Breaking Self-Destructive Behavior Patterns

Irving Howe’s definition of modernism reveals how Jamaica Kincaid’s Girl diverges from Hemingway’s A Clean, Well-Lighted Place. ” According to Howe, modernism is characterized by themes of despair, the inherent problematic nature of existence, and self-defeat. Through this lens, Hemingway’s work aligns more closely with modernist principles than Kincaid’s. While Kincaid addresses societal inequalities, particularly gender imbalances, Hemingway delves into the existential despair that epitomizes modernist literature. This essay argues that Hemingway’s story better encapsulates modernist themes through its exploration of existential despair, the complexities of human suffering, and the pervasive sense of self-defeat, making it a quintessential example of modernist literature in contrast to Kincaid’s narrative.

Exploration of Despair

The first aspect of modernism, despair, is vividly illustrated in Hemingway's “A Clean, Well-Lighted Place.” The story is steeped in existential angst, reflected in the lives of its characters. The older waiter’s musings about life’s futility, encapsulated in the phrase “It was all a nothing and man was a nothing too,” underscore a profound sense of meaninglessness. This nihilistic outlook is a hallmark of modernist thought, suggesting that existence is devoid of inherent meaning. In contrast, Kincaid’s “Girl” lacks this overwhelming sense of despair. The mother’s instructions to her daughter, though reflective of societal constraints, do not convey existential hopelessness. Instead, they provide practical guidance for navigating a patriarchal society. The absence of despair in Kincaid’s narrative indicates a divergence from the modernist focus on existential dread.

The Problematic Nature of Human Existence

Howe's second modernist criterion, the problematic nature of human existence, is exemplified through Hemingway’s portrayal of the old man’s nightly ritual at the café. The story conveys how the human condition is inherently problematic, as the characters grapple with their internal conflicts and the external pressures of societal expectations. The older waiter’s reflection that “the human lot is inescapably problematic” emphasizes the modernist view that life’s challenges are enduring and universal. Conversely, Kincaid’s “Girl” presents a different kind of problem—the societal imposition of gender roles. While these roles are indeed problematic, the narrative does not delve into the internal struggle or existential questioning that characterizes modernist literature. The focus is on societal norms rather than the individual’s internal conflict, which limits its alignment with modernist themes.

Self-Defeat and Coping Mechanisms

The final aspect of Howe’s modernism, self-defeat, is poignantly depicted in Hemingway’s story. The older waiter and the old man both exhibit signs of self-defeat, manifesting in their inability to find meaning in life. The older waiter’s admission of lacking confidence and his repetitive assertion that life is “nada” illustrates a self-defeating mindset. This resignation to life’s futility is a core element of modernist literature, reflecting the internal struggle against a meaningless existence. In contrast, “Girl” does not portray self-defeat. The mother’s instructions, although reflective of societal pressures, do not suggest internal defeat. Rather, they imply resilience and adaptability, with the mother teaching her daughter how to navigate societal challenges. The absence of self-defeat in Kincaid’s narrative further underscores its divergence from modernist themes.

Conclusion

In conclusion, when examined through the lens of Howe’s definition of modernism, Hemingway’s “A Clean, Well-Lighted Place” emerges as a more quintessentially modernist work than Kincaid’s “Girl.” Hemingway’s narrative encapsulates the despair, problematic nature of existence, and self-defeat that define modernist literature, offering a profound exploration of the human condition. In contrast, Kincaid’s focus on societal inequalities, while significant, lacks the existential depth and introspection characteristic of modernism. By highlighting these distinctions, this essay underscores the alignment of Hemingway’s work with modernist principles, illustrating its enduring relevance in the exploration of human despair and existential inquiry.

Did you like this example?

325

14