Patriotism Contemporary Analysis

Patriotism is a concept that embodies the love and devotion one feels towards their country. However, it is not merely a scale for measuring how much a person is loved or hated. Throughout history and across different cultures, the interpretation of patriotism has varied greatly. Mark Twain captured a critical aspect of this notion when he remarked, “In the beginning of a change, the patriot is a scarce man, and brave, and hated and scorned. When his cause succeeds, the timid join him, for then it costs nothing to be a patriot.

” This perspective underlines the transformative power of a single individual in swaying the collective mindset of a nation. Since the beginning of this course, my understanding of patriotism has evolved significantly. While I have gained a deeper appreciation for its nuances, I have also encountered moments in U.S. history that compel me to question, "How could our country let this happen?"

The Good and the Bad

The journey through this course has illuminated several instances where patriotism in the United States has been both commendable and questionable. It's essential to acknowledge that not all actions perceived as unpatriotic are the result of collective national decisions. Sometimes, the actions of one individual can cast a long shadow. Adolf Hitler, for example, exemplified the antithesis of patriotism by manipulating nationalist sentiments to pursue a horrific agenda of genocide. Fortunately, his plans ultimately failed. However, when reflecting on American history, there are numerous instances where patriotism has shone brightly, showcasing the nation's deep-seated love for its people and values.

One of the less illustrious chapters in U.S. history is highlighted in Chapter 15 of the primary document book, "Voices of Freedom." Here, Andrew Johnson's Reconstruction plans are discussed, particularly the implementation of the Black Codes. These laws were ostensibly designed to establish equality for African Americans but, in reality, only served to entrench systemic discrimination. As noted, “These laws granted the freedpeople certain rights, such as legalized marriage, ownership of property, and limited access to the courts. But they denied them the right to testify in court in cases that only involved whites, serve on juries or in state militias, or to vote” (Foner, Voices of Freedom, Document 97, Chapter 15, page 7). This glaring inconsistency with the U.S. Constitution's declaration that “all men are created equal” raises the question: Why wasn't equality the reality in 1865? It seems that societal laziness and a desire to exploit the vulnerable were significant factors. True patriotism would have demanded unity and equality, rather than division and oppression.

Celebrating Courageous Patriotism

Ida B. Wells stands as a beacon of genuine patriotism. As detailed in Chapter 17 of "Voices of Freedom," Wells was an African American woman who tenaciously advocated for racial equality. Her courage in confronting the injustices of her time is encapsulated in her testimonial, “The leading colored women of Boston and Philadelphia had been invited to join in this demonstration, and they came, a brilliant array… behind a lonely, homesick girl who was an exile because she had tried to defend the manhood of her race…” (Foner, Voices of Freedom, Document 112, Chapter 17, page 68). Despite the potential repercussions, Wells stood firm in her beliefs, embodying the essence of patriotism by striving for a more unified and equitable nation. Her legacy serves as a testament to the power of individual bravery in shaping the moral fabric of a country.

Patriotism in Times of War

Another compelling facet of patriotism is its role during times of war. Chapter 19 of "Voices of Freedom" explores how war can galvanize a nation, consolidating the power of the state and uniting its people. The text states, “War sends the current of purpose and activity flowing down to the lowest level of the herd, and to its most remote branches. All the activities of society are linked together as fast as possible to this central purpose of making a military offensive or a military defense, and the state becomes what in peacetimes it has vainly struggled to become” (Foner, Voices of Freedom, Document 125, Chapter 19, page 105). This notion resonates with numerous historical instances when the United States has rallied together, displaying remarkable strength and solidarity. Such moments underscore the profound sense of collective pride and determination that can arise when people unite for a common cause.

The Dark Side of Patriotism

However, not all aspects of patriotism have been positive. The treatment of Chinese immigrants in the American West is a sobering reminder of the darker side of nationalistic fervor. The American West packet describes how Chinese immigrants, seeking freedom and a chance to work in the gold fields, were met with hostility and discrimination. In 1877, a labor rally in San Francisco devolved into an anti-Chinese riot (American West, “On the ‘Evils’ of Chinese Immigration”). This example illustrates how patriotism can be twisted into xenophobia, fueling exclusion and prejudice rather than inclusion and acceptance. Such instances challenge the very core of what it means to be patriotic and highlight the importance of vigilance in safeguarding against the misuse of patriotic sentiment.

Conclusion

In conclusion, this course has profoundly influenced my understanding of patriotism, highlighting both its positive and negative manifestations. While I lean towards a positive interpretation, acknowledging the mistakes of the past is crucial. True patriotism involves making decisions that benefit not just oneself but the entire nation. It's about standing up for what's right with dignity and pride, without resorting to discrimination or slander. Throughout history, countless examples of patriotism have left an indelible mark, but these four instances have significantly shaped my perspective. Patriotism is a complex and evolving concept, one that requires continuous reflection and commitment to the ideals of justice, equality, and unity.

Did you like this example?

1180

62