Cultural Borders: Stories of Commitment

Stories in literature reflect societal values and the personal challenges faced by their characters. Two such narratives, Amy Tan's "Two Kinds" from "The Joy Luck Club" and Thomas King's "Borders," delve into the intricate theme of commitment and the pursuit of personal dreams. These stories illuminate the idea that while talent can be beneficial, it is the determination and perseverance of individuals that truly pave the path to success. Commitment, as depicted in these tales, is not merely about achieving greatness but also about overcoming internal and external conflicts that threaten to derail one's journey.

Commitment and the American Dream

The concept of the American Dream, the belief that anyone in the United States can achieve success through hard work, is a prevalent theme in both "Two Kinds" and "Borders." In Tan's "Two Kinds," we meet the protagonist, Jing-Mei, whose mother, Suyuan, is resolute in her belief that her daughter can achieve greatness in America. Suyuan's conviction is rooted in her own experiences as a Chinese immigrant who endured significant losses, including the death of her children and husband. She envisions a future for Jing-Mei that is marked by success and recognition, believing that with unwavering commitment, her daughter can fulfill this vision. Suyuan's relentless encouragement for Jing-Mei to pursue excellence, whether in academics or music, underscores the notion that anyone can rise to prominence in America, irrespective of their background.

Similarly, in King's "Borders," Letitia exemplifies the spirit of determination as she embarks on a journey to Salt Lake City. At just seventeen, she demonstrates a remarkable commitment to her own aspirations, undeterred by the opinions of others. Her ability to cross the border and establish a new life for herself is a testament to the idea that success is attainable through personal resolve and hard work. Letitia's story reinforces the belief that the American Dream is within reach for those who are willing to pursue it with dedication and tenacity.

Conflicts and the Journey to Success

Both "Two Kinds" and "Borders" explore the conflicts that arise when individuals strive to achieve their dreams. In "Two Kinds," the central conflict is between Jing-Mei and her mother, Suyuan. While Suyuan is determined to mold her daughter into a prodigy, Jing-Mei resists, convinced that she lacks the inherent talent required to meet her mother's expectations. Suyuan's insistence on hard work and perseverance clashes with Jing-Mei's belief that talent is a prerequisite for success. This tension highlights the broader theme that commitment and effort, rather than innate ability, are the keys to achieving one's goals.

In "Borders," the conflicts are both personal and societal. Letitia's mother faces a confrontation with border guards over her refusal to declare citizenship in either Canada or the United States, insisting instead on her Blackfoot identity. This conflict illustrates the struggle between individual identity and societal expectations. Letitia's mother's unwavering pride and determination to assert her heritage symbolize a broader resistance against societal norms that attempt to erase or diminish cultural identity. Despite the challenges they face, Letitia and her mother exemplify the power of perseverance in overcoming obstacles and asserting their rightful place in society.

The Role of Perseverance

Perseverance and hard work emerge as central themes in both narratives, underscoring the idea that success is attainable through dedication and effort. In "Two Kinds," despite Jing-Mei's initial reluctance to embrace her mother's aspirations, the story ultimately reveals the potential for growth and achievement when one commits to a goal. Suyuan's belief in her daughter's potential, even in the absence of apparent talent, underscores the transformative power of perseverance.

Similarly, in "Borders," Letitia's journey to Salt Lake City is a testament to the rewards of determination. Her ability to navigate the challenges of crossing the border and establishing a new life exemplifies the notion that success is not solely determined by external circumstances but by one's inner resolve to overcome adversity. Letitia's story serves as a reminder that personal commitment and hard work can lead to a fulfilling and prosperous life.

Conclusion

In conclusion, both "Two Kinds" and "Borders" offer profound insights into the role of commitment and perseverance in the pursuit of personal dreams. These narratives demonstrate that while talent can be advantageous, it is the unwavering determination and hard work of individuals that ultimately lead to success and fulfillment. The characters in these stories navigate complex conflicts, both internal and external, as they strive to achieve their aspirations. Through their journeys, Tan and King illustrate the enduring power of the human spirit to overcome obstacles and realize the potential for greatness within each of us. As readers, we are reminded that the path to personal fulfillment is not defined solely by talent but by the commitment to pursue our dreams with unwavering dedication.

Did you like this example?

372

20