Dunbar’s Transformation in Dances with Wolves

Cultural boundaries blur like prairie dust as Lieutenant Dunbar finds his true self among the people he was sent to fight. The movie, set against the backdrop of the American frontier, challenges the conventional portrayal of Native Americans as mere antagonists by presenting their story from their own perspective. The storyline centers around Dunbar's journey from being a Union soldier to becoming an integral part of the Comanche tribe. This essay will analyze the character traits of Lieutenant Dunbar that compel him to abandon his allegiance to America and embrace a new life with the Comanche people.

Through examining Dunbar's bravery, adaptability, empathy, and leadership, we can understand how these qualities facilitate his transformation and acceptance within the Comanche tribe.

Bravery and Creativity

Lieutenant John Dunbar's bravery is first and foremost exhibited during the Civil War, where he earns recognition not only for his valor but also for his innovative tactics. Rather than succumbing to despair over his impending leg amputation, Dunbar takes a daring ride on horseback directly in front of enemy lines, which serves as a surprising distraction to the Confederate troops. This act of courage results in his army gaining the upper hand, leading to Union victory. Dunbar's actions during this battle not only highlight his willingness to face danger head-on but also demonstrate his ability to think outside the box when confronted with dire situations. His bravery is further illustrated when he defends the Comanche village from the Pawnee, showcasing his commitment to protecting those he has come to see as his own. This creative and fearless nature garners him respect from both his fellow soldiers and the Comanche people, setting the stage for his eventual integration into their community.

Adaptability and Connection

Dunbar's decision to request a post on the western frontier, despite its deserted condition, underscores his adaptability and desire for a fresh start. Upon arrival, he takes on the task of repairing and revitalizing the fort, a testament to his industriousness and resourcefulness. His choice to remain in solitude at the fort speaks to his self-assured nature and his willingness to embrace the unknown. As he gradually becomes acquainted with the Comanche tribe, Dunbar demonstrates an openness to new experiences and a genuine curiosity about their customs and way of life. His adaptability is further reflected in his interactions with the tribe, where he sheds his previous identity and immerses himself in their culture. Dunbar's ability to connect with the tribespeople on a personal level is evident in his relationships with individuals like Kicking Bird and Stands With A Fist, a white woman raised by the tribe. Through these connections, Dunbar begins to understand and appreciate the richness of Comanche culture, ultimately leading him to question his own loyalties and identity.

Empathy and Cooperation

Dunbar's empathy and cooperative spirit play significant roles in his acceptance by the Comanche people. From the outset, he displays compassion by rescuing Stands With A Fist when she is injured, an act that endears him to the tribe and marks the beginning of his deep bond with them. His empathy extends to understanding the struggles faced by the Comanche in their conflicts with the Pawnee. By choosing to stand alongside them in times of war and hardship, Dunbar proves himself a trusted ally. Furthermore, his cooperative nature is evident in his willingness to participate in communal activities such as buffalo hunts, where he showcases both his skills and his respect for the tribe's traditions. Dunbar's ability to work harmoniously with the Comanche demonstrates his commitment to their collective well-being and underscores his transformation from an outsider to a member of the community.

Leadership and Loyalty

Dunbar's leadership qualities emerge prominently as he navigates the complexities of his dual identity. His experiences as a Union soldier imbue him with a sense of duty and the ability to lead others, traits that he carries over to his interactions with the Comanche. His leadership is not merely about directing others, but about inspiring trust and fostering unity. This is evident when he leads the Comanche to victory against the Pawnee, earning their admiration and solidifying his place within the tribe. Additionally, Dunbar's loyalty to the Comanche is tested when he is offered a position by the American army to serve as an interpreter. His refusal to betray the tribe by accepting the offer demonstrates his unwavering commitment to his new community. Even when faced with charges of treason, Dunbar's loyalty remains steadfast, highlighting the profound transformation he has undergone.

Conclusion: A Journey of Transformation

In summary, "Dances with Wolves" presents a compelling narrative of transformation, as Lieutenant John Dunbar evolves from a Union soldier to a respected member of the Comanche tribe. Through his bravery, adaptability, empathy, and leadership, Dunbar transcends cultural barriers and challenges preconceived notions of loyalty and identity. His journey serves as a testament to the power of human connection and the capacity for change. The film not only redefines the roles of protagonist and antagonist but also invites viewers to reconsider the complexities of cultural interaction and the enduring impact of empathy and understanding. Dunbar's story is a poignant reminder of the importance of embracing diversity and recognizing the shared humanity that unites us all.

Did you like this example?

522

27