Female Literary Voices in Colonial America

Introduction

The theme of women's unequal treatment in literature is as old as the English language itself, reflecting societal norms that have long placed women in subordinate roles. Within "The Concise Heath Anthology of American Literature: Volume I Beginnings to 1865," Anne Bradstreet's poem "The Prologue [To Her Book]" offers a glimpse into the challenges faced by female writers in a male-dominated society. However, the anthology could benefit from the inclusion of Susanna Rowson's "Charlotte Temple," a novel that more comprehensively explores the broader theme of women's unequal treatment.

This essay will argue that while Bradstreet's poem provides valuable insight into the personal struggles of a female writer, Rowson's novel offers a more extensive critique of the societal constraints placed on women, making it a more fitting addition to the anthology.

Anne Bradstreet's "The Prologue": A Personal Struggle for Recognition

In "The Prologue," Anne Bradstreet candidly addresses the challenges she faces as a female poet in a patriarchal society. The first four stanzas of the poem reveal her awareness of the limited subjects deemed appropriate for women writers, as she contrasts her work with the religious epics of Guillaume de Salluste du Bartas. Bradstreet acknowledges the societal expectation that women should focus on domestic tasks, yet she asserts the value of her own writing, even if it lacks the grandiose themes celebrated in men's literature. Her poem is a testament to her belief in the legitimacy of her voice, despite accusations that she might plagiarize male authors.

Bradstreet's work is both a personal reflection and a critique of the gendered limitations imposed on women writers. However, it is important to note that her poem primarily focuses on her individual experience and does not delve into the broader implications of gender inequality. Her assertion that women possess the same intellectual capabilities as men remains a powerful statement, yet it is rooted in her personal quest for recognition rather than a comprehensive exploration of women's rights.

Susanna Rowson's "Charlotte Temple": A Broader Perspective

In contrast, Susanna Rowson's "Charlotte Temple" provides a more expansive exploration of the systemic challenges faced by women in the 18th century. The novel follows the tragic story of Charlotte, a young woman seduced by the British soldier Montraville. As Charlotte navigates the complexities of love and betrayal, Rowson illustrates the societal pressures that limit women's autonomy and the consequences of defying these norms.

The novel's plot highlights the lack of support systems for women who deviate from societal expectations. Charlotte's abandonment by Montraville and the subsequent isolation she faces underscore the vulnerability of women in a patriarchal society. Her tragic fate, including her struggles with illness and poverty, serves as a powerful critique of the societal structures that fail to protect women. Rowson's narrative goes beyond individual experience, providing a broader commentary on the systemic inequalities faced by women.

The Case for "Charlotte's Temple" in the Anthology

Incorporating "Charlotte's Temple" into the anthology would offer readers a more comprehensive understanding of the theme of women's unequal treatment. Unlike Bradstreet's poem, which is largely introspective, Rowson's novel presents a narrative that examines the broader societal constraints on women. The novel's depiction of Charlotte's downfall due to societal neglect provides a poignant critique of the gender norms of the time.

Moreover, "Charlotte's Temple" serves as a valuable counterpoint to the other works in the anthology, which often focus on individual struggles rather than systemic issues. By including Rowson's novel, the anthology would offer a more nuanced exploration of how societal expectations and gender roles contribute to women's oppression.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while Anne Bradstreet's "The Prologue [To Her Book]" offers insight into the personal challenges faced by a female writer seeking recognition, Susanna Rowson's "Charlotte Temple" provides a more comprehensive examination of the systemic inequalities faced by women. By exploring the broader societal constraints that limit women's autonomy, Rowson's novel offers a more fitting contribution to "The Concise Heath Anthology of American Literature: Volume I Beginnings to 1865." Including "Charlotte's Temple" would enhance the anthology's exploration of the theme of women's unequal treatment, providing readers with a more thorough understanding of the historical context and the ongoing struggle for gender equality.

Did you like this example?

313

16