Race and Family in “Color of Water”

James McBride's "The Color of Water" is a poignant exploration of identity, race, and the complexities of familial relationships. This autobiography delves into the life and struggles of McBride's Jewish mother, Ruth Deborah Shilsky, born Ruchel Dwajra Zylska in Poland. As she navigates her transformative journey in America, Ruth's story unfolds as one of self-discovery, resilience, and the confrontation of a past she once feared to share. Through McBride's narrative, readers witness the profound impact of Ruth's experiences on her son, James, and their shared quest for identity amidst the turbulent backdrop of racial and cultural diversity.

Ruth's Journey of Transformation

Ruth's life is a testament to the enduring spirit of an outsider striving to find her place in a world that often rejected her. From her early days in Poland to her upbringing in America, Ruth consistently faced adversity. Her struggles began in white-dominated schools and extended to her neighborhood and even her own family. Her father's oppressive presence, characterized by racism and emotional abuse, left indelible marks on her life. Yet, despite the challenges, Ruth emerged as a woman of contradictions—someone who kept her past hidden yet displayed unwavering strength in raising her children.

The transformation of Ruth from a woman who concealed her heritage to one who embraced her identity is central to the narrative. Initially, she avoided discussing her past with James, fearing judgment and rejection. However, as the story progresses, Ruth confronts her self-doubt and begins to share her experiences, allowing her son to gain a deeper understanding of his heritage. This transformation is a testament to Ruth's resilience and serves as a powerful example of how embracing one's past can lead to personal growth and healing.

James's Identity Struggles

For James, growing up with a mother who seemed enigmatic and disconnected from her past presented its challenges. He often grappled with feelings of shame and confusion, unable to reconcile his mother's Jewish identity with his own African-American heritage. The societal norms and prejudices he encountered further complicated his understanding of self. James internalized the conflicting messages about race and identity, leading to moments of self-doubt and questioning.

Throughout the book, James's search for identity is a recurring theme. He navigates a world where he is constantly reminded of his differences, both in appearance and background. This struggle is poignantly illustrated when James questions his own origin, prompted by his brother Richie's taunts about adoption. In response, James creates an imaginary world where he envisions a boy who looks like him but possesses the freedom he yearns for. This imaginary construct highlights James's desire to break free from the constraints of societal expectations and discover his true self.

Tateh's Influence and Racism

Ruth's father, Tateh, embodies the racial prejudice and bigotry prevalent during that era. His actions and beliefs cast a long shadow over Ruth's life and significantly impact James's understanding of race. Tateh's refusal to accept Ruth's marriage to a black man underscores the deeply entrenched racism within their family. His discriminatory practices in his store, where he charged black customers exorbitant prices, reveal the pervasive racial tensions of the time.

The narrative vividly illustrates the impact of Tateh's racism on Ruth and her family. His actions serve as a stark reminder of the systemic inequalities faced by marginalized communities. Despite his oppressive influence, Ruth defies her father's expectations and forges her own path, marrying two black men and raising a family in a predominantly black community. Her defiance is a powerful statement against the oppressive norms of her upbringing, highlighting her determination to create a life defined by love and acceptance rather than prejudice and hatred.

Ruth's Contradictions and Strength

Ruth's complex character is marked by contradictions that both intrigue and confound her children. She is a woman who often says one thing but believes another, embodying a duality that reflects her multifaceted identity. Her decision to raise her children in a predominantly black community, despite being a Jewish woman, underscores her belief in transcending racial boundaries. Ruth's refusal to affiliate herself with any particular race highlights her desire to create a world where her children are not defined by the color of their skin.

Ruth's strength as a mother is evident in her unwavering dedication to her children's well-being. She draws wisdom from each of them, allowing their experiences to shape her perspective and provide a sense of healing from her own tumultuous past. When Rosetta runs away, Ruth is reminded of her own departure from her family, prompting moments of introspection and growth. Through these experiences, Ruth gains insight into the complexities of identity and the importance of embracing one's heritage.

The Role of Race in James's Life

The theme of race is intricately woven into James's narrative, shaping his understanding of himself and the world around him. His fear of the Black Panther Party, fueled by media portrayals, exemplifies the internalized racism that pervades his consciousness. This fear is a product of societal conditioning, highlighting the damaging impact of stereotypes and misinformation. James's journey to reconcile his mother's Jewish identity with his own African-American heritage is a central aspect of the narrative, reflecting the broader struggle for self-acceptance and understanding.

In a pivotal moment, James witnesses his parents' determination to establish a church in the Red Hook Community. This endeavor underscores the challenges they face in navigating a racially divided society. Ruth's ability to secure the lease for the church building, despite the owner's racism, highlights the privilege associated with her white appearance. This scene serves as a commentary on the complexities of race and privilege, illustrating how Ruth's identity as a white woman allows her to navigate spaces that her black husband cannot.

Conclusion

"The Color of Water" is a profound exploration of identity, race, and the enduring impact of familial relationships. Through the lens of Ruth and James's experiences, McBride offers readers a nuanced understanding of the complexities of race and the importance of embracing one's heritage. Ruth's transformation from a woman who conceals her past to one who embraces her identity is a testament to the power of resilience and self-discovery. James's journey to reconcile his dual heritage underscores the universal struggle for identity and acceptance. Ultimately, McBride's narrative serves as a powerful reminder of the enduring strength of the human spirit and the transformative power of love and acceptance in the face of adversity.

Did you like this example?

293

12