Marigolds by Eugenia Collier

In Eugenia W. Collier's short story "Marigolds," the protagonist, Lizbeth, undergoes a pivotal transformation from childhood innocence to the cusp of adulthood during the tumultuous era of The Great Depression. Set against a backdrop of economic hardship and emotional turmoil, the narrative explores how a seemingly trivial act of destruction becomes a catalyst for Lizbeth's self-awareness and maturity. Through the symbolic marigolds, Collier delves into themes of innocence, poverty, and the complexities of growing up. This essay will analyze how Lizbeth's actions reflect her transition from naivety to a more mature understanding of her world.

Childlike Naivety

At the story's outset, Lizbeth is characterized by her childlike innocence, which is vividly depicted through her interactions with Mrs. Lottie's marigolds. Alongside her friends, Lizbeth engages in juvenile antics, such as throwing stones at the flowers, oblivious to the pain they may cause the elderly woman. This behavior is encapsulated in her mocking chant, "Old witch, fell in a ditch, picked up a penny and thought she was rich!" (Collier 3). This childish rhyme underscores Lizbeth's immaturity and lack of empathy at this stage in her life. She is unaware of the significance these marigolds hold for Mrs. Lottie, representing a sense of beauty and hope amidst the bleakness of their environment.

Lizbeth's carefree nature is further illustrated by her reminiscence of childhood adventures: "I was still child enough to scamper along with the group over rickety fences and through bushes that tore our already raggedy clothes…the girls in faded dresses that were too long or too short…" (Collier 2). Her nostalgia for these moments highlights her innocence and the freedom she associates with her younger years. At this point, Lizbeth is shielded from the harsh realities of life, including the implications of wearing ragged clothing in a society that values appearances. The narrative's use of past tense signals a change in Lizbeth's perspective, suggesting that she is recounting these memories from a more enlightened standpoint.

Awakening to Harsh Realities

The turning point in Lizbeth's development occurs when she overhears a distressing conversation between her parents about their financial struggles, prompting her father to break down in tears. This moment shatters Lizbeth's sheltered worldview, as she confronts the stark reality of her family's poverty for the first time. In this moment of vulnerability, Lizbeth is overwhelmed by emotions: "the need for her mother who was never there, the hopelessness of her poverty and degradation, the bewilderment of being neither child nor woman and yet both at once, the fear unleashed by my father’s tears" (Collier 4). These feelings culminate in a destructive impulse, leading her to ravage Mrs. Lottie's marigolds.

The act of destroying the marigolds symbolizes Lizbeth's loss of innocence. The flowers, once a target of her childish pranks, now represent the fragility of beauty and hope in a world marred by suffering. By lashing out at the marigolds, Lizbeth is, in essence, rejecting the naive joys of childhood and confronting the harshness of her reality. This pivotal moment marks the beginning of her emotional and intellectual growth, as she starts to comprehend the complexities of her circumstances and the impact of her actions on others.

The Beginning of Compassion

Following the destruction of the marigolds, Lizbeth experiences a profound realization that signals her transition into maturity. She reflects, "the years have put words to the things I knew at that moment, and as I look back upon it, I know that that moment marked the end of innocence…in that humiliating moment I looked beyond myself and into the depths of another person. This was the beginning of compassion, and one cannot have both compassion and innocence" (Collier 5). This introspective moment reveals that Lizbeth has gained a new understanding of empathy and responsibility. She acknowledges that her actions have consequences and that true maturity involves recognizing and respecting the feelings of others.

The narrative underscores that with the loss of innocence comes the acquisition of compassion—a key component of adulthood. Lizbeth's transformation is complete as she learns to balance personal desires with an awareness of the broader human experience. By embracing this newfound compassion, Lizbeth accepts her role in a world where she can no longer remain oblivious to the suffering around her.

Conclusion: A New Perspective

In conclusion, Eugenia W. Collier's "Marigolds" poignantly captures Lizbeth's journey from innocence to maturity through the symbolic destruction of marigolds. Initially characterized by childlike naivety, Lizbeth's experiences lead her to confront the harsh realities of poverty and emotional turmoil. The act of destroying the marigolds becomes a turning point, signaling the end of her innocence and the beginning of a compassionate understanding of the world. Through this transformation, Lizbeth embodies the complexities of growing up, illustrating that true maturity involves not only gaining knowledge but also developing empathy and responsibility. As Lizbeth navigates the challenges of her environment, she emerges with a deeper awareness of herself and the world around her, symbolizing the universal journey from childhood to adulthood.

Did you like this example?

743

39