Sameness in the Giver

Novel "The Giver" presents a thought-provoking portrayal of a society that has embraced the concept of sameness. This society, governed by The Elders, is characterized by the absence of individual differences, emotions, and choices, all in the pursuit of equality. The protagonist, Jonas, is chosen to be the Receiver of Memories, a role that opens his eyes to the complexities of human emotions and experiences that his community is deprived of. This essay will explore the concept of sameness in "The Giver" and argue that while it aims to eliminate conflict and inequality, it also suppresses individuality and genuine human connections.

The Illusion of Equality

In "The Giver," the community's commitment to sameness begins with the removal of color perception. By eliminating colors, the society seeks to eradicate the visual differences that could lead to favoritism or discrimination. As The Giver explains, "We relinquished color when we relinquished sunshine and done away with the difference. We gained control of many things. But we had to let others go" (Lowry, 95). This quote encapsulates the trade-off between control and richness of experience. While the absence of color might prevent superficial judgments, it also strips away the beauty and diversity of the world, leaving the community in a monochrome existence.

The eradication of color is emblematic of the community's broader efforts to create uniformity and suppress individuality. In this world, people's lives are devoid of personal expression, reducing their experiences to mere shadows of what they could be. The lack of colors becomes a metaphor for the lack of depth and variety in the lives of the community members.

The Suppression of Emotion

Another fundamental aspect of sameness in the community is the suppression of emotions. The citizens are conditioned to live without the capacity to feel love, joy, or even pain. This emotional numbness is designed to maintain order and prevent conflicts arising from passionate or irrational behavior. However, this comes at the cost of genuine human connection. Jonas's realization of this is poignantly captured in his feelings for his friends Asher and Fiona: "He felt such love for Asher and Fiona, but they could not feel it back without the memories. And he could not give them those" (Lowry, 135).

This emotional void highlights the dehumanizing aspect of the society's pursuit of sameness. By stripping away emotions, the community aims to create a harmonious environment, yet it also eradicates the very essence of what it means to be human. Without emotions, relationships become shallow, and the bonds that typically enrich human life are absent. The inability to feel love or compassion isolates individuals, creating a sterile and mechanical society.

The Absence of Choice

Central to the theme of sameness is the absence of personal choice. In Jonas's society, every aspect of life is predetermined, from familial arrangements to career paths. This lack of autonomy is justified by the desire to eliminate the chaos and uncertainty that choices can bring. As Lowry illustrates through a past Receiver's experience, "Then, when he had had a choice, he had made the wrong one: the choice to leave. And now he was starving" (Lowry, 174). This highlights the community's fear of choice and its potential consequences.

However, the absence of choice also stifles individuality and personal growth. Choices, even when they lead to mistakes, are essential for learning and developing one's identity. The community's rigid control over every aspect of life reduces individuals to mere cogs in a well-oiled machine, devoid of personal agency or self-determination. This lack of freedom ultimately creates a stagnant environment, where innovation and creativity are sacrificed for the sake of stability.

Conclusion: A Monochrome Existence

In "The Giver," the pursuit of sameness creates a society that is both stable and sterile. By eliminating color, emotion, and choice, the community aims to achieve equality and harmony. However, this comes at the cost of individuality, genuine human connection, and personal growth. The novel invites readers to question whether the absence of conflict and inequality is worth the sacrifice of the richness and diversity that make life meaningful.

The exploration of sameness in "The Giver" serves as a cautionary tale about the dangers of prioritizing uniformity over individuality. While the community's intentions may be rooted in creating equality, the result is a world devoid of the very qualities that define humanity. As readers, we are challenged to consider the value of our differences and the importance of embracing the full spectrum of human experience.

Did you like this example?

966

53