Gender Inequality in Marriage: a Literary Analysis

In examining the societal structures of yesteryears through literature, two stories, "The Story of an Hour" by Kate Chopin and "A Sorrowful Woman" by Gail Godwin, vividly illuminate the entrenched gender inequalities that plagued the institution of marriage. These narratives expose the manifold layers of oppression faced by women, highlighting their struggles under male dominance and societal expectations. The men in these stories, representative of larger societal norms, are afforded greater opportunities and are deemed more competent in political, professional, and domestic spheres, thus perpetuating gender disparity.

This essay elucidates why gender imbalance within marriage is a significant issue, underscoring how it reflects and reinforces broader societal injustices. In a patriarchal world, a woman's role is often diminished, regarded as less vital, and therefore, easily overlooked. This marginalization is a central concern of feminist criticism, which seeks to interrogate the ways literature reflects and perpetuates women's economic, political, social, and psychological oppression.

The Plight of Women in Literature

Both Chopin's "The Story of an Hour" and Godwin's "A Sorrowful Woman" provide incisive critiques of marital discontent, as they portray women trapped in roles defined by societal expectations. These women are confined to their identities as wives and mothers, trapped in marriages that offer no fulfillment. In "The Story of an Hour," Chopin depicts marriage in the nineteenth century as a binding contract, where women are relegated to subordinate roles. Mrs. Mallard, the protagonist, is introduced through her marital status, emphasizing her identity as a wife. Her apparent fragility is highlighted, yet her internal reaction to her husband's supposed death reveals a profound sense of relief and liberation.

Chopin writes, "She said it over and over under her breath: 'free, free, free!'" This reaction underscores how marriage can feel like a life sentence for women, a sentiment that culminates in Mrs. Mallard's tragic demise upon learning that her husband is alive. The narrative suggests that her heart condition symbolizes the oppressive weight of her marriage rather than joy at her husband's return.

Marriage Dynamics in "A Sorrowful Woman"

In contrast, Godwin's "A Sorrowful Woman" presents a more nuanced depiction of marital dynamics. The protagonist is overwhelmed by the relentless demands of domesticity, which ultimately lead to her demise. Her husband's attempts to alleviate her burden, though well-intentioned, fall short of providing genuine support. His temporary assistance underscores a lack of understanding of the need for sustained and equitable partnership.

Despite his efforts, the husband's failure to recognize the necessity of sharing responsibilities reflects a broader societal issue. In the story, he rearranges his life to manage household duties temporarily, saying, "We will manage until you're better, however long that is." This response highlights the notion that his involvement is a temporary measure, not a permanent commitment to equality.

The husband's actions, though seemingly considerate, do not address the underlying inequalities within the marriage. His wife's dissatisfaction stems not merely from physical exhaustion but from the emotional toll of unacknowledged labor and unfulfilled aspirations. The story underscores the importance of viewing marriage as a partnership, where both partners share responsibilities equally, rather than a hierarchical relationship where one is subservient to the other.

Conclusion: The Need for Gender Equality

Both stories poignantly illustrate how women are more acutely affected by the failures within marriage, becoming prisoners in their homes and lives. Their liberation is only achieved through death, symbolizing the ultimate escape from societal constraints. These narratives serve as a reminder that gender conflicts are deeply rooted in societal structures and personal relationships.

The stories of Mrs. Mallard and Godwin's unnamed protagonist reveal the profound impact of gender inequality, calling for a reevaluation of traditional roles within marriage. If Mr. Millard had allowed his wife to pursue her own path, and if Godwin's protagonist had received genuine support from her husband, their marriages might not have failed. These stories emphasize the need for societal change, advocating for equal opportunities and the cessation of gender prejudice to achieve socio-economic and political progress.

Did you like this example?

874

46