Literary Theory as Social Commentary

Literary works often serve as mirrors reflecting society and its traditions, aiming for readers to grasp the lessons and messages they embody. Critical theories, therefore, are reflective assessments and critiques of society and culture, applying knowledge to interpret these messages and integrate them into our lives. By delving into the depths of literary analysis, we gain a more profound understanding of the world we inhabit and the values that guide it.

Reader Response theory, Deconstruction theory, and Ethical theory are pivotal in uncovering the meanings of a text, each offering a unique lens through which readers can enhance their comprehension of the underlying messages.

Reader Response theory confines analysis to the reader’s experience when engaging with the text, emphasizing the subjective nature of interpretation. The interpretations of a text depend not only on the individual reader but also on the time and context in which the piece is encountered.

Reader Response

The Reader Response theory anticipates that readers possess prior knowledge of particular topics to discern the broader meaning of a literary piece. Works that lend themselves to analysis through this theory include Nathaniel Hawthorne’s "Young Goodman Brown" and F. Scott Fitzgerald’s "The Great Gatsby." In "The Great Gatsby," Fitzgerald critiques the American Dream and its inherent corruption. The protagonist, Gatsby, initially aspires to transcend poverty, often through illicit means, to gain respect, wealth, and the love of Daisy. Despite his apparent success, his efforts ultimately prove futile.

Within the narrative, a stark division exists between those possessing inherited wealth and those who have recently acquired it. Tom Buchanan epitomizes traditional wealth, having inherited his fortune rather than earning it through personal effort. This portrayal reflects the historical narrative of male dominance across various life aspects. Tom’s characterization as cruel suggests that Fitzgerald challenges traditional themes, including wealth and patriarchal dominance. Gatsby’s quest leads him to abandon his true self to conform to societal expectations, ultimately losing his desired outcome.

Daisy symbolizes the unattainable American Dream for Gatsby, representing the tradition that prevents him from embracing his authentic self. Similarly, "Young Goodman Brown" reveals the complexity of good and evil, prompting readers to question traditional moral standards. Goodman Brown, a character embodying conventional devotion, discovers that those he admired have betrayed their faith, leading him to question his identity and the values he has long upheld.

Deconstruction

Deconstruction theory encourages readers to look beyond the apparent, teaching that not everything is as it seems. Symbols and characters warrant thorough analysis to fully grasp the message. William Faulkner’s "A Rose for Emily" exemplifies this theory, highlighting the South’s resistance to abandoning old traditions. Emily and her home symbolize the decay of the past and Southern traditions. Emily, trapped by societal and cultural paralysis, clings to her aristocratic demeanor even after financial decline.

Faulkner illustrates Emily’s denial of her father’s death as a refusal to accept the financial and social changes his passing entails. Despite her desperate circumstances, Emily’s involvement with Homer, a Northerner of lower social standing, suggests her adaptability. However, her society’s inability to embrace progress ultimately drives Emily to retreat into a private world frozen in the past. Similarly, Harper Lee’s "To Kill a Mockingbird" challenges Southern traditions, prompting readers to question and reconsider entrenched beliefs.

Set in Maycomb, a quintessential Southern town, the narrative exposes ingrained prejudices, particularly regarding race and class. The racially charged trial of Tom Robinson, a black man accused of raping a white woman, underscores the town’s inability to transcend its biases. Despite compelling evidence of Tom’s innocence, the all-white jury convicts him, reflecting the deeply rooted racism that defies the ideal of equality. Both stories prompt readers to recognize the destructive nature of enduring traditions and the need for change.

Ethical

Ethical theory engages readers through principles of morality, exploring well-defined standards of right and wrong that shape human character and conduct. This theory can intersect with other critical approaches, allowing literature to be analyzed from multiple perspectives. Shirley Jackson’s "The Lottery" and Kate Chopin’s "The Story of an Hour" exemplify ethical considerations, delving into darker aspects of human nature and societal norms.

"The Story of an Hour" addresses the constraints imposed by marriage, highlighting the protagonist’s realization of newfound freedom following her husband’s presumed death. Mrs. Mallard’s brief joy at the prospect of liberation underscores the oppressive nature of traditional gender roles. Conversely, Jackson’s "The Lottery" explores the irrationality of societal traditions through a ritualistic stoning, revealing the destructive power of conformity and the fear of breaking from ancestral customs.

Both stories illuminate the tension between individual desires and societal expectations, inviting readers to reflect on the broader implications of tradition and change. "The Lottery" critiques the collective adherence to outdated practices, while "The Story of an Hour" highlights personal liberation as a path to self-discovery. Together, these works emphasize the necessity of questioning and reevaluating traditions to foster a more just and equitable society.

In conclusion, literary theories such as Reader Response, Deconstruction, and Ethical theory offer valuable frameworks for analyzing texts and their reflections on society. By engaging with these theories, readers gain insight into the complexities of human nature and the evolving nature of societal norms. Through literature, we are urged to reconsider our place within the traditions of our society, ultimately applying literary themes to real-life situations. As societies change, these works remind us of the importance of adapting traditions to prevent them from becoming harmful or destructive.

Did you like this example?

306

16