Sense, Sensibility, and the Symphony of Life: the Dashwood Sisters in Jane Austen’s Novel

Jane Austen’s “Sense and Sensibility” tells the story of the Dashwood sisters, Elinor and Marianne, navigating the societal pressures and personal desires of late 18th-century England. This exploration of reason and emotion can be uniquely viewed through the lens of musical composition, where the structured harmony of Elinor contrasts with the free-flowing melody of Marianne. By comparing their journeys to the elements of a symphony, we can appreciate the balance they seek in life, much like the balance sought in music.

Elinor Dashwood’s character represents the structured foundation of a musical piece, akin to the bass line or harmony that provides stability and coherence. Her life is guided by reason and restraint, much like the bass notes in a symphony that maintain the piece’s structure. Elinor’s practical approach to her relationship with Edward Ferrars, despite her deep affection for him, mirrors the careful construction of a symphony where each note and chord must align perfectly. Her composed demeanor and sense of duty ensure that she upholds societal expectations, much like how a symphony’s harmony must adhere to musical rules to maintain its integrity.

In contrast, Marianne Dashwood embodies the melody of a symphony, expressive and often unpredictable. Melody, with its fluidity and emotional appeal, drives the listener’s engagement, much like Marianne’s passionate and spontaneous nature drives the novel’s emotional narrative. Her relationship with John Willoughby is a whirlwind of romance and intensity, reflecting her belief that love should be deeply felt and openly displayed. This unrestrained emotion leads to heartbreak, analogous to a melody that, without the grounding of harmony, can become chaotic and unstructured.

Austen’s narrative is not only a personal journey for the Dashwood sisters but also a critique of the societal norms of her time, much like how a symphony can reflect the cultural contexts of its creation. The rigid class system and the societal expectation that women’s fortunes are tied to marriage are themes that Austen deftly critiques. Through Elinor and Marianne, she examines the limited roles available to women and the pressures to conform. This thematic exploration is similar to how composers use musical elements to comment on and reflect their societal contexts.

The secondary characters in “Sense and Sensibility” further enrich the narrative and enhance the musical metaphor. Edward Ferrars and Colonel Brandon, representing different aspects of musical theory, add depth to the story. Edward’s struggle with duty versus desire mirrors the tension between harmony and dissonance in music. His ultimate choice of honor over convenience is like resolving dissonance into consonance, achieving a pleasing and balanced outcome. Colonel Brandon’s steadfast love for Marianne, in contrast to Willoughby’s capriciousness, represents a melodic line that is both beautiful and enduring, emphasizing the importance of balance and consistency in both music and life.

Lucy Steele and Mrs. Jennings, the secondary female characters, add complexity and texture to the narrative, much like counterpoint in music. Counterpoint involves the interaction of independent melodies, creating a rich and intricate tapestry. Lucy Steele’s manipulative cunning and Mrs. Jennings’s boisterous matchmaking efforts serve as counterpoints to the Dashwood sisters’ more nuanced characterizations. These characters illustrate the various strategies women employ to navigate societal constraints, much like how different melodic lines can interact and influence each other in a musical composition.

The resolution of “Sense and Sensibility” can be likened to the final cadence in a symphony, providing closure and a sense of completeness. Elinor’s marriage to Edward and Marianne’s union with Colonel Brandon suggest a harmonious balance between sense and sensibility. Just as a well-crafted symphony integrates harmony and melody to create a cohesive whole, the Dashwood sisters’ growth illustrates the necessity of blending rationality with emotional depth. Elinor learns to express her emotions more freely, while Marianne tempers her sensibility with greater prudence, achieving a synthesis that leads to personal fulfillment and stability.

In conclusion, viewing “Sense and Sensibility” through the lens of musical composition provides a unique perspective on the balance between structure and expression, reason and emotion. Through the contrasting lives of Elinor and Marianne Dashwood, Austen explores the complexities of human nature and societal expectations, much like how music theory helps us understand the interplay between harmony and melody. By comparing the novel to a symphony, we gain a deeper appreciation for the delicate balance required to navigate life’s challenges, achieving harmony in both our personal relationships and our broader societal interactions. This unique perspective not only enriches our understanding of Austen’s work but also highlights the timeless relevance of finding balance in all aspects of life.

Did you like this example?

260

11