The Dreamlike Journey of Young Goodman Brown

Dreams and demons dance through Brown's forest night, where Hawthorne explores conscience's darkest corners. Born in Salem, Massachusetts, Hawthorne was deeply influenced by his Puritan heritage, which is reflected in his writing. He changed his last name to distance himself from his past, suggesting a desire to escape the shadow of his ancestry. This theme of escaping reality is mirrored in Goodman Brown's eerie journey into the forest, which blurs the line between dream and reality. This essay argues that Goodman Brown's journey is a dream, serving as a narrative device to explore his inner turmoil and the nature of his faith.

A Dream or Reality?

Goodman Brown, a devout man living in a Puritan society, experiences a profound crisis of faith during his journey into the forest, which unfolds in a dreamlike state.

Initially, he is a man of unwavering belief, trusting in God and the righteousness of those around him. Hawthorne sets the scene with Goodman Brown bidding farewell to his wife, Faith, on the streets of Salem village. Her mention of dreams at the onset of the story foreshadows the surreal experience that follows. Hawthorne writes, "What a wretch am I to leave her on such an errand! She talks of dreams, too" (line 20). This line highlights Goodman Brown's internal conflict and the unease that accompanies him on his nightmarish journey.

As Goodman Brown ventures deeper into the forest, his faith is tested. He encounters an older traveler with a serpent-like staff, a symbol often associated with the devil. Despite the traveler's offer to give him the staff, Goodman Brown refuses, recognizing it as a symbol of evil. This encounter underscores the dreamlike quality of the journey, where symbols and subconscious fears manifest in tangible forms. As R.H. Robinson notes in "The Vision of Goodman Brown," the devil's speech mirrors Goodman Brown's own naive understanding of sin, suggesting that the journey is a projection of his inner doubts and fears rather than a literal encounter with evil.

The Subconscious Forest

Hawthorne's description of the forest as a "dreary road" with "gloomiest trees" and "innumerable trunks" (lines 27-30) creates an unsettling atmosphere, reflecting Goodman Brown's troubled state of mind. This setting symbolizes a descent from the conscious world into the subconscious, where Goodman Brown's perceptions are distorted. As Reginald Cook observes in "The Forest of Goodman Brown's Night," Goodman Brown transitions from a conscious reality into a subconscious one, where his vision is clouded, and his senses are unreliable.

Within this subconscious realm, Goodman Brown hears voices, including that of his wife, Faith. These voices, described as coming from "a cloud of night," further blur the line between reality and illusion. Hawthorne's portrayal of these voices as the congregation of the church suggests that Goodman Brown's spiritual community is intertwined with the dark forest, emphasizing his internal struggle to discern truth from fabrication.

The Symbolism of the Journey

Goodman Brown's journey is rich with symbolic imagery that reinforces its dreamlike quality. The vision of a devilish Indian lurking behind every tree and the appearance of an older version of himself waiting in the forest represent his subconscious fears and insecurities. The older traveler, who resembles Goodman Brown "in expression than features" (line 43), symbolizes the duality within Goodman Brown—the conflict between his outward righteousness and his inner doubts.

As Goodman Brown continues his journey, his subconscious mind becomes increasingly disoriented. He struggles to find a way out of the forest, symbolizing his inability to escape his own doubts and fears. Hawthorne writes, "Too far! too far,’ exclaimed the goodman, unconsciously resuming his walk" (line 61), illustrating Goodman Brown's lack of control over his actions and his entrapment within his subconscious mind.

Conclusion: The Haunting Legacy

In conclusion, Nathaniel Hawthorne's "Young Goodman Brown" is a masterful exploration of the subconscious, using the dreamlike journey as a vehicle to examine the complexities of faith and doubt. From the beginning to the end of the story, Hawthorne provides ample evidence to support the thesis that Goodman Brown's experience is a dream, reflecting his internal struggle rather than an external reality. The dream haunts Goodman Brown for the rest of his life, leaving him isolated and unable to distinguish between what is real and what is imagined. Through this narrative, Hawthorne delves into the human psyche, questioning the nature of belief and the impact of doubt on one's perception of the world.

Did you like this example?

1295

54