The Tension between Desire and Doctrine in Go Tell it on the Mountain

In James Baldwin's seminal work, "Go Tell It on the Mountain," young John Grimes is raised within the stringent traditions of the Christian church, a setting that creates a profound conflict between his personal desires and the duties imposed upon him by religious doctrine. This tension is a central theme of the novel, exploring how rigid religious beliefs can often repress individual desires and lead to inner turmoil. The church, with its strict guidelines on behavior and morality, becomes both a source of community and a suppressive force, highlighting the complexities of faith and identity.

The Role of the Church

The church in "Go Tell It on the Mountain" is not only a place of worship but also a cornerstone of the African American community, particularly for those of lower socioeconomic status. This storefront church, known as The Church of the Fire Baptized, serves as a moral compass, offering support and guidance while promising eternal salvation for those who adhere to its doctrines. However, its role is dual-faceted. On the one hand, it provides a sense of belonging and an outlet for emotional expression through singing, shouting, and clapping, as noted by O'Neale. This release of pent-up emotions is crucial in a community where other forms of expressing frustration and anger might not be socially acceptable.

Yet, the church also imposes a rigid moral framework that can be judgmental and exclusionary. Its members, referred to as "saints," often view themselves as morally superior to those who indulge in desires deemed sinful. This sense of moral superiority creates a division between the church's members and the broader society, fostering an environment where hypocrisy can flourish. As described in the novel, the storefront's humble origins reflect the social status of its congregation, contrasting sharply with the grandeur of churches attended by wealthier and predominantly white congregations. This disparity highlights the systemic inequalities faced by the African American community and the ways in which religion can both empower and oppress.

John's Internal Struggle

At the heart of the novel is John's internal struggle with his emerging sexuality and his desire to break free from the constraints of his religious upbringing. Baldwin masterfully captures the confusion and turmoil of adolescence, particularly for a young boy grappling with feelings that are in direct conflict with the teachings of the church. John's experiences and observations, such as the stain on the ceiling or his clandestine moments of desire, illustrate the universal struggle of coming to terms with one's identity in the face of societal expectations. These experiences serve as metaphors for his repressed desires and his longing for freedom, both physical and spiritual.

John's relationship with Elisha further complicates his understanding of himself. While the novel does not explicitly label John's sexuality, his admiration for Elisha—described in terms that are both physical and spiritual—suggests a depth of feeling that transcends simple friendship. This ambiguity allows Baldwin to explore the fluidity of desire and the ways in which it can manifest in different forms. John's feelings for Elisha, as well as his reactions to other characters, reflect his broader struggle to reconcile his personal desires with the moral framework imposed by the church.

The Hypocrisy of Religious Doctrine

The novel also delves into the hypocrisy often present within religious institutions. Characters like Gabriel, who outwardly project an image of piety while secretly engaging in sinful behavior, underscore the dissonance between public persona and private actions. Gabriel's violent tendencies and moral failings, including infidelity and theft, reveal the ways in which religious doctrine can be manipulated to serve one's needs. This hypocrisy is not lost on John, who observes the inconsistencies between the church's teachings and the behaviors of its members. The church's judgmental nature and its failure to practice the compassion it preaches contribute to John's ambivalence toward religion.

Baldwin uses these characters to question the validity of a system that promises salvation while simultaneously fostering an environment of judgment and exclusion. The novel suggests that true morality is not determined by adherence to doctrine but by the authenticity of one's actions and intentions. This critique of religious hypocrisy invites readers to reflect on the broader implications of faith and the ways in which it can both uplift and constrain.

Conclusion

Ultimately, "Go Tell It on the Mountain" poses critical questions about faith, identity, and the nature of morality. It challenges readers to consider whether it is possible to remain true to oneself while adhering to a doctrine that may not align with one's personal values. Baldwin's exploration of these themes is nuanced and thought-provoking, inviting readers to reflect on their own beliefs and the ways in which they navigate the tensions between desire and duty. The novel's enduring relevance lies in its ability to capture the complexities of human experience and the ongoing struggle for personal authenticity in the face of societal expectations.

Did you like this example?

354

15