Survival Themes in Dystopian Literature

In every nightmare, fear takes center stage as individuals grapple with the instinct to survive against terrifying odds. This theme is vividly explored in two distinct novels: Lois Lowry’s "The Giver" and Mindy McGinnis’ "Not a Drop to Drink." Both novels delve deeply into the concepts of fear and survival but do so in varied contexts, presenting readers with unique insights into human resilience and the struggle for life. This essay examines the similarities and differences in how fear and survival are portrayed in these novels, highlighting the profound impact of these themes on the characters' lives and decisions.

Fear in Unfamiliar Worlds

In "The Giver," the protagonist, Jonas, lives in a meticulously controlled community where fear is a rare and unsettling emotion. The novel begins with Jonas recalling an incident that instilled fear in him—an unauthorized aircraft flying over the community. This experience is significant because it disrupts the illusion of safety and predictability in Jonas's world. As he states, “It was almost December, and Jonas was beginning to become frightened” (Lowry 1). This fear is compounded when Jonas learns the truth about "release," a euphemism for euthanasia, which shakes his trust in the community's principles. Jonas's fear becomes personal when he realizes that Gabriel, a baby he's grown attached to, is at risk of being released. This fear drives him to make the courageous decision to flee the community, taking Gabriel with him to save the child from a grim fate.

In contrast, "Not a Drop to Drink" presents a more visceral and immediate fear of survival in a post-apocalyptic world where water scarcity dictates life and death. The protagonist, Lynn, lives with the constant dread of running out of water, a fear that is exacerbated by the harsh realities of her environment. Whenever the water level in the pond decreases, Lynn's anxiety intensifies, reflecting the precariousness of her existence. Her fear is not just for herself but also for her mother, who has instilled in her the ruthless instincts needed to protect their water source. The words of Lynn’s mother, “Do you want to die like this?” (McGinnis 56), serve as a chilling reminder of the constant threat they face, underscoring the relentless nature of their struggle for survival.

Survival Against All Odds

Survival is a central theme in both novels, manifesting in different yet equally compelling ways. In "The Giver," Jonas’s journey toward survival is both a physical and moral quest. His escape from the community is fraught with danger as he navigates the unknown terrain of Elsewhere. His determination to save Gabriel propels him forward, even when faced with the unknown. Jonas's survival is not just about staying alive; it is about preserving his humanity and protecting an innocent life from an oppressive system.

Similarly, in "Not a Drop to Drink," survival is a daily, tangible battle against environmental and human threats. After Lynn’s mother dies, Lynn must rely on her own ingenuity and the help of others, such as Stebbs, to secure food and water. The fear of running out of resources drives her actions, and her survival hinges on her ability to adapt to ever-changing circumstances. The bond she forms with Stebbs and Lucy illustrates the importance of community and cooperation in overcoming adversity.

Contrasts in Themes of Fear and Survival

While both novels explore fear and survival, they do so from different perspectives. In "The Giver," fear is rooted in the potential loss of individuality and freedom, as Jonas grapples with the moral implications of his society's practices. His fear is existential, focused on the broader implications of a life devoid of choice. Conversely, "Not a Drop to Drink" presents fear as a tangible, immediate concern tied to the scarcity of a vital resource. Lynn’s fear is pragmatic, driven by the need to secure basic necessities for survival.

The two novels also differ in how they depict survival. In "The Giver," survival is tied to escape and rebellion against an oppressive regime. Jonas's journey represents a quest for a better world, where freedom and choice are possible. In contrast, "Not a Drop to Drink" portrays survival as a relentless fight to maintain the status quo in a harsh, unforgiving world. Lynn’s struggle is not about changing her circumstances but enduring them.

Conclusion

In conclusion, "The Giver" and "Not a Drop to Drink" offer compelling explorations of fear and survival, each through its unique narrative lens. Jonas’s fear of losing Gabriel and his quest for a life of freedom contrast with Lynn’s pragmatic fear of water scarcity and her fight to survive in a desolate landscape. Both novels highlight the resilience of the human spirit in the face of fear and adversity, though they do so in markedly different contexts. Through their stories, these novels remind us of the fundamental human drive to survive, even when faced with seemingly insurmountable challenges.

Did you like this example?

794

33