Women’s Struggles in 19th Century Oppressive Literature

Introduction

In the literary realm of the 19th century, Charlotte Perkins Gilman's "The Yellow Wallpaper" and Kate Chopin's "The Story of an Hour" stand as poignant critiques of the oppressive conditions faced by women under male-dominated societal norms. Both short stories delve into the lives of their respective protagonists, illustrating how these women navigate the overwhelming forces of loss and oppression. Although both women experience significant personal losses, the nature and impact of these losses diverge markedly, leading to contrasting emotional outcomes.

This essay will explore the similarities and differences between the protagonists' experiences of oppression and loss, while also examining how these experiences shape their ultimate responses, ranging from despair to liberation. Through this analysis, we can better understand the complex dynamics of gender roles and personal agency in a time when women were granted few rights and faced severe societal limitations.

Oppression and Societal Constraints

During the late 1800s, women were largely confined to roles defined by domesticity and subservience, with limited opportunities for self-expression or autonomy. In "The Story of an Hour," Chopin portrays a protagonist who, upon learning of her husband's death, envisions a future unburdened by the demands of a patriarchal marriage. This newfound freedom is captured in the line, “But she saw beyond that bitter moment a long procession of years to come that would belong to her absolutely. And she opened and spread her arms out to them in welcome” (Chopin 94). This quote underscores the liberation she feels at the prospect of living for herself, free from the perpetual obligation to cater to her husband’s needs. Conversely, Gilman’s protagonist in "The Yellow Wallpaper" is subjected to her husband’s paternalistic control, evident when he insists, “I must take care of myself for his sake” (Gilman 85). Her struggle to reclaim her sense of self is thwarted by societal expectations that prioritize her husband's well-being over her own mental health. Both examples highlight the oppressive environments these women navigate, yet their responses to such oppression differ starkly.

The Right to Self-Expression

A notable aspect of Gilman's narrative is the restricted freedom of expression faced by the protagonist, Jane. Her clandestine writing represents a desperate attempt to assert her individuality in a world that dismisses her thoughts and feelings as trivial. She writes in secret, fearing her husband’s disapproval: “I did write for a while in spite of them; but it does exhaust me a good deal—having to be so sly about it, or else meet with heavy opposition” (Gilman 80). In contrast, the protagonist in Chopin’s story finds an internal voice that celebrates her autonomy upon her husband's death. The oppressive constraints that bind these women are emblematic of a broader societal refusal to acknowledge women's intellectual and emotional capabilities. While Jane’s narrative illustrates the detrimental effects of silencing female expression, Chopin’s protagonist briefly experiences the transformative potential of self-assertion, albeit within a limited window of perceived freedom.

Experiences of Loss

The theme of loss manifests differently in the two stories, shaping the protagonists' emotional journeys. In "The Yellow Wallpaper," Jane's loss is internal and psychological. Her fixation on the wallpaper symbolizes her deteriorating mental state and the loss of her self-identity. This is poignantly captured when she declares, “I’ve got out at last…in spite of you and Jane. And I’ve pulled off most of the paper, so you can’t put me back” (Gilman 92). Her reference to herself in the third person signifies her complete disassociation from her former identity. By contrast, Chopin’s protagonist experiences a tangible, external loss—her husband’s death. Despite her initial grief, she revels in the freedom his absence affords her, imagining a life dedicated to self-discovery. Chopin writes, “She knew that she would weep again when she saw the kind, tender hands folded in death” (Chopin 94), acknowledging her complex emotions but emphasizing her overriding sense of joy. This juxtaposition highlights how different forms of loss can lead to radically different outcomes.

Reactions to Loss

The contrasting reactions of the protagonists to their respective losses offer insight into their emotional and psychological states. Gilman’s Jane spirals into sorrow and isolation, her mental and physical health deteriorating as her story progresses. She confesses, “I don’t weigh a bit more…nor as much; and my appetite may be better in the evening when you are here but it is worse in the morning when you are away” (Gilman 86). Her inability to eat or gain weight exemplifies her declining condition, reflecting the oppressive forces that suffocate her spirit. On the other hand, Chopin’s protagonist finds profound joy and liberation, repeatedly uttering the word “free” as she envisions a life of personal autonomy. Chopin writes, “But she saw beyond that bitter moment a long procession of years to come that would belong to her absolutely. And she opened and spread her arms out to them in welcome” (Chopin 94). This imagery of open arms symbolizes her embrace of a future unshackled by societal expectations, contrasting sharply with Jane's entrapment.

Conclusion

In conclusion, "The Yellow Wallpaper" and "The Story of an Hour" serve as powerful commentaries on the oppressive conditions faced by women in the 19th century. Through their respective narratives, Gilman and Chopin explore themes of oppression, loss, and self-identity, offering distinct perspectives on how these forces shape women's lives. While both protagonists endure significant losses, their reactions reveal the varied emotional landscapes women navigated during this period. Gilman’s Jane succumbs to despair and madness, symbolizing the destructive impact of oppression, while Chopin’s protagonist temporarily revels in the prospect of freedom and selfhood. These stories underscore the resilience and complexity of women’s experiences, highlighting the enduring struggle for autonomy and self-expression in a patriarchal world. Through their nuanced portrayals, both authors invite readers to reflect on the historical and ongoing challenges faced by women striving for equality and self-determination.

Did you like this example?

1546

81