of his father.

Hamlet's Psychological Conflict

The Id's Influence

Hamlet's psychological struggle begins with his id, the primal part of his psyche that operates on the pleasure principle and seeks immediate gratification. His father's untimely death plants the seed of revenge deep within his heart. Grief overwhelms him, as he mourns the loss of his father and grapples with jealousy over his uncle Claudius's usurpation of the throne and his mother, Gertrude. This jealousy and mourning, which manifest in Hamlet's famous line, "But I have that within which passeth show, these but the trappings and the suits of woe" (Shakespeare I.ii.85), reveal the id's grip on his actions, or lack thereof.

Moreover, Hamlet's Oedipus complex, as articulated by scholars such as E. Jones, adds another layer of complexity to his id. This theory suggests that Hamlet's repressed desire for his mother resurfaces upon Claudius's usurpation, creating an internal conflict that fuels his hesitation. The id's influence, therefore, serves as both a motivator for revenge and an obstacle, as it ensnares Hamlet in a web of conflicting desires and emotions.

The Superego's Restraint

In stark contrast, Hamlet's superego imposes moral and ethical constraints, preventing him from acting on his vengeful impulses. Hamlet is acutely aware of his moral obligations and religious beliefs, which serve as counterweights to his id's demands. He questions the nature of the ghost's revelation, pondering, "The spirit that I have seen may be the devil, and the devil hath power T’ assume a pleasing shape" (Shakespeare II.ii.560). This skepticism reflects his superego's attempt to uphold ethical standards and avoid damnation.

Hamlet's superego also grapples with the political ramifications of regicide. Killing Claudius, who is not only his uncle but also the king, could plunge Denmark into chaos, a prospect Hamlet wishes to avoid due to his belief in maintaining order and hierarchy. This political consideration is echoed in Bingshan Liu's commentary on the dangers of rashly killing a monarch. Furthermore, Hamlet's religious convictions, encapsulated in his soliloquy about the "undiscovered country" (Shakespeare III.i.79-82), reinforce his aversion to murder, as he fears both eternal damnation and the violation of divine law.

The Ego's Balancing Act

Caught between his id's demands for revenge and his superego's moral reservations, Hamlet's ego struggles to mediate. The ego, tasked with reconciling internal desires with external realities, ultimately delays action. Hamlet's isolation and lack of power, compounded by his distrust of those around him, exacerbate his indecision. As WANG Juan notes, Hamlet's humanist ideals and lack of allies further contribute to his paralysis.

Hamlet's ego, adhering to the principle of reality, prioritizes careful deliberation over impulsive action. This internal conflict is poignantly expressed in his soliloquy, "Thus conscience does make cowards of us all" (Shakespeare III.i.84-86), where he acknowledges his own hesitation. Only when faced with death does Hamlet's ego align with his id and superego, allowing him to finally enact his revenge upon Claudius.

Stages of Grief

Depression and Bargaining

Hamlet's journey through the stages of grief begins with depression, a profound sadness stemming from his father's death. This is evident in his lament, "Oh, that this too, too sullied flesh would melt" (Shakespeare I.ii.129-131), where he contemplates suicide as an escape from his despair. Simultaneously, Hamlet bargains with fate, hoping for a resolution to his suffering. This emotional turmoil lays the groundwork for his vengeful desires.

Denial and Isolation

The second stage, denial and isolation, emerges from Hamlet's fractured relationship with Ophelia. Her rejection, influenced by her father's interference, deepens Hamlet's sense of betrayal and abandonment. His harsh words to Ophelia, "Get thee to a nunnery" (Shakespeare III.i.136-140), reveal his attempt to distance himself from further emotional pain. In doing so, he isolates himself from those who might offer solace, further complicating his path to revenge.

Anger and Acceptance

Hamlet's anger, a natural progression in the grieving process, is directed towards both Gertrude and Polonius. His confrontation with Gertrude, where he accuses her of hypocrisy and betrayal, exemplifies his rage: "makes marriage vows as false as dicer’s oaths" (Shakespeare III.iv.43-46). This anger propels him to impulsively kill Polonius, an act that momentarily emboldens his resolve for revenge.

Ultimately, Hamlet reaches acceptance in the final act, confronting his mortality and the inevitability of his fate. As he faces death, he expresses a sense of peace, telling Horatio, "But let it be" (Shakespeare V.ii.333-336). This acceptance, coupled with his final act of vengeance against Claudius, signifies his reconciliation with his internal conflicts.

Conclusion

In conclusion, analyzing "Hamlet" through the intertwined lenses of psychoanalysis and the five stages of grief offers a comprehensive understanding of the protagonist's complex psychology. Hamlet's internal struggle, driven by the conflicting forces of his id, superego, and ego, is further complicated by his journey through grief. This dual framework reveals the intricacies of Hamlet's character and the reasons behind his infamous delay in seeking revenge. By delving into these psychological and emotional layers, we gain a deeper appreciation for Shakespeare's masterful portrayal of human nature in all its complexity.

Did you like this example?

456

24