The Insider-Outsider Dynamics in Jane Eyre

Between the pages of Charlotte Brontë's "Jane Eyre," a young outsider's journey from childhood rebel to self-possessed woman challenges Victorian society's rigid boundaries. Jane is frequently perceived as a threat by other characters because she either differs from those around her or her views challenge societal norms. Although Jane spends much of her life as an outsider, she often chooses this role, believing herself to be intellectually superior to those around her. Her journey, however, is more than just about seeking belonging; it is about redefining what belonging means to her personal identity and societal expectations.

The Early Years at Gateshead Hall

In the opening pages of the novel, Jane is depicted as a girl physically and emotionally treated as an outsider. Growing up at Gateshead Hall with her aunt and cousins, Jane is never treated like family. She is consistently reminded of her inferior status and is taught from a young age that she is not equal to those surrounding her. For instance, she is forced to refer to her cousin John Reed as "Master," and when she protests, she is harshly told, "No; you are less than a servant, for you do nothing for your keep. There, sit down and think over your wickedness" (17, Barnes & Noble Edition). Being an outsider at Gateshead Hall, Jane isn’t discouraged by this but rather prefers it because she believes she is superior, intellectually, to those around her. Although Jane refers to herself as "humbled by the consciousness of my physical inferiority to Eliza, John, and Georgina Reed" (11), she implies that her intelligence outweighs her physical shortcomings. This belief enables her to cope with her exclusion and fuels her desire to separate herself from the Reed children. Beyond emotional isolation, Jane is physically an outsider within Gateshead Hall. She is often locked away or kept separate from the family, a point emphasized when she is sent to the Red Room as punishment. The room is described as "chill, because it seldom had a fire; it was silent, because remote from the nursery and kitchens; solemn, because it was known to be so seldom entered" (19). This physical separation mirrors her emotional isolation and highlights her outsider status within the Reed household. Jane's time at Gateshead Hall lays the foundation for her struggle with both herself and societal norms, as she has never been taught what it means to be an insider or how to become one.

The Search for Belonging at Lowood Institution

Leaving Gateshead Hall and entering Lowood Institution marks Jane's first foray into society, allowing her to experience the nuances between being an insider and an outsider. Initially, Jane continues to exist as an outsider. Mr. Brocklehurst, the school's supervisor, publicly humiliates her, labeling her a "little castaway; not a member of the true flock, but evidently an interloper and an alien" (78). His attempts to ostracize her highlight society's inclination to marginalize those who do not conform. However, Jane eventually finds acceptance through connections with Miss Temple and Helen Burns at Lowood. Miss Temple serves as a motherly figure, providing Jane with guidance and comfort, while Helen becomes her first true friend. Their relationships allow Jane to feel a sense of belonging for the first time in her life.

These connections profoundly impact Jane's development. Through Miss Temple, she learns to recognize and admire qualities she values, ultimately aiding her maturation. Helen, in contrast, acts as a foil, particularly regarding religion and submissiveness. Despite their differences, Jane treasures her friendship with Helen, which offers her an insider's perspective. Jane's willingness to endure pain for the sake of love, illustrated when she tells Helen, "If others don’t like me, I would rather die than live—I cannot bear to be solitary and hated" (70), demonstrates her craving for acceptance. However, Jane's newfound sense of belonging is fleeting. Helen's death and Miss Temple's departure plunge Jane back into isolation, underscoring her internal struggle with exclusion and her longing for love and acceptance.

Thornfield Hall: The Quest for Equality

After leaving Lowood, Jane becomes a governess at Thornfield Hall, where she meets Mr. Rochester. Her relationship with him complicates her understanding of belonging and challenges her desire for equality. Mr. Rochester is the first person to intellectually challenge Jane, and she begins to equate this intellectual stimulation with love and acceptance. Jane asserts their equality by stating, "I am sure he is… though rank and wealth sever us widely, I have something in brain and heart, in my blood and nerves, that assimilates me mentally to him" (208). Her relationship with Mr. Rochester represents a departure from societal norms, as she is valued for her character rather than her social standing.

Mr. Rochester, intrigued by Jane's outsider status, is drawn to her precisely because she challenges him. Their mutual attraction is fueled by their shared desire to transcend societal roles: Jane seeks equality while Rochester yearns to escape the confines of his privileged position. However, Jane's quest for equality is tested when she discovers secrets about Rochester, prompting her to reevaluate her place in the relationship and society.

Finding a True Home at Marsh End

Jane's journey takes a pivotal turn when she leaves Thornfield and finds herself at Marsh End, where she discovers her family. Running away from Mr. Rochester, Jane experiences physical and emotional deprivation, symbolizing her search for true acceptance. At Marsh End, she finds a semblance of stability and belonging, discovering her relatives and finding an intellectual match with her cousins, Diana and Mary. Her dream of starting a small school is realized with the help of her cousin St. John Rivers, who offers an alternative to the life promised by Mr. Rochester.

Despite the positive aspects of life at Marsh End, Jane is not satisfied. St. John views her as inferior, both intellectually and because she is a woman. Jane's assertion, "I have a woman’s heart, but not where you are concerned; for you I have only a comrade’s constancy; a fellow-soldier’s frankness, fidelity, fraternity" (472), reflects her recognition of the inequality in their relationship. Unlike with Mr. Rochester, Jane is valued for her intellect and character at Marsh End, but she ultimately desires a relationship where she is viewed as an equal.

Conclusion

Jane Eyre's journey throughout the novel is a complex exploration of what it means to be an insider and outsider. Her experiences at Gateshead Hall, Lowood Institution, Thornfield Hall, and Marsh End shape her understanding of belonging and identity. Jane consistently grapples with societal expectations and her desire for equality, ultimately finding fulfillment in a relationship where she is valued for her intellect and character. Her story highlights the struggle for personal identity and societal acceptance, illustrating the nuanced dynamics of insider-outsider roles. By the novel's end, Jane achieves a sense of belonging that transcends social class, affirming her belief in the importance of character over status.

Did you like this example?

593

31