Heroic Journeys: Comparing Mulan and Odysseus Across Cultures

Introduction

The Hero's Journey is a narrative pattern that has been widely explored in literature and film, revealing a deeper meaning beyond the surface interpretation of the phrase. This journey consists of several critical stages: The Ordinary World, Call to Adventure, Refusal of the Quest, Accepting the Call, Entering the Unknown, Supernatural Help, Talisman, Allies/Helpers, Tests, Supreme Ordeal, Reward/Journey Home, and finally, Restoring the World. These stages form a template that many characters in stories and books, often unknowingly to the reader, follow as they evolve into heroes.

This essay aims to explore the Hero's Journey through a comparative analysis of two iconic characters: Mulan from Disney's "Mulan" and Odysseus from Homer's "The Odyssey." Despite the different cultural contexts and storylines, both characters undergo transformative journeys, though with varying degrees of bravery and loyalty. This essay argues that while both Mulan and Odysseus embark on heroic quests, Mulan's journey exemplifies a more daring and courageous heroism, challenging traditional gender roles and expectations.

The Call to Adventure and Refusal

In both "Mulan" and "The Odyssey," the protagonists begin in their respective Ordinary Worlds. Odysseus enjoys a peaceful life with his wife, Penelope, and son, Telemachus, whereas Mulan struggles with societal expectations of women in ancient China. Odysseus is called to war but initially refuses, feigning madness to avoid leaving his family. His facade is dismantled when his son is put in danger, compelling him to accept the call. Mulan's call to adventure arises when her ailing father is summoned to fight the Huns. Driven by fear of losing him, she defies societal norms by proposing to take his place. Her refusal is not to the journey itself but to the limitations imposed on her as a woman. This act of defiance sets the stage for her heroic journey, highlighting her courage in challenging societal constraints.

Supernatural Aid and Allies

Both characters receive supernatural assistance, which plays a crucial role in their journeys. Odysseus is aided by the goddess Athena, who intervenes on his behalf, persuading other gods to assist him. This divine intervention underscores the importance of divine favor in Greek mythology, where heroes often rely on the gods' support. In contrast, Mulan relies on the guidance of her ancestors who send Mushu, a small dragon, to protect her. While Mushu provides comic relief and serves as a mentor, Mulan's journey is largely self-driven, emphasizing her independence and resourcefulness. This distinction highlights the different cultural perceptions of heroism, where Mulan's reliance on her own abilities contrasts with Odysseus's dependence on divine intervention.

Trials, Tests, and Supreme Ordeal

Both Mulan and Odysseus face numerous trials that test their skills and resolve. Odysseus’s journey is marked by encounters with mythical creatures and formidable challenges, such as the Cyclops, Sirens, and Scylla and Charybdis. Each trial tests his leadership and cunning, ultimately leading to the loss of his crew. Mulan, on the other hand, faces societal and military challenges. Her journey requires her to disguise herself as a man to fight alongside male soldiers, constantly risking exposure and death. Despite the absence of mythical beasts, her trials are no less daunting, as they challenge deeply entrenched gender norms and her own identity. Her ingenuity and bravery in overcoming these obstacles underscore her as a hero who defies traditional expectations, making her journey as significant as Odysseus’s.

The Reward and Restoring the World

The culmination of the Hero's Journey is the Reward and the Restoring of the World. For Odysseus, the supreme ordeal is his return to Ithaca, where he must reclaim his home from the suitors vying for his wife. Disguised as a beggar, he competes in an archery contest, proving his identity and killing the suitors. His victory restores order to his household, reuniting him with his family. Mulan's reward is multifaceted; she gains the respect of her fellow soldiers and the Emperor, ultimately earning her place and honor in her society. Her journey challenges and transforms societal views on gender roles, allowing her to be herself without the constraints of traditional femininity. Her father's acceptance and pride signify the restoration of her world, where she is celebrated for her true self.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the Hero's Journey provides a framework for analyzing the transformative quests of Mulan and Odysseus. While both characters embark on journeys filled with trials and supernatural assistance, Mulan's journey stands out as a testament to individual courage and the challenge of societal norms. Her heroism lies not only in her physical feats but in her defiance of traditional gender expectations, making her a more relatable and inspiring hero for contemporary audiences. Through this comparative analysis, it becomes evident that the Hero's Journey is a versatile narrative that transcends cultural boundaries, offering insights into the universal quest for identity, honor, and self-discovery.

Did you like this example?

1057

56