A Landmark Case: Korematsu V. United States and its Legacy

Korematsu v. United States stands out as a big controversial chapter in American legal history. Back in 1944 the Supreme Court made a call to back the internment of Japanese Americans during World War II all in the name of national security. Fred Korematsu a Japanese American citizen found himself at the heart of this showdown when he refused to follow orders to go to an internment camp. His arrest and conviction set the stage for a legal showdown that went all the way to the highest court in the land raising serious questions about rights racial bias and government authority.

Fred Korematsu’s beef with Executive Order 9066 which allowed the internment of Japanese Americans boiled down to his belief that it was flat-out racist and trampled on basic constitutional rights. When Korematsu got nabbed for dodging the internment he argued his conviction should be thrown out because the order and what followed weren’t kosher under the Constitution. But the Supreme Court didn’t see it his way voting 6-3 against him. Their reasoning? They figured keeping tabs on spies trumped Korematsu’s personal rights during a time of war.

Justice Hugo Black who penned the majority opinion said the internment was a must-do move for wartime. He stressed they weren’t letting race sway their decision but were laser-focused on safeguarding national security when it mattered most. But not everyone in the court agreed. Justice Frank Murphy in his dissent slammed the internment as a race-based move that plunged “deep into the ugly abyss of racism.”

Korematsu v. United States has sparked major debates and backlash over the years. Scholars legal eagles and civil rights champs have blasted it as a major flop in standing up for civil liberties and another example of the court giving a green light to keeping minorities down. Some even put it in the same league as other infamous court cases like Dred Scott v. Sandford and Plessy v. Ferguson where the court backed unfair practices.

As time rolled on after Korematsu there’s been a bigger push to face up to the raw deal Japanese Americans got during World War II. In 1983 a federal court threw out Korematsu’s conviction saying the government had hid proof that showed Japanese Americans weren’t the spies they’d been made out to be. This was a huge win for Korematsu and a strong nod to the harm done during those tough times.

The shadow of Korematsu v. United States still hangs over talks today about rights security and racial fairness. It’s a glaring reminder of how easily rights can get tossed aside when the country feels threatened. The case warns us loud and clear to keep our eyes peeled and not let anyone steamroll over our rights even when things get hairy. And in 2018 the Supreme Court put a nail in the coffin of Korematsu’s ruling in Trump v. Hawaii with Chief Justice John Roberts saying flat-out it was “dead wrong from day one.”

Even with that the lessons from Korematsu v. United States are a big deal. It shows why we’ve gotta have tough laws and rules to stop folks in power from doing wrong and trampling on our rights. It also shines a light on brave souls like Fred Korematsu who took a stand against unfairness and fought hard for justice and equality.

In sum Korematsu v. United States is a landmark that still shapes how we look at rights and what the government can do. It’s a stark reminder of how racism can steer things wrong and why we’ve gotta fight to keep our rights in check no matter what. As we think back on this case it’s key to remember the lessons it teaches and to keep pushing to keep our rights and freedoms safe for everyone.

Did you like this example?

282

12