Christopher Columbus: Hero or Villain

Why Christopher Columbus is a hero has been a topic of debate for centuries. On the second Monday of October each year, many people celebrate what is known as Christopher Columbus Day. Columbus and his accomplishments have been rewritten and retold many times in various ways. In schools, students are often taught that Christopher Columbus is an iconic Italian hero who discovered America and wanted to prove that the world was not flat. However, in other narratives, he is portrayed as a cunning, malevolent figure.

This dichotomy leads to the ongoing argument: Was Christopher Columbus a hero or a villain?

The Legend of Columbus

Christopher Columbus is traditionally taught as the man who "sailed the ocean blue in 1492" and discovered America. This narrative is underpinned by the fact that we celebrate a federal holiday in his honor. Yet, many people are unaware of the complete backstory of his voyages and the implications of his actions. As researchers uncover more details, controversy has arisen regarding the merits of honoring Columbus as a hero. According to one of his journals, Columbus set sail across the Atlantic Ocean from Spain four times—in 1492, 1493, 1498, and 1502. These voyages were attempts to find a direct water route west from Europe to Asia, a mission in which he was ultimately unsuccessful.

Despite this, Columbus stumbled upon the Americas during his voyages, a land already inhabited by millions of indigenous people. His discovery challenges the notion of him as the "founder" of America. The actual revelation that Columbus did not find an uninhabited land was later clarified by explorer Amerigo Vespucci. Vespucci's accounts highlighted that Columbus's claims were inaccurate, which in turn, paint Columbus as more of a villain than a hero.

Columbus: A Controversial Figure

A secondary source that sheds light on Columbus's controversial legacy is a report by Arthur Schlesinger Jr. in The American, published in 1992, marking the "500th anniversary" of Columbus landing on an island in San Salvador. Schlesinger noted, "the great hero of the nineteenth century seems well on the way to becoming the great villain of the twenty-first." This shift in perception suggests that the truths about Columbus were beginning to resurface in modern times. The article described Columbus as a "pioneer of oppression, racism, slavery, rape, theft, vandalism, extermination, and ecological desolation." These attributes contribute to the perception of Columbus as a villain in the eyes of many contemporary critics.

While Columbus made significant contributions, such as opening up the Americas to European exploration and subsequent colonization, his methods and their consequences were often brutal and destructive. The indigenous populations suffered immensely due to his actions and those of subsequent explorers, leading to a legacy that many view as villainous rather than heroic.

Reevaluating Columbus's Legacy

In conclusion, the question of whether Columbus is a hero or villain remains contentious. While he achieved notable feats, such as navigating uncharted territories, the negative impacts of his actions often overshadow his accomplishments. The primary and secondary sources discussed reveal both sides of his legacy. Given the backstory and the suffering that followed his voyages, many argue that Columbus Day should not be celebrated as it currently is. Instead, it might be more appropriate to use this day to reflect on the broader impact of his journeys.

Ultimately, why Christopher Columbus is a hero or villain depends largely on one's perspective of history. As new generations reassess historical figures, it is crucial to consider all facets of their legacies. Moving forward, it is important to engage with these narratives critically, acknowledging both Columbus's achievements and his transgressions.

Did you like this example?

1369

72