Silent Struggles: Power and Choice in Hemingway’s White Elephants

Sunlight glints off white hills as a couple's conversation masks deeper currents of power, choice, and silent desperation. Set against the backdrop of a train station in Spain, the narrative unfolds with an American girl and a Spanish-speaking man engaging in a conversation laden with subtext and tension. The story revolves around an impending decision regarding an operation, which is implied to be an abortion. This decision becomes a pivotal point that could dictate the future of their relationship. Hemingway uses the power dynamics between the characters, linguistic barriers, and alcohol consumption to underscore the challenges they face in addressing the truth of their situation.

This essay delves into how these elements contribute to the story’s central themes.

The Landscape of Silence and Symbolism

The relationship between the characters is characterized by silence, superficial conversations, and alcohol consumption as a means of avoiding deeper issues. When the girl whimsically notes that the hills resemble white elephants, it metaphorically highlights the unspoken tension between them—the proverbial "elephant in the room." The description of the landscape as both fertile and barren alludes to the pregnancy that lies at the core of their silent conflict. Additionally, the couple's choice to remain in the shade, avoiding the sun's glare, symbolizes their reluctance to face the stark reality of their situation. This avoidance is further emphasized when their attempt to address the issue quickly devolves into bickering, illustrating their inability to communicate effectively.

Dominance and Decision-Making

Hemingway skillfully illustrates the power imbalance between the couple through the man's dominance in decision-making. For instance, when he asks, "Do you want it with water?" he immediately answers for both, asserting control over even minor choices (Mays 635). This pattern of behavior extends to the more significant decision regarding the operation. The man attempts to persuade the girl by trivializing the procedure, suggesting that life can return to normal afterward. His use of a nickname, "Jig," introduces a false sense of intimacy, masking the underlying manipulation. Although he superficially offers her the choice, his insistence reveals a subtle form of coercion aimed at guiding her decision to align with his desires.

Communication Breakdown and Emotional Manipulation

The girl's attempts at small talk, such as her comment on the drink's licorice taste, are met with the man's irritation, reflecting his unwillingness to engage in genuine conversation. Her efforts to maintain a semblance of normalcy are thwarted by his refusal to confront the core issues in their relationship. As the man continues to downplay the operation's significance, the girl becomes increasingly skeptical about the possibility of happiness and stability. Hemingway's narrative technique allows readers to perceive the girl's internal conflict through her observations of the lush landscape, which contrasts with the bleakness of her relationship. The man’s manipulation is further evident when he claims that they can have a fulfilling life even after the operation, leveraging her emotions to achieve his objective.

The Illusion of Choice and Freedom

Throughout the story, the themes of choice, relationship, and freedom are interwoven, with the man ostensibly sympathizing with the girl while simultaneously advocating for the abortion to evade responsibility. His dual desire to be with her while pushing for the procedure highlights the paradox of his intentions. By attempting to dominate the girl's opinion, he inadvertently prompts her to question the stability and authenticity of their relationship. The luggage, which the man carries to the train, symbolizes the burden of the decision that weighs heavily on them. His moment of introspection, as he surveys the seemingly normal surroundings, underscores his internal turmoil and the facade of normalcy they strive to maintain.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Hemingway's "Hills Like White Elephants" leaves readers with the impression of unresolved tensions and an uncertain future for the couple. The story's exploration of power dynamics, communication breakdown, and emotional manipulation provides a poignant commentary on the complexities of human relationships. The lack of a definitive decision underscores the fragility of their connection, as they continue to mask their true emotions and avoid confronting the life-altering situation before them. By delving into these themes, Hemingway invites readers to reflect on the intricacies of choice and the impact of unspoken truths in the dynamics of relationships.

Did you like this example?

525

28