The Great Gatsby: a Mirror to the American Dream’s Illusion

F. Scott Fitzgerald's novel, The Great Gatsby, serves as a profound commentary on the American Dream, dissecting its promises and exposing its inherent hypocrisy. The narrative, set in the Roaring Twenties, explores themes of wealth, love, and the relentless pursuit of happiness. The focus keyword here is "Great Gatsby argumentative essay," which is an apt descriptor of the critical examination of the novel's underlying messages. In this essay, I will argue that The Great Gatsby reveals the American Dream as an unattainable illusion, corrupted by materialism and a distorted sense of reality.

Through the characters of Jay Gatsby, Daisy Buchanan, and Tom Buchanan, Fitzgerald critiques the moral decay hidden beneath the veneer of opulence and success. This analysis will be supported by evidence from the text and scholarly interpretations.

Jay Gatsby: The Tragic Embodiment of the American Dream

Jay Gatsby, the enigmatic millionaire at the heart of Fitzgerald's novel, embodies the American Dream's alluring yet deceptive promise. Gatsby's life is a rags-to-riches story, fueled by his unwavering belief in the power of self-reinvention and the pursuit of wealth. However, his dream is ultimately hollow, as it is founded on an idealized past and a fantasy of romantic fulfillment with Daisy Buchanan. Gatsby's opulent parties, designed to attract Daisy, symbolize the superficiality and emptiness of his ambitions. As noted by critic Matthew J. Bruccoli, "Gatsby's flaw is his faith in the American Dream, his belief that money can buy anything, including happiness and social acceptance" (Bruccoli, 1992). Despite his immense wealth, Gatsby remains an outsider in the eyes of East Egg's old-money elite, illustrating the social barriers that the American Dream fails to acknowledge. His tragic end underscores the futility of his pursuit, as he is left with nothing but the shattered remnants of his dream. Through Gatsby's character, Fitzgerald exposes the American Dream as a seductive yet ultimately destructive force, driven by materialism rather than genuine fulfillment. The novel illustrates how the dream's promise of upward mobility and personal success is often overshadowed by the harsh realities of societal constraints and personal disillusionment. Ultimately, Gatsby's demise serves as a poignant critique of the myth of the American Dream, revealing its inherent contradictions and the inevitable disappointment it engenders.

Daisy Buchanan: The Illusion of Love and the Corruption of Values

Daisy Buchanan, the object of Gatsby's affection, represents the moral decay and superficiality underlying the American Dream. Her character embodies the allure of wealth and social status, yet her actions reveal a profound emptiness and lack of integrity. Daisy's choice to marry Tom Buchanan, despite her love for Gatsby, illustrates her prioritization of security and comfort over genuine emotional connection. This decision reflects the societal values of the Jazz Age, where material success was often prioritized over moral or ethical considerations. As critic Sarah Churchwell observes, "Daisy's voice is full of money... she is the embodiment of the American Dream's allure and its ultimate inaccessibility" (Churchwell, 2014). Daisy's voice, described as "full of money" by Gatsby, symbolizes the pervasive influence of wealth in her life and relationships. Her eventual betrayal of Gatsby, choosing to remain with Tom despite his infidelities, underscores her complicity in the moral corruption that defines their world. Daisy's character highlights the emptiness of the American Dream's promise, as her pursuit of material wealth and social status leaves her emotionally unfulfilled and morally bankrupt. Through Daisy, Fitzgerald critiques the superficial values of the era, emphasizing the disillusionment that accompanies the pursuit of an unattainable ideal. Her actions serve as a reminder of the hollowness of a life driven by materialism and societal expectations, rather than genuine human connections and ethical principles. In this way, Daisy's character serves as a powerful indictment of the American Dream's failure to deliver true happiness or fulfillment.

Tom Buchanan: The Preservation of Privilege and the Failure of the Dream

Tom Buchanan, Daisy's husband, serves as a symbol of the entrenched privilege and moral decay that the American Dream fails to address. As a member of the old-money elite, Tom epitomizes the arrogance and entitlement that come with inherited wealth. His character challenges the notion of the American Dream as an equal opportunity for success, highlighting the social and economic disparities that persist despite the dream's promises. Tom's disdain for Gatsby, whom he regards as a social upstart, underscores the rigid class distinctions that the American Dream purports to transcend. Scholar Roger L. Pearson argues that "Tom Buchanan represents the old-money class that sees itself as the rightful custodian of American values, yet is deeply corrupt and morally bankrupt" (Pearson, 1970). Tom's affair with Myrtle Wilson and his callous treatment of those around him further exemplify his moral failings and the hypocrisy of his privileged status. His ability to manipulate and control situations to his advantage, without facing consequences, highlights the limitations of the American Dream in addressing issues of power and inequality. Tom's character underscores the failure of the American Dream to foster genuine social mobility or moral integrity, as it remains inextricably linked to entrenched systems of privilege and power. Through Tom, Fitzgerald critiques the dream's inability to deliver on its promises, revealing the underlying social and economic barriers that perpetuate inequality and injustice. In this way, Tom's character serves as a stark reminder of the dream's limitations, challenging the notion of its universality and accessibility.

In conclusion, F. Scott Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby offers a poignant critique of the American Dream, exposing its inherent contradictions and the moral decay it engenders. Through the characters of Jay Gatsby, Daisy Buchanan, and Tom Buchanan, the novel illustrates the dream's failure to deliver genuine fulfillment or social mobility. Gatsby's tragic pursuit of an idealized past, Daisy's superficial values, and Tom's entrenched privilege highlight the dream's limitations and the societal barriers that persist despite its promises. This analysis underscores the novel's enduring relevance, as it continues to resonate with contemporary audiences grappling with issues of inequality, materialism, and the pursuit of happiness. Ultimately, The Great Gatsby serves as a cautionary tale, reminding readers of the dangers of chasing an unattainable ideal and the moral compromises that often accompany the pursuit of wealth and success.

• Bruccoli, Matthew J. Some Sort of Epic Grandeur: The Life of F. Scott Fitzgerald. University of South Carolina Press, 1992.
• Churchwell, Sarah. Careless People: Murder, Mayhem, and the Invention of The Great Gatsby. Penguin Books, 2014.
• Pearson, Roger L. "Gatsby: False Prophet of the American Dream." English Journal, vol. 59, no. 5, 1970, pp. 638-641.

Did you like this example?

233

10