Self-Worth and Freedom in Steinbeck’s ‘The Chrysanthemums’

Introduction

John Steinbeck, one of the most celebrated American authors of the 20th century, was born in 1902 in Monterey County, California. His upbringing in the Salinas Valley influenced much of his literary work, which often explores themes of social justice, human dignity, and the struggles of marginalized individuals. Steinbeck's ability to create relatable characters and poignant narratives has cemented his place in American literature. Among his notable works is the short story "The Chrysanthemums," set in the 1920s-1930s, a period marked by significant social changes, particularly concerning women's rights.

This essay examines the themes of self-worth, underappreciation, and freedom in "The Chrysanthemums," arguing that Steinbeck uses the protagonist, Elisa Allen, to reflect women's struggles for recognition and autonomy during this era.

Time Era and Setting

"The Chrysanthemums" is set against the backdrop of the 1920s-1930s, a time when America was undergoing profound social transformations. The mention of "the strangers getting into their Ford Coupe" serves as a temporal marker, highlighting the era's technological advancements and societal shifts. This period was significant for women as they began to challenge traditional roles and advocate for greater rights and opportunities. Steinbeck's setting underscores these social tensions, as Elisa Allen, the protagonist, grapples with the limitations imposed on women of her time. Her rural Californian environment, coupled with the era's social norms, frames her internal and external conflicts.

Character Analysis

Elisa Allen emerges as a complex character, embodying both strength and vulnerability. Described as "lean and strong" with "eyes as clear as water," she is portrayed as a robust and independent woman. Her "gardening costume" gives her a bulky appearance, symbolizing her inner strength and defiance against societal expectations of femininity. Steinbeck uses Elisa's passion for chrysanthemums as a metaphor for her unacknowledged potential and creativity. Her interaction with the unnamed traveling handyman further illuminates her character. The handyman, depicted as a "very big man" with "calloused hands," introduces an element of mystery and serves as a catalyst for Elisa's self-awareness. Despite his rugged appearance, he represents an outsider's fleeting recognition of her worth, which momentarily empowers Elisa.

Henry Allen, Elisa's husband, embodies the era's conventional attitudes towards gender roles. His dismissive attitude towards her chrysanthemums, despite acknowledging her "gift with things," reflects a societal tendency to undervalue women's contributions unless they yield tangible, economic benefits. Henry's pragmatism stands in contrast to Elisa's yearning for personal fulfillment and recognition.

Summary and Analysis

The narrative of "The Chrysanthemums" follows Elisa Allen as she tends to her beloved flowers, symbolizing her stifled aspirations and individuality. Her husband, Henry, suggests she apply her talents to more profitable endeavors, subtly reinforcing the notion that women's work is only valuable when it translates to economic gain. Elisa's encounter with the traveling handyman marks a pivotal moment in the story. Initially, his attempts to secure work through sympathy and self-praise fail, but he succeeds by feigning interest in her chrysanthemums. Elisa's excitement at this perceived appreciation highlights her longing for validation. However, this fleeting sense of empowerment is shattered when she discovers her discarded flowers along the roadside, realizing the handyman's interest was purely manipulative.

Steinbeck masterfully weaves themes of self-worth, underappreciation, and freedom throughout the story. Elisa's self-worth is intricately tied to her chrysanthemums, as they symbolize her creativity and autonomy. Her initial pride and confidence are evident when she asserts that her plants will be "strong this coming year." However, this self-worth is precariously dependent on external validation, as demonstrated by her elation at the handyman's feigned interest and subsequent despair upon discovering her flowers' fate. Steinbeck cautions against anchoring self-worth to external factors, as they can be capricious and unreliable.

The theme of underappreciation is pervasive, manifesting in Elisa's interactions with both her husband and the handyman. Her husband's pragmatic dismissal of her talents underscores the societal tendency to devalue women's work unless it serves economic purposes. Elisa's brief connection with the handyman offers a glimpse of appreciation, yet it is ultimately superficial and self-serving. This underscores the broader societal underappreciation of women's contributions and the challenges they face in seeking recognition.

Freedom, or the lack thereof, is a subtle yet powerful theme in "The Chrysanthemums." Elisa's yearning for freedom is symbolized through her chrysanthemums, representing her desire for self-expression and autonomy. Her fleeting sense of empowerment after the handyman's visit is a momentary escape from societal constraints, but it is ultimately illusory. Steinbeck captures the complexity of women's struggles for freedom, highlighting the societal barriers that confine them.

Conclusion

In "The Chrysanthemums," John Steinbeck crafts a poignant narrative that explores themes of self-worth, underappreciation, and freedom through the character of Elisa Allen. Set against the backdrop of the 1920s-1930s, the story reflects the societal challenges women faced as they sought recognition and autonomy. Steinbeck's portrayal of Elisa's internal and external conflicts serves as a microcosm of women's broader struggles during this era. Through her story, Steinbeck invites readers to reflect on the importance of self-worth grounded in personal identity rather than external validation. The themes explored in "The Chrysanthemums" remain relevant today, as they resonate with ongoing discussions about gender equality and the recognition of women's contributions in all spheres of life.

Did you like this example?

234

10