Race and Identity in the Color of Water Explored

Introduction

James McBride's "The Color of Water: A Black Man’s Tribute to His White Mother" serves not only as a heartfelt memoir but also as a profound exploration of race, identity, and familial bonds. McBride intricately weaves his narrative as a biracial child with the remarkable life story of his mother, Ruth McBride Jordan—a white Jewish woman who defied societal norms by raising twelve successful biracial children. This essay examines "The Color of Water" through the lens of Ethnic Studies, focusing on the concepts of controlling images and skin-color stratification.

By delving into these themes, the essay aims to demonstrate the book's relevance in a classroom setting, offering insights into the complex dynamics of race and identity.

Structure and Narrative

The book employs a dual narrative structure, alternating between James McBride's reflections and his interviews with his mother, Ruth. This format allows readers to gain a comprehensive understanding of both Ruth's life and James's experiences growing up. Ruth's story begins with her birth as Ruchel Dwajra Zylska in an Orthodox Jewish family in 1921. Her father, Fishel Shilsky, was an Orthodox rabbi with a troubled past, while her mother, Hudis, was a Polish Jew whose health was frail. Ruth's family immigrated to the United States, seeking a better life but encountering new challenges, particularly in the racially segregated environment of the Jim Crow South.

Ruth's formative years were marked by prejudice, both for her Jewish heritage and her relationships with African Americans. Her close friendship with an African American boy named Peter exemplified the racial tensions of the time. Ruth's story is one of resilience, navigating a world defined by racial and cultural divides. She eventually moved to New York, where she met and married Dennis McBride, James's father. Their interracial marriage faced societal resistance, yet it was filled with love and mutual respect.

Controlling Images

One of the Ethnic Studies concepts that can be applied to "The Color of Water" is controlling images. These are gendered depictions in the media that shape perceptions of African Americans. In the 1960s, James McBride encountered controlling images through media portrayals of the Black Power movement. The media often depicted Black Power activists as violent and threatening, which deeply affected James, leading him to fear for his mother's safety. He recalls a Black Panther rally, where the fervent chants of "Black Power!" instilled a sense of dread, believing that his white mother could be a target.

This fear highlights the power of controlling images in shaping perceptions and influencing relationships. Despite being a person of color, James internalized the media's depiction of Black Power as a threat, illustrating how pervasive and influential these images can be. The media's focus on anger and confrontation overshadowed the movement's broader goals of empowerment and justice, contributing to misunderstandings and racial tensions.

Skin-Color Stratification

Another critical concept in "The Color of Water" is skin-color stratification, where resources and status are distributed unequally based on skin color. This theme is vividly illustrated through the experiences of Ruth's father, Rabbi Shilsky, who ran a grocery store in Suffolk, Virginia. He exploited African American customers by charging exorbitant markups on goods, capitalizing on their lack of access to alternative resources. Ruth observed the hypocrisy and injustice of her father's actions, recognizing the systemic inequalities that marginalized communities faced.

Skin-color stratification extends beyond economic exploitation, influencing social interactions and opportunities. Ruth's marriage to Dennis McBride challenged societal norms, as interracial relationships were stigmatized and often met with hostility. Despite these challenges, Ruth and Dennis built a life grounded in love and mutual respect, defying societal expectations and creating a nurturing environment for their children.

Conclusion

In "The Color of Water," James McBride offers a poignant exploration of race, identity, and resilience. By examining the book through the lenses of controlling images and skin-color stratification, we gain a deeper understanding of the complexities of biracial identity and the enduring impact of racial dynamics. Ruth McBride Jordan's story is a testament to the power of love and determination in overcoming adversity. Her legacy, as seen through the accomplishments of her children, underscores the importance of challenging societal norms and embracing diversity. This essay demonstrates the relevance of "The Color of Water" in an academic setting, providing valuable insights into the intersections of race, identity, and family.

By reimagining James McBride's narrative through the framework of Ethnic Studies, we uncover layers of meaning that enrich our understanding of the book and its themes. The exploration of controlling images and skin-color stratification not only enhances our appreciation of the narrative but also invites us to reflect on the broader implications of race and identity in contemporary society. Through Ruth and James's stories, we are reminded of the enduring power of storytelling to illuminate the complexities of the human experience and to foster empathy and understanding across diverse communities.

Did you like this example?

538

28