Is Gatsby a Tragic Hero? Analyzing Ambition, Love, and Materialism

The Irony of Gatsby’s Greatness

The Great Gatsby is one of the most amazing pieces of American literature. Scott incorporated a lot of writing elements, such as the creation of themes, humor, and irony, to illustrate the narrative. The novel remains relevant in today’s world because Scott addressed the issues that are currently being witnessed in the economy, such as the American dream, the post-war society, wealth, and love. Jay Gatsby is represented as a character with a strong will in life.

However, I believe that the title of the novel is ironic because the materialistic nature of Gatsby, his false love, and the crowds of people that attend his parties are indications that he is not a great character.

Gatsby’s Dubious Path to Wealth

Jay Gatsby is represented as a poor character after the war who could not afford money to purchase new clothes. However, he is very rich, and at the beginning of the narration, he claims to have come across a huge amount of wealth that he doesn’t explain where it came from. As the narration progresses, we realize that he obtained his wealth through unlawful ways such as bootlegging and the stealing of securities. The protagonist associates with other characters, such as Meyer Wolfsheim and Don Cody, who bring to light how he acquired his wealth. Don Cody runs a silver mining business, and therefore, he takes Jay Gatsby aboard his yacht and gives him different job opportunities.

They sail across the world, and, at this time, it is clear that Gatsby’s character is taking a new shape. He begins climbing the ladder to an upper social status in society when it comes to wealth issues, just as he dreams of. As well, Meyer claims to have made Gatsby the person he is when asked whether he started him in business. Meyer says, “I made him”. Therefore, the bad influence that Gatsby receives from Meyer and Don forces him to join criminal activities in order to gain the wealth that he has always dreamt of. As a result, this does not make him a great person but rather a criminal who has a materialistic view of life. Jay Gatsby believes that he can win Daisy’s wealth as long as he is rich hence explaining the crowded and classy parties that he holds in his home. A great person searches for riches through hard work and considering the well-being of others by avoiding criminal activities.

The Illusion of Gatsby’s Love

Jay Gatsby claims to have always been in love with Daisy, but the manner in which he wins her heart does not make him a great person. One of his main aims for acquiring a lot of wealth is to please Daisy. He holds classy parties that display a lot of attention with the hope that Daisy will show up so that he can get a chance to talk to her. As well at the end of the narration, Nick claims that Jay Gatsby was a very close friend, but in the real sense, Gatsby knew that Nick was a friend of Daisy. Therefore, he knew that by befriending Nick and assuring him of his trust, he would be able to get close to Daisy, and this led to Nick organizing a meeting for Jay Gatsby and Daisy to meet. As a result, Nick was the only person who got to hear the love stories of Daisy from Jay because this would have played a substantial role in maintaining the love affair. In most cases, Jay sees himself as a son of God and Daisy as his trophy hence bringing out the fact that he is not committed to Daisy but rather sees her as an object that he deserves to have because he is a successful person in society.

This explains the reason why Daisy’s love for Jay Gatsby was not very strong. She existed as an image in Jay’s life during his struggle to achieve the American dream. Daisy says, “I did” love him once but love another person more. A great person is responsible for falling in love with a person for rightful purposes and letting the other party achieve the same feeling of love. Tricking someone into falling in love out of material things and creating the impression of having many friends by holding crowded parties does not make Jay Gatsby a great character but rather a coward. He should instead have worked his way into Daisy’s heart in the right way in order to become great.

Is Gatsby a Tragic Hero?

In addition, after the tragic end of Gatsby, it is clear that the crowded parties were just a show-off, and he used his wealth to get into other people’s minds. Hence, people responded by being good to him and attending the parties for personal benefits. Nick is the only character that is concerned about arranging a funeral for Gatsby despite the fact that a lot of people we see are close to him. An example is Klipspringer, who is not devastated by Gatsby’s death but is rather worried about the tennis shoes that he has lost. Therefore, this is an indication that the people who got close to Gatsby did that so that they could benefit from his wealth and not because he was a great person to befriend. As well he held crowded parties, but people were just there to have fun in life because none of them was seen touching his shoulders. A touch on the shoulder in society is a show of love and unending friendship (Lindberg, 2015). Gatsby shows a lot of hospitality to people with the aim of winning their hearts instead of befriending them in the right manner. As a result, such friendship lasts as long as he is alive because the people are only concerned about benefiting from his wealth. Nick is the only character involved in organizing his funeral, while the rest of the characters are unconcerned.

Therefore, Jay Gatsby is not a great character because, out of their love for material things, Gatsby was able to make fake friends who never helped out during his funeral, show false love for Daisy, and hold crowded parties to please society. In the current society, such people still exist, and every member of the society should identify such people and be careful when dealing with them to avoid ending up like the friends of Gatsby. Hence, digging deeper into the story of Gatsby, we realize that he had a strong will in life, but the manner in which he did things in order to achieve the American dream is what made him have a tragic end. Hence, he was not a great character.

References:

1. Scott, F. S. (2017). The Great Gatsby. Simon and Schuster.

2. Little, B. G. (2015). The Great Gatsby as an exploration of the American dream. In Twentieth-Century Literary Criticism (Vol. 339, pp. 251-258). Gale.

3. Fitzgerald, F. S. (1991). The Great Gatsby. Scribner.

4. Lindberg, S. (2015). The symbolism of West Egg and East Egg in The Great Gatsby. Lund University.

Did you like this example?

249

13