The Champions of John Scopes: a Defense that Shaped History

During the hot summer of 1925 Dayton Tennessee was the strange heart of a major court case that put faith against science and progress against custom. A young high school teacher called John Scopes was at the center of this fight. He was accused of breaking the Butler Act by teaching Charles Darwin’s theory of evolution in a public school. The trial which became famous as the “Scopes Monkey Trial” was not only held in one place but it was seen by famous lawyers and interested people from all over the country.

There were two great men who fought for Scopes. Their names will always be remembered in American law history: Clarence Darrow and Dudley Field Malone.

By the time of the Scopes Trial Clarence Darrow was already a well-known figure. He was a strong lawyer who was known for his powerful speeches and unwavering dedication to civil rights. It was because Darrow fought for labor leaders rebels and people on the outside of society that he was known as the “Attorney for the Damned.” He joined John Scopes’ defense team because he strongly believed in intellectual freedom and wanted to fight against the spread of religious dogma into public schools. Darrow’s participation in the trial made sure that the whole country paid attention since he was a well-liked and controversial figure.

Wes Dudley Field Malone was also very important to the defense. He brought a different set of skills to the trial that were just as important. Malone was known for his skill as a speaker and his dedication to progressive causes. He had been a minister and a lawyer for a long time. He fought hard for women’s right to vote and had a long history of working for social justice. It was Malone’s strong belief in the separation of church and state and the need for scientific research to be free from religious meddling that led him to support Scopes. Together Darrow and Malone were a strong team. They had the same goal of creating a society where people could discuss and explore ideas openly.

The Scopes Trial was both a court case and a big deal in the news. There were a lot of reporters witnesses and even radio hosts in the courtroom who told people across the country about the action. The prosecution led by the powerful William Jennings Bryan who ran for president three times and was a strong supporter of creationism tried to show that Scopes broke Tennessee’s laws and harmed young people. Bryan was a tough opponent because he was good at public speaking and strongly believed in God. The trial quickly turned into a battle of the giants.

Darrow’s plan for protection was both risky and out of the ordinary. To do this he not only tried to protect Scopes but also the law itself. Darrow said the Butler Act was illegal because it went against the First Amendment’s protections for free speech and the separation of church and state. He asked a number of experts such as scientists and preachers to talk about how true evolutionary theory is and how important academic freedom is. Darrow’s cross-examination of Bryan which ended with Bryan testifying is one of the most famous events in the history of American law. Bryan’s literal reading of the Bible was shown to be inconsistent and contradictory by Darrow’s questions. This showed the conflict between scientific proof and religious belief.

Malone was also very important to the defense. His passionate statements and smart legal mind went well with Darrow’s more aggressive style. Malone was very well-spoken when he gave an emotional speech about why intellectual freedom is important and how control is bad. People who thought that education should be a place of study and finding not faith and brainwashing really felt what he said.

John Scopes was found guilty and given a $100 fine but the trial was important for a lot more reasons than just the decision. The Scopes Trial was a turning point in American history. It showed how science and religion custom and progress are always at odds with each other. It showed how powerful legal lobbying can be and how important it is to protect civil rights. Darrow and Malone’s defense of John Scopes was a brave defense of intellectual freedom and a deep statement about the ideals that make a democracy work.

People in the United States continued to argue about faith schooling and science after the Scopes Trial for many years. The trial made it clear how important it is to protect the right to think teach and discover new ideas. These are still important ideas almost 100 years later. The fight between Clarence Darrow and Dudley Field Malone to defend John Scopes was more than just a court case. It was a turning point in the ongoing search for truth and knowledge.

Did you like this example?

231

12